Loading...
Land Development and Planning Project Files_1006 Grand Ct._20201112_Application No. 20-0014DENIED BY: PLANNING BOARD 11.12.2020 APPL. No. 20-0014 TRANSMITTAL FORM REPORT OF REVIEW & ACTION BY PLANNING BOARD Transmit to: Town Planner Ingrid Allen Building Department Date: November 12, 2020 Applicant/Owner: Richard Touchette Property Address: 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, FL 33487 Property Control Number: 24-43-47-09-00-000-0090 Application No. 20-0014 REVIEW GIVEN TO SUBJECT PROPETY D Preliminary Review: D Final Review: [g] Amended Site Plan Review (Application No. 39412) D Other AT THE NOVEMBER 12, 2020, MEETING, THE PLANNING BOARD REVIEWED THE ABOVE MATTER PER THE REQUEST OF THE TOWN PLANNER DA TED SEPTEMBER 29, 2020, AND HEREBY CERTIFIES THAT THE FOLLOWING ACTION WAS TAKEN: [g] Denied D Recommendation to Approve D Approved with Modifications (as noted) D Other: PLEASE TAKE WHATEVER ACTION IS REQUIRED TO COMPLETE THE SUBJECT MATTER, I.E., ISSUE PERMIT, TRANSMIT TO TOWN COMMISSION, RETURN TO APPLICANT, ETC. david axelrod (Nov 12, 2020 15:24 EST) David Axelrod, Chairperson IF THE ABOVE PLANS WERE DENIED OR APPROVED WITH MODIFICATIONS, PLEASE NOTE THE BOARD'S FINDINGS: MOTION: Member Mendelson made a motion to deny the request for an amendment to Development Order Application No. 20-0014 as presented. Member DeMoss seconded the motion. UPON ROLL CALL the motion passed on a 7 to O vote, unanimously. CLERK'S OFFICE USE ONLY: Transmitted to the Building Department: 11/12/2020 1006 Grand Court LLC_ Application No. 20-0014 Richard Touchette 11.12.2020 Mtg Final Audit Report 2020-11-12 Created: 2020-11-12 By: Beverly Wright (bwright@highlandbeach.us) Status: Signed Transaction ID: CBJCHBCAABAAeAZsuwsrDYA-iCXc1_La4x17pELkt9VZ "1006 Grand Court LLC_ Application No. 20-0014 Richard Touc hette 11.12.2020 Mtg" History 'El Document created by Beverly Wright (bwright@highlandbeach.us) 2020-11-12 -7:31 :20 PM GMT-IP address: 12.18.232.162 g Document emailed to david axelrod (dzaxelrod@gmail.com) for signature 2020-11-12 - 7:32:00 PM GMT 'El Email viewed by david axelrod (dzaxelrod@gmail.com) 2020-11-12 -8:23:41 PM GMT-IP address: 66.102.8.13 @e Document e-signed by david axelrod (dzaxelrod@gmail.com) Signature Date: 2020-11-12 -8:24:55 PM GMT -Time Source: server-IP address: 65.34.206.171 0 Agreement completed. 2020-11-12 -8:24:55 PM GMT fJ Adobe Sign PLANNING BOARD STAFF REPORT MEETING OF: NOVEMBER 12, 2020 TO: PLANNING BOARD FROM: INGRID ALLEN, TOWN PLANNER SUBJECT: APPLICATION BY RICHARD TOUCHETTE REQUESTING AN AMENDMENT TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED TEN POST PLATFORM BOAT LIFT (APPLICATION NO. 39412) IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE HEIGHT OF THE BOAT LIFT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1006 GRAND COURT. (APPLICATION NO. 20-0014) Property Owner: 1006 Grand Court LLC 1006 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487 Applicant: Richard Touchette 1006 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487 Property Characteristics: Comprehensive Plan Land Use: Multi Family Low Density Zoning District: Residential Multiple Family Low Density (RML) Parcel PCN#: 24-43-47-09-00-002-0090 I. GENERAL INFORMATION: HIGHLAND BEACH BUILDING DEPARTMENT 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 Ph: (561) 278-4540 Fx: (561) 265-3582 Page 54 Adjacent Properties: PARCEL ZONING DISTRICT FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION North Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density South Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density East Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density West Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density Background: On February 8, 2017, the Planning Board approved a request (Application No. 39412) to install a 40,000 lb., eight (8) post platform boat lift (Attachment No. 1 in the August 13, 2020 Planning Board packet). On October 11, 2017, the Planning Board approved a request (Application No. 39412) to add two (2) additional posts to the previously approved eight (8) post platform boat lift (Attachment No. 2 in the August 13, 2020 Planning Board packet). Note that according to Town electronic records, the Planning Board item packet did not include a boat lift detail sheet (DTL-1). On May 23, 2019, the Town’s Building Official, Jeffrey Massie, issued a Stop Work Order on Permit No. 39412 (Attachment No. 3 in the August 13, 2020 Planning Board packet). On July 9, 2020, the Planning Board continued to the August 13, 2020 meeting (in an effort to have the Applicant reach a compromise with his neighbors), a request to increase the height of the boat lift pilings from four (4) feet above the existing dock decking, as approved on February 8, 2017, to 12 feet above the existing dock decking (Development Order No. 19-0001). On August 13, 2020, the Planning Board disapproved Development