Loading...
Adjustment Hearing Case Files_3614 S. Ocean Blvd._20070417_Petition No. 01-07-91 1 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS DECISION ON PETITION FOR VARIANCE Petition No. 01 - - Public Hearing Date April 17, 2007 Town Code Chapter 23 [Signs & Advertising} Sec. 7(c) (1) (c) (a) Petitioner TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH (NEW TOWN HALL ENTRANCE SIGN) Property Address 3614 S. Ocean Blvd. In the above numbered Petition, by vote as shown in the official Minutes and recorded on the reverse side of this orm, it was determined and ordered that the requested variance be granted [ ]; denied [ ]; granted subject to the following conditions and safeguards [ l: In reaching its decision and order, the Board has found /has not found in the case of the above numbered Petition that: 1. Special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure or building involved, and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the same district. 2. The special conditions and circumstances do not result from the action of the applicant. 3. Granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by the ordinance to other lands, structures or buildings in the same district. 4. Literal interpretation of the provisions of this ordinance would deprive the applicant of rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same district under the terms of the ordinance, and would work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant. 5. The reasons set forth in the applicant's petition justify the granting of the variance, and the variance granted is the minimum reasonable variance that will make possible the reasonable use of land, structure or building. 6. Granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the ordinance, and will not be injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. Chapter 30 Zoning Code /Article III; Sec.30- 40(h): A variance, when implemented in accordance with the approval granted by the Board of Adjustment and Appeals, shall run with the land in perpetuity. Unless a lesser time is approved by the Board of Adjustment and Appeals, a variance that is not implemented shall expire eighteen (18) months following approval. Extensions of variance approvals shall not be granted by the Board of Adjustment and Appeals. Board of Adjustment and Appeals Page 2 April 17, 2007 Decision on Petition for Variance No. 01 -07 -91 (Town of Highland Beach) SIGNATURES WRITE "FOR" OR "AGAINST" PETITION NEW TOWH HALL ENTRANCE SIGN. Joseph A. Sarubbi, Chairman Joseph S. Yucht, Vice Chair - /2- Merton Rubin Jack A. Ha n )4-7 i 1 01 I / f ) Pete .rrales �/ Vi i/ „ -..S– Anthony PARutolo, Sec. ---/-4,-,-_. ao,„,„z6 V N Theresa M. Colarullo NOTE: ANY PERSON, OR PERSONS, OR ANY TAXPAYER, BOARD, DEPARTMENT, OFFICER, BOARD OR BUREAU OF THE TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH AGGRIEVED BY A DECISION OF THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS, MAY, WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS AFTER RENDITION OF THE DECISION OF THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS, APPLY TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW PURSUANT TO FLORIDA STATUTE 163.250. C Attest: A / C i /� i Date: l'7 0: cc: Buil� Official f s e .. ir TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH `` �► ' . mss; BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT RECEIVED ''.