Order No. 19-0001. On September 1, 2020, the Town’s Building Official issued a Notice of Violation (NOV) for the boat lift and associated structure/pilings (Attachment No. 1). On September 18, 2020, the Applicant’s attorney requested to postpone violation action (Attachment No. 2). On September 18, 2020, the Town’s Building Official suspended the NOV (Attachment No. 3). II. REQUEST AND ANALYSIS: Page 55 The Applicant is requesting an amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat lift (Application No. 39412). According to the Applicant’s Development Order Application (DO No. 20-0014) they are requesting approval to increase the height of the boat lift pilings to seven (7) feet from the existing dock decking. The boat lift detail (sheet DTL-1) approved by the Planning Board on February 8, 2017 indicates the height of the boat lift pilings and the existing dock pilings at four (4) feet above the existing wood dock. The proposed boat lift detail (sheet DTL-1) provided by the Applicant, reflects the height of the boat lift pilings at seven (7) feet above the existing dock decking. As a result, the proposed boat lift pilings are three (3) feet higher than what was previously approved by the Planning Board. The Applicant has obtained Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) approval to install a boat lift (File No. 50-345492-004-EE). According to FDEP, the proposed request does not require a separate permit or authorization from the US Army Corps of Engineers. The Town Code does not provide a maximum height for dock or lift pilings. Section 30-131 of the Town Code defines “boat lifts” as the bottom of the keel of any boat shall not be hoisted greater than one foot above the minimum seawall elevation and in no case shall the lift be higher than the superstructure of the boat when lifted. In addition, Section 30-68(h) of the Town Code provides the following provisions regarding mooring facilities (Section 30-68(h)(1) of the Town Code indicates that dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, docks and moorings are collectively “mooring facilities”): -Section 30-68(h)(1)(c) They will not create a hazardous interference with navigation (this is addressed below under the Town’s consultant review), endanger life or property, or deny the public reasonable visual access to public waterways. -Section 30-68(h)(4) Shall not cause a hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the adjacent property owners or public reasonable visual access to the public waterway. Pursuant to Section 30-68(h)(3) of the Town Code, the Building Official may request evidence, prepared by a recognized marine expert, demonstrating the proposed mooring facilities will not deny reasonable visual access to public waterways. Accordingly, the Applicant’s plans were reviewed by Applied Technology & Management, Inc. (ATM) a coastal and marine engineering consultant. Dr. Michael G. Jenkins, ATM’s Coastal Engineering Principal, provided a technical review report (Attachment No. 4) which includes the following finding: “Based on the information provided it is undetermined if the new, reduced pile elevations are the minimum required to meet the intent of the structure. However, the elevations as proposed in the revised drawings are generally consistent with standard practice relative to pile height and overall structure elevation required for the lifting of the design vessel.” III. Recommendation Page 56 If the Planning Board decides to approve the Applicant’s request, staff recommends the following conditions which are based on the Applicant’s plan set, date stamped received by the Building Department on October 30, 2020: 1. Following approval by the Planning Board and prior to initiation of construction, the Applicant will be required to obtain a building permit from the Town of Highland Beach Building Department (prior permit No. 39412 expired on May 30, 2020). Plans submitted as part of the building permit shall reflect NAVD-88. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (561) 637-2012 or iallen@highlandbeach.us Ingrid Allen Town Planner Town of Highland Beach Attachments: Application Attachment No. 1 – Town Notice of Violation (NOV) dated September 1, 2020. Attachment No. 2 – Applicant’s request to postpone violation action dated September 18, 2020. Attachment No. 3 – Town suspension of NOV dated September 18, 2020. Attachment No. 4 – ATM review report dated October 23, 2020. Plans FDEP authorization (File No. 50-345492-004-EE) Public Comments August 13, 2020 Planning Board packet for Development Order No. 19-0001 & meeting minutes. July 9, 2020 Planning Board meeting minutes Page 57 Page 58 Page 59 Page 60 Page 61 Page 62 Page 63 Page 64 Page 65 Page 66 Page 67 Page 68 Page 69 Page 70 Page 71 Page 72 ATTACHMENT NO. 1 Page 73 ATTACHMENT NO. 1 Page 74 ATTACHMENT NO. 2 Page 75 September 18, 2020 Ingrid Allen Town Planner Jeff Remas Building Code Official Town of Highland Beach 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, Florida 33487 VIA EMAIL iallen@highlandbeach.us and bco@highlandbeach.us Re: 1006 Grand Court, Town of Highland Beach – Boatlift Pilings Dear Ms. Allen and Mr. Remas: Thank you both for taking the time to speak to me on Wednesday, September 18, 2020. As we discussed, we are diligently moving forward with plans for a boat lift in the exact location as previously approved, but with the pilings significantly shorter than what was constructed. As we discussed, I would provide written notification denoting our progress in hopes that the existing violation can be placed on hold as we diligently work through the application and approval process. To that end, as you can see from the attached, we have revised signed and sealed plans as well as the new DEP permit with the Corps authorization included. This Tuesday, I will be having the required pre-application meeting with Ingrid Allen. Shortly following that pre-application meeting, we will formally submit a Development Order to the Town of Highland Beach for review and ultimate approval. Please accept this email as our formal request to postpone violation action as the Applicant is faithfully and diligently moving through the process to bring the boat lift pilings into compliance. Sincerely, Ele Zachariades Page 76 ATTACHMENT NO. 3 Page 77 Page 78 ATTACHMENT NO. 4 Page 79 APPLIED TECHNOLOGY & MANAGEMENT, INC. 2047 VISTA PARKWAY • SUITE 201 • WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33411 • 561.659.0041 10/23/20 Ingrid Allen Town Planner Town of Highland Beach 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 Re: Technical Review of Proposed Boat Lift – 1006 Grand Court Revised Submission dated 10/14/2020 Town of Highland Beach Ms. Allen, This correspondence is provided as a follow-up response to the technical review previously provided in regard to the proposed boat lift at 1006 Grand Court, Town of Highland Beach. Specifically, this correspondence provides additional review regarding the revised plan drawings received on /14/2020. In general this revised plan is consistent with previous submittals with the exception of a reduced pile and overall structure height. Basis of Review This additional review is narrowly focused on the revisions to the plan as delineated within the revised submission, specifically the change in pile height. The following documents were utilized as a basis for this review: - Engineering drawings of revised lift design (SP, DTL-1, DTL-2) This review was limited to the information as provided above. No additional investigations or studies were conducted. Page 80 Page 2 of 3 APPLIED TECHNOLOGY & MANAGEMENT, INC. Coastal, Environmental, Marine & Water Resources Engineering Drawing Review The following comments are provided regarding the revised design. 1. Sheet SP; General note 4. Note references the North Atlantic Vertical Datum (NAVD- 88). The vertical datum reference shown in sheet DTL-1 is the National Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD-29). NAVD-88 is the current accepted standard reference but is not utilized and NGVD is only utilized in reference to the tide range. No citation reference is provided regarding the source of the tide range provided. All height references should be to NAVD-88. 2. Sheets DTL-1 and DTL-2, drawing scale. The vertical and horizontal scales are not the same. The drawing reference appears to be consistent with the vertical scale. 3. While the vertical distance appears to be to scale, height callouts are referenced to the height of the adjacent dock and not to a defined vertical datum. The overall height of the structure is on the order of 12 feet relative to Mean High Water. Discussion referencing the structure height as 7 feet is relative to the adjacent dock and not the height relative to water level (or defined datum). Further this height does not include the height of the beam and equipment on top of the pile which adds an additional 1’06” to the overall structure height. 4. Based on the information provided it is undetermined if the new, reduced pile elevations are the minimum required to meet the intent of the structure. However, the elevations as proposed in the revised drawings are generally consistent with standard practice relative to pile height and overall structure elevation required for the lifting of the design vessel. Page 81 Page 3 of 3 APPLIED TECHNOLOGY & MANAGEMENT, INC. Coastal, Environmental, Marine & Water Resources Engineering These comments are specific to technical aspects of the revised drawings provided. Revisions to the drawings based on these comments are recommended. Sincerely, Applied Technology & Management, Inc. Michael G. Jenkins, Ph.D., P.E. Coastal Engineering Principal Florida Professional Engineer, Lic.No. #58072 Printed copies of this document are not considered signed and sealed and the signature must be verified on any