•,F,om0� PETITION DO NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE - FOR OFFICE USE ONE.! 1 b LO07 PETITION NO. ° I — O 61 l 1 ` AND BEACH BUILDING DEPARTMENT FEE PAID /RECEIPT NO. DATE SET FOR PUBLIC HEARING The owner or his agent has has not submitted a petition regarding the subject property within the last year. NOTE: Ordinance No. 442 Fees: Variance and /or Appeal to Board of Adjustment $500. BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT - TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH, FLORIDA OWNERS NAME Town of Highland Beach PHONE 561 - 278 -4548 OWNERS ADDRESS 3614 S. Ocean Blvd. Highland Beach, FL 33487 AUTHORIZED AGENT Dale S. Sugerman PHONE 561 -278 -4548 AUTHORIZED AGENT ADDRESS 3614 S. Ocean Blvd. Highland Beach, FL 33487 request that a determination be made by the Board of Adjustment of the Town of Highland Beach for the following Variance under Section(s) 23 -7 (c) (1) (c) (a) of Chapter 30 of the Code of Ordinances of the Town of Highland Beach. The description of the subject property is as follows: ADDRESS 3614 S. Ocean Blvd. Highland Beach, FL 33487 LOT 0200 BLOCK 004 SUBDIVISION Boca Raton Lagoon LOT SIZE 4.4 Acres +/- PRESENT ZONING GSD PRESENT USE Government Service District (GSD) 1. Present Structures (type) Plywood Site Identification sign 2. The proposed use will be Permanent structural site identification sign 3. If this Petition is granted, the effect will be to Provide an architecturally pleasing, and highly visible, Town municipal complex identification sign -brief description - i.e., to reduce side yard from 7 -1/2' to 2') 'TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH ( .■9 .BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT PETITION Page 2-of 3 4. For a variance to be favorably considered, the Board of Adjustment must find that the following four requirements have been met. After each paragraph, state fully your reasons justifying the granting of this variance. (a) That special conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar to the land, structure, or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the same district; The property development. regulations for the GSD zoning district are either "N /A" or "TBD ". Town Hall is the only public use building in the GSD zone and therefore it is in a unique situation which is not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings. (b) That the special conditions and circumstances do not result from the actions of the applicant; The applicant does not need or desire to erect a permanent sign which exceeds the square footage of the sign code. The size of the proposed sign is to meet the needs of the general population of the community, many of whom have difficulty seeing. (c) That granting the variance requested will not confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by this ordinance to other lands, buildings or structures in the same district; This is the only facility located in the district, so no other applicant could .ask for, nor would they be denied, the granting of a variance. (d) That literal interpretation of the provisions of this ordinance would deprive the applicant of the rights commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same