electronic copies. The signed and sealed document consists of 6 pages. Michael G Jenkins Digitally signed by Michael G Jenkins DN: cn=Michael G Jenkins c=US o=APPLIED TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT ou=A01410C0000016CBAB4 B64100004844 Reason: I am the author of this document Location: Date: 2020-10-23 13:15-04:00 Page 82 Page 83 Page 84 Page 85 Page 86 Page 87 Page 88 www.dep.state.fl.us FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF Environmental Protection Southeast District Office 3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1 West Palm Beach, FL 33406 561-681-6600 Ron DeSantis Governor Jeanette Nuñez Lt. Governor Noah Valenstein Secretary September 17, 2020 Richard Touchette 1006 Grand Court Boca Raton, FL 33487 Email Address: nutt3839@bellsouth.net File No.: 50-345492-004-EE File Name: Touchette 1006 Grand Court Dear Mr. Touchette: On September 14, 2020, we received your request for verification of exemption to perform the following activities: To install a new boatlift. The project is located in the Boat Basin, Class III Waters, adjacent to 1006 Grand Court, Boca Raton, FL (Section 09, Township 47 South, Range 43 East), in Palm Beach County (Latitude N 26° 23’ 37.39”, Longitude W 80° 04’ 06.93”). Your request has been reviewed to determine whether it qualifies for (1) regulatory exemption, (2) proprietary authorization (related to state-owned submerged lands), and (3) federal approval that may be necessary for work in wetlands or waters of the United States. Your project qualifies for all three. However, this letter does not relieve you from the responsibility of obtaining other federal, state, or local authorizations that may be required for the activity. If you change the project from what you submitted, the authorization(s) granted may no longer be valid at the time of commencement of the project. Please contact us prior to beginning your project if you wish to make any changes. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact Newt Robson at the letterhead address or at 561-681-6620, Newt.Robson@Floridadep.gov . Page 89 File No.: 50-345492-004-EE File Name: Touchette 1006 Grand Court Page 2 of 5 www.dep.state.fl.us 1. Regulatory Review – VERIFIED Based on the information submitted, the Department has verified that the activities as proposed are exempt, under Chapter 62-330.051(5)(h), Florida Administrative Code, from the need to obtain a regulatory permit under part IV of Chapter 373 of the Florida Statutes. This exemption verification is based on the information you provided the Department and the statutes and rules in effect when the information was submitted. This verification may not be valid if site conditions materially change, the project design is modified, or the statutes or rules governing the exempt activity are amended. In the event you need to re-verify the exempt status for the activity, a new request and verification fee will be required. Any substantial modifications to the project design should be submitted to the Department for review, as changes may result in a permit being required. 2. Proprietary Review – NOT REQUIRED The activity does not appear to be located on sovereign submerged lands and does not require further authorization under chapter 253 of the Florida Statutes, or chapters 18-20 or 18-21 of the Florida Administrative Code. 3. Federal Review – SPGP APPROVED Your proposed activity as outlined in your application and attached drawings qualifies for Federal authorization pursuant to the State Programmatic General Permit V-R1, and a SEPARATE permit or authorization will not be required from the Corps. Please note that the Federal authorization expires on July 26, 2021. However, your authorization may remain in effect for up to 1 additional year, if provisions of Special Condition 19 of the SPGP V-R1 permit instrument are met. You, as permittee, are required to adhere to all General Conditions and Special Conditions that may apply to your project. Special conditions required for your project are attached. A copy of the SPGP V-R1 with all terms and conditions and the General Conditions may be found at https://www.saj.usace.army.mil/Missions/Regulatory/Source-Book. Authority for review - an agreement with the USACOE entitled “Coordination Agreement Between the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers (Jacksonville District) and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (or Duly Authorized Designee), State Programmatic General Permit”, Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbor Act of 1899, and Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. Additional Information Please retain this letter. The activities may be inspected by authorized state personnel in the future to ensure compliance with appropriate statutes and administrative codes. If the activities are not in compliance, you may be subject to penalties under Chapter 373, F.S., and Chapter 18-14, F.A.C. NOTICE OF RIGHTS This action is final and effective on the date filed with the Clerk of the Department unless a petition for an administrative hearing is timely filed under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, F.S., before the deadline for filing a petition. On the filing of a timely and sufficient petition, this action will not be final and effective until a subsequent order of the Department. Because the administrative Page 90 File No.: 50-345492-004-EE File Name: Touchette 1006 Grand Court Page 3 of 5 www.dep.state.fl.us hearing process is designed to formulate final agency action, the hearing process may result in a modification of the agency action or even denial of the application. Petition for Administrative Hearing A person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department’s action may petition for an administrative proceeding (hearing) under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, F.S. Pursuant to Rules 28-106.201 and 28-106.301, F.A.C., a petition for an administrative hearing must contain the following information: (a) The name and address of each agency affected and each agency’s file or identification number, if known; (b) The name, address, any e-mail address, any facsimile number, and telephone number of the petitioner, if the petitioner is not represented by an attorney or a qualified representative; the name, address, and telephone number of the petitioner’s representative, if any, which shall be the address for service purposes during the course of the proceeding; and an explanation of how the petitioner’s substantial interests will be affected by the agency determination; (c) A statement of when and how the petitioner received notice of the agency decision; (d) A statement of all disputed issues of material fact. If there are none, the petition must so indicate; (e) A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, including the specific facts that the petitioner contends warrant reversal or modification of the agency’s proposed action; (f) A statement of the specific rules or statutes that the petitioner contends require reversal or modification of the agency’s proposed action, including an explanation of how the alleged facts relate to the specific rules or statutes; and (g) A statement of the relief sought by the petitioner, stating precisely the action that the petitioner wishes the agency to take with respect to the agency’s proposed action. The petition must be filed (received by the Clerk) in the Office of General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000, or via electronic correspondence at Agency_Clerk@dep.state.fl.us. Also, a copy of the petition shall be mailed to the applicant at the address indicated above at the time of filing. Time Period for Filing a Petition In accordance with Rule 62-110.106(3), F.A.C., petitions for an administrative hearing by the applicant and persons entitled to written notice under Section 120.60(3), F.S., must be filed within 21 days of receipt of this written notice. Petitions filed by any persons other than the applicant, and other than those entitled to written notice under Section 120.60(3), F.S., must be filed within 21 days of publication of the notice or within 21 days of receipt of the written notice, whichever occurs first. You cannot justifiably rely on the finality of this decision unless notice of this decision and the right of substantially affected persons to challenge this decision has been duly published or otherwise provided to all persons substantially affected by the decision. While you are not required to publish notice of this action, you may elect to do so pursuant Rule 62-110.106(10)(a). Page 91 File No.: 50-345492-004-EE File Name: Touchette 1006 Grand Court Page 4 of 5 www.dep.state.fl.us The failure to file a petition within the appropriate time period shall constitute a waiver of that person's right to request an administrative determination (hearing) under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, F.S., or to intervene in this proceeding and participate as a party to it. Any subsequent intervention (in a proceeding initiated by another party) will be only at the discretion of the presiding officer upon the filing of a motion in compliance with Rule 28-106.205, F.A.C. If you do not publish notice of this action, this waiver will not apply to persons who have not received written notice of this action. F.A.C.Extension of Time Under Rule 62-110.106(4), F.A.C., a person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department’s action may also request an extension of time to file a petition for an administrative hearing. The Department may, for good cause shown, grant the request for an extension of time. Requests for extension of time must be filed with the Office of General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000, or via electronic correspondence at Agency_Clerk@dep.state.fl.us, before