district under the terms of this ordinance and would work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant. N /A. There are no other potential applicants who would or could enjoy any rights under the GSD zoning district. • EC es IF JM! 1 8 7007 eg�`e � cl tu�.jj N G �u b 1 11 „ i 0 �'1 BUILDING' ,2 s mT (ENT TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH POARD OF ADJUSTMENT PETITION Page 3 of 3 5. Has any previous application or appeal been filed within the last year in connection with these premises? (Yes) (No) X If so, briefly state the nature of the application or appeal. Following are the names and addresses of all owners of property within a distance of 300 feet from the outside edges of the property involved in this petition. Petitioner guarantees that such owners of property will be legally notified by certified mail of the hearing date and the nature of this petition, through a copy of the petition, and will provide satisfactory affidavit proof of notification, including certified mail receipts, in advance of any scheduled public hearing, as provided below. Name Please see attached sheet (Attach extra sheet if necessary) The undersigned hereby attest to the fact that all statements_ contained in this document are true. Town of Highland Beach 0 OWNER AUTHORIZED A NT Owner must supply authorized agent notarized letter attesting to same. Sworn and subscrib d before me this / m day of rout < , J rVED 4E REE . . E N••tary Public „ ' JANE P. DILLON r . ■•■ ..: MY COMMISSION # DD 285248 ‘ EXPIRES: January 27, 2008 ' Banned Thru Nary Public Underwrfters PROPOSED TOWN HALL SIGN ry E \ Property owners within 300 feet of Town Hall property: J!Ar. 1 a ?c1)7 West Side of SR AlA Donald D. Gray 3567 S. Ocean Blvd. (0270) Roger A Quinn 3569 S. Ocean Blvd. (0280) Highland Trust 190 Roxborough Drive 3571 S. Ocean Blvd. Ontario, Canada M4W1X8 (0320) Ray Anthony Lewis, Jr. 3573 S. Ocean Blvd. (0290) Lynn Tilton 3575 S. Ocean Blvd. (0300) Stuart and Roni Doppelt 3615 S. Ocean Blvd. (0210) Fred Hassan 3617 S. Ocean Blvd. 5 Pine Valley Way (0250) Florham Park, NJ 07932 -2700 William L. Knight 3621 S. Ocean Blvd. (0170) Ocean Grande Place Ocean Grande Place HOA 3620 S. Ocean Blvd. (0020) Richard S. Bailyn 3622 S. Ocean Blvd. (0010) • Cary J. Hoffman 3624 S. Ocean Blvd D (0020) Arthur Kwait JAN 1 8 2007 3626 S. Ocean Blvd. (0030) HIGHLAND !MACH BUILDING DEPARTMENT Sergei M. Malikhin 3628 S. Ocean Blvd. (0040) Eva San Filippo 3630 S. Ocean Blvd. (0050) Davis Malcolm 3632 S. Ocean Blvd. (0060) Michael J. DeSalvo 3634 S. Ocean Blvd. (0070) Perry Bard 3636 S. Ocean Blvd. (0080) Alan Freedman 3638 S. Ocean Blvd. (0090) Harry Mondestin 12 Timber Knoll Drive 3640 S. Ocean Blvd. Washington Crossing, PA 18977 (0100) Patricia C. Weiss 3642 S. Ocean Blvd. (0110) Naomi G. Bass 3644 S. Ocean Blvd. (0120) Marcia Rymer 3646 S. Ocean Blvd. (0130) Josephine Rybka 130 Springdale Dr. #300 3648 S. Ocean Blvd. Akron, OH 44333 (0140) Peter J. Belmonte EIVED 3650 S. Ocean Blvd. (0150) JAN 1 8 2007 Cynthia Jakeway HIGHLAND BEACH 3652 S. Ocean Blvd. 91,JILDING DEPARTMENT (0160) Richard J. Kerr 3654 S. Ocean Blvd. (0170) Highland Beach Club 3600 South Ocean Blvd. Attn: Paul L. Wilkis, Property Manager Toscana North Condominium Association, Inc. 3700 South Ocean Blvd. Attn: Henry Harvey, Property Manager Toscana West Condominium Association, Inc. 3720 South Ocean Blvd. Attn: Wayne Koccak, Property Manager • • A (J1 . . crl I }) .,:, '.,sr O ✓ t, w _, IV 0 iii " i N . r O p vD w 0 c Z - o C z 13 0 Z Z w n m CD ch a _ 1, X > Na c� I, 1 . r- _ ,; #j .. • o Z , ,,., w 0 (''' • m co 3 Z^ I"— ° -ri • tE� rn rn '") ¢ = 1. T e ' c nN N do t N x . 'air c o m c o "A " ,01 ...' o N T J // //�� i. < a C N F. t// .. ■ 1 a Q k O y M r n � ' ' d o — i l _ 1 � _ 7 0 ul r c �. Fm a uN n° ZH ; 1 a a N rn 0 0 Z a M - nJ nnn a zc x 0 i7,-,a. oc m I'll O 'r 'G tp s T , m o m o C —i �. 3 Z N 5 y hl pa T 4 N yT f 1 N � i D 0.. ri cn N Z COLOR 4.5 in. flat cut metal letters painted black SQUARE FOOT SCHEDULE: 15 °X15° logo painted to match the city's CALCULATIONS: Total sq. ft. 50 color specifications. • STRUCTURAL NOTES: ELECTRICAL NOTES: GOVERNING CODE: 2004 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, ASCE 7 -02 USING V= 140MPH, EXPOSURE 'C ALL COMPONENTS U/L USTED AND SHALL COMPLY WITH NEC 2002 AND 1 =0.77, SOLID SIGN METHOD (Cf=1.2) . THE BUILDING CODE STATED HEREIN. ELECTRICAL INFORMATION PROVIDED AS REFERENCE ONLY AND WILL BE INSTALLED BY A LICENSED SIGN GROUNDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH NEC 250. CONTRACTOR. NO ENGINEERING CERTIFICATION IS OFFERED WITH ANY ELECTIRICAL INFORMATION ALL BREAKER AND TIMING DEVICES SHALL BE IDENTIFIED AT TIME OF CONTAINED HEREIN. INSTALLATION. ALL ALUMINUM WILL BE 6063 T -6 OR BETTER. EXISTING PRIMARY BY OTHERS, ANCHORS TO BE ITW BUILDEX, ELCO TAPCON, POWERS, OR MFR. RATED EQUAL, 1 - 20 AMP CIRCUIT WITH *12 THIN WIRE MINIMUM EMBEDMENT DEPTH DOES NOT INCLUDE STUCCO, FINISHES, OR SHIM SPACING. 1 - 20 AMP DISCONNECT SWITCH PER CIRCUIT. STRUCTURAL BOLTS TO BE A -325, GRADE 5 BREAKER # LOCATED IN REAR OF LOCATION. HOST STRUCTURE IS BY OTHERS AND SHALL BE DESIGNED TO CARRY LOADS BY PROPOSED SIGN. n - ' QQ REMARKS DRWR CMKD DATE a Ilt T 9 INITISSUE - FLB • S /GNS /c1NS ENGINEERING 6 > m g T • n - - Full Service Si Company r o z N e.a 9 �L. EXPRESS® > �(� In ? - 561-347-1517 ° 1 l ° s s/aw.s 1io . :. moo f 160 SW 12th AVENUE *106 A t 7 !' - 325 NE Spanish Rlver B,vC. g.. -x , +) m MI a R4.2 1 Boca Raton, FL 33431 DEERFIELD BEACH, FL 33442 z 1 2 lQPAOa1CFONVngtE 01 1N1YTNgIfWMfxNb4 a0E liw(L off- D ■ oEF K,ua.a�amaawr .aonu Town of Highl Beach R+' ( 354 -0660 FAX: (954) 354-0443 D Io1K0ooYFN1MEMO,ttIW,Ifo-=',E0u QAY G ,CM. m O d o $ WWW.ENGEXP.COM t \'.._ •-■ rn 11111111111111111111111111111111111 Highland Bch., FL. A FRANK L. BENNARDO, P I INNOVATION y< J Page 1 of 1 .a_a11,5111%..A.,11/16 1_,Apl GJJ . ' . 7:- '-1- ---- ENGINEERING E A FRANK L. BENNARDO, P.E., INC. INNOVATION - ------- 160 SW 12 Ave, #106, Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 (954) 354-0660 FAX:(954) 354-0443 Sign Post & Footing Calculator ' Date: November 27, 2006 Job #: save (/1_4) Contractor: Bignsations HELP: lig Project: Highlands Beath Monument fill im s eed Soil Type 0) ExpeSUre gji t 4. Sand III til d P 113106 ' 140 1% 11 1 00 1 0 wIngtjoInnor Sign Width 1 0 Presets (click) % 0 fen 110.41)No."="91 Footer Depth: PM' PRI 0 FL Contour Map _ rov ; ti 10.00 ft # # 4.00 ft. 40 US CentOur MaP . 