the deadline for filing a petition for an administrative hearing. A timely request for extension of time shall toll the running of the time period for filing a petition until the request is acted upon. Mediation Mediation is not available in this proceeding. FLAWAC Review The applicant, or any party within the meaning of Section 373.114(1)(a) or 373.4275, F.S., may also seek appellate review of this order before the Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission under Section 373.114(1) or 373.4275, F.S. Requests for review before the Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission must be filed with the Secretary of the Commission and served on the Department within 20 days from the date when this order is filed with the Clerk of the Department. Judicial Review Once this decision becomes final, any party to this action has the right to seek judicial review pursuant to Section 120.68, F.S., by filing a Notice of Appeal pursuant to Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure 9.110 and 9.190 with the Clerk of the Department in the Office of General Counsel (Station #35, 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000) and by filing a copy of the Notice of Appeal accompanied by the applicable filing fees with the appropriate district court of appeal. The notice must be filed within 30 days from the date this action is filed with the Clerk of the Department. Page 92 File No.: 50-345492-004-EE File Name: Touchette 1006 Grand Court Page 5 of 5 www.dep.state.fl.us EXECUTION AND CLERKING Executed in Orlando, Florida. STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ______________________________ Newt Robson Environmental Specialist II Southeast District Enclosures: Attachment A- Specific Exemption Rule General Conditions for the use of the Federal SPGP V General Conditions for the use of the Federal SPGP V Project Drawings, 5 pages CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned duly designated deputy clerk hereby certifies that this permit and all copies were sent on the filing date below to the following listed persons: FDEP – Newt Robson Matt Mitchell, Palm Beach County, Environmental Resources, mmitchell@pbcgov.org FILING AND ACKNOWLEDGMENT FILED, on this date, pursuant to Section 120.52, F. S., with the designated Department Clerk, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged. ________________________ September 17, 2020 Clerk Date Page 93 Attachment A Chapter 62-330.051 Exempt Activities. The activities meeting the limitations and restrictions below are exempt from permitting. However, if located in, on, or over state-owned submerged lands, they are subject to a separate authorization under Chapters 253 and 258, F.S., and Chapters 18-18, 18-20, and 18-21, F.A.C., as applicable. (5) Dock, Pier, Boat Ramp and Other Boating-related Work ‒ (h) The installation of a pile-supported boat lift within an existing mooring area at a docking facility that is legally in existence, provided: 1. Such installation does not conflict with a condition of a permit issued thereunder; 2. The boat lift does not include additional structures, such as platforms, cat walks, and roofs. Page 94 www.dep.state.fl.us Special Conditions for Federal Authorization for SPGP V-R1 Note: JAXBO (Jacksonville District’s Programmatic Biological Opinion), referenced throughout, may be found online in the Jacksonville District Regulatory Division Sourcebook, or at http://cdm16021.contentdm.oclc.org/utils/getfile/collection/p16021coll3/id/577. The SPGP V-R1 instrument and all attachments may be found online through the Sourcebook, or at https://www.saj.usace.army.mil/SPGP/ In addition to the conditions specified above, the following Special Conditions apply to all projects reviewed and/or authorized under the SPGP V-R1. Special Conditions for All Projects 1. Authorization, design and construction must adhere to the terms of the SPGP V-R1 instrument including the Procedure and Work Authorized sections. 2. Design and construction must adhere to the PDCs for In-Water Activities (Attachment 6, from PDCs AP.7 through AP11, inclusive, of JAXBO) (Reference: JAXBO PDC AP.1.). 3. All activities performed during daylight hours (Reference: JAXBO PDC AP.6.). 4. For all projects involving the installation of piles or sheet piles, the maximum number of piles, sheet piles or concrete slab walls or boatlift I-beams installed by impact hammer per day is limited to no more than 5 per day. Any installation of metal pipe or metal sheet pile by impact hammer is not authorized (Reference: Categories D and E of JAXBO PDCs for In-Water Noise from Pile and Sheet Pile Installation, page 86.). 5. Projects within the boundary of the NOAA Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary require prior approval from the Sanctuary (Reference: JAXBO PDCs AP.14 and A1.6). 6. Notifications to the Corps. For all authorizations under this SPGP V-R1, including Self- Certifications, the Permittee shall provide the following notifications to the Corps: a. Commencement Notification. Within 10 days before the date of initiating the work authorized by this permit or for each phase of the authorized project, the Permittee shall provide a written notification of the date of commencement of authorized work to the Corps. b. Corps Self-Certification Statement of Compliance form. Within 60 days of completion of the work authorized by this permit, the Permittee shall complete the “Self-Certification Statement of Compliance” form (Attachment 32) and submit it to the Corps. In the event that the completed work deviates in any manner from the authorized work, the Permittee shall describe the deviations between the work authorized by this permit and the work as constructed on the “Self-Certification Statement of Compliance” form. The description of any deviations on the “Self-Certification Statement of Compliance” form does not constitute approval of any deviations by the Corps. Page 95 www.dep.state.fl.us c. Permit Transfer. When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time the property is transferred, the terms and conditions of this permit will continue to be binding on the new owner(s) of the property. To validate the transfer of this permit and the associated liabilities associated with compliance with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign and date the enclosed form (Attachment 2). d. Reporting Address. The Permittee shall submit all reports, notifications, documentation, and correspondence required by the general and special conditions of this permit to the following address. (1) For standard mail: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Regulatory Division, Enforcement Section, P.O. Box 4970, Jacksonville, FL, 32232-0019. (2) For electronic mail: SAJ-RD-Enforcement@usace.army.mil (not to exceed 10 MB). The Permittee shall reference this permit number, SAJ- 2015-02575 on all submittals. 7. The District Engineer reserves the right to require that any request for authorization under this SPGP V-R1 be evaluated as an Individual Permit. Conformance with the terms and conditions of the SPGP V-R1 does not automatically guarantee Federal authorization. 8. On a case-by-case basis, the Corps may impose additional Special Conditions which are deemed necessary to minimize adverse environmental impacts. 9. Failure to comply with all conditions of the SPGP V-R1 constitutes a violation of the Federal authorization. 10. No structure or work shall adversely affect or disturb properties listed in the National Register of Historic Places or those eligible for inclusion in the National Register. Prior to the start of work, the Applicant/Permittee or other party on the Applicant’s/Permittee’s behalf, shall conduct a search of known historical properties by contracting a professional archaeologist, and contacting the Florida Master Site File at 850-245-6440 or SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us. The Applicant/Permittee can also research sites in the National Register Information System (NRIS). Information can be found at http://www.cr.nps.gov/nr/research. a. If, during the initial ground disturbing activities and construction work, there are archaeological/cultural materials unearthed (which shall include, but not be limited to: pottery, modified shell, flora, fauna, human remains, ceramics, stone tools or metal implements, dugout canoes or any other physical remains that could be associated with Native American cultures or early colonial or American settlement), the Permittee shall immediately stop all work in the vicinity and notify the Compliance and Review staff of the State Historic Preservation Office at 850-245-6333 and the Corps Regulatory Project Manager to assess the significance of the discovery and devise appropriate actions, including salvage operations. Based on the circumstances of the discovery, equity to all parties, and considerations of the public interest, the Corps may modify, suspend, or revoke the permit in accordance with 33 C.F.R. § 325.7. Page 96 www.dep.state.fl.us b. In the unlikely event that human remains are identified, the remains will be treated in accordance with Section 872.05, Florida Statutes; all work in the vicinity shall immediately cease and the local law authority, and the State Archaeologist (850-245-6444) and the Corps Regulatory Project Manager shall immediately be notified. Such activity shall not resume unless specifically authorized by the State Archaeologist and the Corps. 11. The Permittee is responsible for obtaining any “take” permits required under the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s regulations governing compliance with these laws. The Permittee should contact the appropriate local office of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to determine if such “take” permits are required for a particular activity. 