0. go.Footing? r' - - ti Minimum 4 poorer 1 WIdth: ussumoissaaaarainie** Vertical 0 ft 4 in 1 Contini.rous Height Known min post spacing 5.00 ft. .... Unbraced Length I 1 m —- CAUTION: Milninlurn post o 48.0 In. Bottom spacing must be at least 0'-4". If actual post snacIn IS Number Posts? Height Smaller than 0'-4", increase ----5----,..,., 4.00 ft. post/foot make a = Continuous footing. material PeSt Steel Shape Sched 40 A 1,, 4 ,. : ( A36 Steel vl ( Pipe vi r 3 Schad 40 ,Ir'l , l'i , '"* 7.4 "" 6"P: 7,1 _ _ , 1, *Pi144&ATh-l'.:` Pressure moment at Orade s _ Sin 1.72 ltk 3 fe ''?,' i ''0 i '..--.) Mod sched 40 ,...:,,, s ched Ho 1 0 ft * „,..) k Lit m a IOW* 3-1 IC- fl--rEte,!,'!:teralat 20.9 pat 0.55 k-ft ASOE7-02 Calcs The total force on Below Grade Coles: Kh=0.575 each post is 104.28 lb Soil Friction Angle, Phi= 41 Deg BELOW GRADE RESULTS k41=0.85 The moment arm Soil Unit Weight, Gamma= 130 pcf V=140 MPH above grade is 4.50 ft. kp..(i+sin(phl))/(1-sin(phl))=1.638 Minimum Footer Width: 0s.4 taz 0.77 The critical point of your 4....h= 1 8.87 psf structure Is at ground Moment frorn Soil mp.si/6GarrirnaHiA3wkp POST RESULTS G=0.85 level. Moment from Resultant Ma= lt(d+H) Min Saw 0.31 In A 3 Cf= 1.3 M=FS Depth Post/Footer 11=4.00 ft. Shanew 3 Scheel 40 P=d_h*G*Cf M=0.55 k-ft Minimum WIcith: M % Ut11=18% P=20.9 psf F= 21.6 ksi w=6R(d+H)/(KPGammaliA3)=0'-4" center notes here. Engineer Seal: Notes: Calculations per ASCE 7-02 & valid for use with the 2004 Florida Building Code & the 2003 international Building Code. Results shall be reviewed and approved by a 11/27/2006 professional engineer and are only valid with original signature and raised engineer seal. Use of thls calculator is by permission of Frank L. Bennardo, P.E., inc. and is subject to Frank L. Ete;;;rclo, P.E revision and revocation without notice. Calculator concept is protected under copyright PE PL465491Cert Auth 9885 laws & shall not b c reproduced or copied In any way. Copyright 2006 Frank L. Bennardo, P.E., Inc. & •ElsiGINEERING v2.5 11413/06 EXPY=?ESS . http://www.engexp.com/calculators/sign.cfm 11/27/2006 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS ATTENDANCE FOR WORKSHOP MEETING MARCH 30, 2007 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS IN ATTENDANCE ABSENT JOSEPH A. SARUBBI, CH. JOSEPH S. YUCHT, V.CH. MERTIN RUBIN JACK A. HALPERN PETER CORRALES ANTHONY P. RUOTOLO THERESA M. COLARULLO ` Boca Raton, FL - BocaNews.com - events, education, real estate, society and arts - Boca ... Page 1 of 2 Home 1 Local News 1 Sports I Society 1 Schools 1 Business I Columnists 1 Classifieds 1 Advertising 1 Contact Us 1 Subscribe BOCA Raton New, SUBSCRIBE BocaNe ws. cam �°'` Boca N ews ARCHIVE 0 W / �► 0 This Aftemoon: Sunny with a high of SEARCH: 1/ 80 SIGN UP OUR FREE OR CLASSIFIEDS - ANNOUCEMENTS -LEGAL NOTICES Get a EMAILED NEWSPAPER EMAIL ADDRESSS: 101 Legal Notices 61 ju SUBMIT 1 IMPORTANT NOTICE ,fix ` A t - CLASSIFIEDS THE CITY OF BOCA RATON WATER CUSTOMERS TO MAINTAIN THE WATER QUALITY IN THE CITY'S WATER SYSTEM, THE CITY OF BOCA .. Merchandise RATON UTILITY SERVICES DEPARTMENT VMLL TEMPORARILY MODIFY Real Estate THE DISINFECTION PROCESS USED BY THE WATER TREATMENT Cale Employment FACILITY. THE CITY WILL BE USING A SOMEWHAT STRONGER DISINFECTION PROCESS TO PRODUCE FREE CHLORINE RESIDUAL _ """"i' Automotive INSTEAD OF A CHLORAMINE RESIDUAL FOR A TWO -WEEK PERIOD and more... BEGINNING ON APRIL 8, 2007. THE CHANGE IN THE TREATMENT WILL LOCAL NEWS PROVIDE ADDITIONAL PROTECTION AGAINST BACTERIA AND IS BEING DONE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CITY'S DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM News MAINTENANCE PROGRAM. CUSTOMERS SERVED BY THE CITY OF Sports BOCA RATON UTILITY SERVICES MAY NOTICE A SLIGHT CHLORINE _ Society TASTE OR ODOR IN THE TAP WATER DURING THIS PERIOD. HOWEVER, T y THESE TEMPORARY CONDITIONS WILL NOT CAUSE ADVERSE HEALTH Schools EFFECTS. USERS OF HOME KIDNEY DIALYSIS MACHINES, OWNERS OF �t�jtt�Y Business TROPICAL FISH AQUARIUMS, AND MANAGERS OF STORES AND k/ RESTAURANTS WITH FISH AND SHELLFISH HOLDING TANKS ARE Ruo>tt t Yntar Masora Editorial ADVISED THAT THE METHODS FOR TESTING AND REMOVING FREE Went Earl, Grand mama island CHLORINE RESIDUALS DIFFER FROM THOSE USED FOR CHLORAMINE Weekend RESIDUALS. BOTH TYPES OF RESIDUALS MAY ADVERSELY AFFECT Columnists USERS OF KIDNEY DIALYSIS MACHINES AND MAY BE TOXIC TO FISH Directory AND AQUATIC ANIMALS IF NOT TREATED PROPERLY. WE ENCOURAGE Archives CUSTOMERS WHO MAY BE AFFECTED BY THIS CHANGE TO SEEK PROFESSIONAL ADVICE. THE CITY WILL CONTINUE TO FLUSH FIRE HYDRANTS DURING THIS PERIOD. CUSTOMERS MAY NOTICE FLOWING GET THE BOCA RATON WATER IN STREETS AND SWALES, LOCALIZED LOWER WATER NEWS PRESSURES AND A SLIGHT DISCOLORATION OF THEIR TAP WATER. In the Mail AGAIN, THESE TEMPORARY CONDITIONS WILL NOT CAUSE ADVERSE HEALTH EFFECTS. IF YOU SHOULD NEED FURTHER INFORMATION ON In your Inbox THIS CHANGE IN THE WATER TREATMENT PROCESS, PLEASE CALL Customer Service UTILITY SERVICES AT 581 -338 -7310. Publish: April 03, 2007 ADVERTISING Proof of Publication: FP077255 Boca Raton News Online Media Kit NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ABOUT BOCA RATON Called By: Census Data Joseph A. Sarubbi 3 d Demographics Chairman, Board of �' 7 History Adjustment and Appeals Boca Raton Map Town of Highland Beach, Geography Florida 33487 Date: BOLA NEWS RSS Tuesday, April 17, 2007 Time: Local News Immediately following the 9:30 a.m. Quarterly Meeting 0 MY "1'nraocofl Place: Business News Highland Beach tr Y - n - Commission Chambers 3614 S. Ocean Blvd. Highland Beach, Florida 33487 Site Map Subject: http: / /www.bocanews. com/index.php ?src= gendocs &link =101 CLASSIFIEDS- LEGAL %20... 4/3/2007 Boca Raton, FL - BocaNews.com - events, education, real estate, society and arts - Boca ... Page 3 of 3 rescheduled to Monday, April 23, 2007 at the same time and location. Publish: April 13, 2007 Boca Raton News NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Called By: Joseph A. Sarubbi Chairman, Board of Adjustment and Appeals Town of Highland Beach, Florida 33487 Date: Tuesday, April 17, 2007 Time: Immediately following the 9:30 a.m. Quarterly Meeting Place: Highland Beach Commission Chambers 3614 S. Ocean Blvd. Highland Beach, Florida 33487 Subject: TO EXAMINE A PETITION FOR VARIANCE SEEKING RELIEF FROM TOWN CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 23 (SIGNS AND ADVERTISING); SECTION 7(C)(1)(C)(A); FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3614 S. OCEAN BLVD. HIGHLAND BEACH, FL. OWNER: TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH Publish: Tues. April 3, 2007 Fri. April 13, 2007 Boca Raton News ® 2007 Boca Raton News. All rights reserved. .tC0 ( 11-2 S q- /.3- http: / /www.bocanews. com/index.php?src=gendocs&link=101CLASSIFIEDS-LEGAL%20... 4/13/2007