12. For Projects authorized under this SPGP V-R1 in navigable waters of the U.S., the Permittee understands and agrees that, if future operations by the United States require the removal, relocation, or other alteration, of the structures or work herein authorized, or if, in the opinion of the Secretary of the Army or his authorized representative, said structure or work shall cause unreasonable obstruction to the free navigation of the navigable waters, the Permittee will be required, upon due notice from the Corps of Engineers, to remove, relocate, or alter the structural work or obstructions caused thereby, without expense to the United States. No claim shall be made against the United States on account of any such removal or alteration. 13. The SPGP V-R1 will be valid through July 26, 2021 unless suspended or revoked by issuance of a public notice by the District Engineer. The Corps, in conjunction with the Federal resource agencies, will conduct periodic reviews to ensure that continuation of the permit during the period ending July 26, 2021, is not contrary to the public interest. The SPGP V-R1 will not be extended beyond July 26, 2021, but may be replaced by a new SPGP. If revocation occurs, all future applications for activities covered by the SPGP V-R1 will be evaluated by the Corps. 14. If the SPGP V-R1 expires, is revoked, or is terminated prior to completion of the authorized work, authorization of activities which have commenced or are under contract to commence in reliance upon the SPGP V-R1 will remain in effect provided the activity is completed within 12 months of the date the SPGP V-R1 expired or was revoked. Special Conditions for Docks, Piers, Associated Facilities, and other Minor Piling-Supported Structures 1. For temporary structures associated with marine events. Upon completion of the event, these structures must be removed and, to the maximum extent practical, the site must be restored to pre- construction elevations. Water depths in the area of marine events must be deep enough to support at least 5 ft of water depth under the keel of a vessel and between the keel of a vessel and Endangered Species Act listed coral colonies, if present, when transiting to the mooring areas (Reference: JAXBO PDC A2.1.4.). 2. Educational Signs. For commercial, multi-family, or public facilities, and marine events, signs must be posted as described below (Reference: These replicate JAXBO PDCs A.2.2 and A.2.2.1 Page 97 www.dep.state.fl.us to A.2.2.3., inclusive, within the table PDCs Specific to Activity 2 - Pile Supported Structures and Anchored Buoys, starting on page 112.): a. (A2.2.) For commercial, multi-family, or public facilities, and marine events, signs must be posted in a visible location(s), alerting users of listed species in the area susceptible to vessel strikes and hook-and-line captures. The most current version of the signs that must be downloaded and sign installation guidance are available at: (http://sero.nmfs.noaa.gov/protected_resources/section_7/protected_species_educational_s igns/index.html). The signs required to be posted by area are stated below: (1) (A2.2.1.) All projects in Florida shall use the Save Sea Turtle, Sawfish, and Dolphin sign. These signs shall include contact information to the sea turtle and marine mammal stranding networks and smalltooth sawfish encounter database. (2) (A2.2.2.) Projects within the North Atlantic right whale educational sign zone shall post the Help Protect North Atlantic Right Whales sign. (3) (A2.2.3.) On the east coast of Florida, projects located within the St. Johns River and those occurring north of the St. Johns River to the Florida-Georgia line shall post the Report Sturgeon sign. On the west coast of Florida, projects occurring from the Cedar Key, Florida north to the Florida-Alabama line. 3. Monofilament Recycling Bins. For commercial, multi-family, or public facilities, monofilament recycling bins must be provided as described below (Reference: The below replicates PDC A.2.3 within the table PDCs Specific to Activity 2 - Pile Supported Structures and Anchored Buoys, the PDC itself on page 113 of the JAXBO.): a. (A2.3.) For commercial, multi-family, or public facilities, monofilament recycling bins must be provided at the docking facility to reduce the risk of turtle or sawfish entanglement in, or ingestion of, marine debris. Monofilament recycling bins must: (1) (A2.3.1.) Be constructed and labeled according to the instructions provided at http://mrrp.myfwc.com. (2) (A2.3.2.) Be maintained in working order and emptied frequently (according to http://mrrp.myfwc.com standards) so that they do not overflow. 4. North Atlantic Right Whale. The attached North Atlantic Right Whale Information Form (Attachment 27) describes the presence of North Atlantic right whales in the area and the Federal regulations governing the approach to North Atlantic right whales. (The FDEP or Designee will attach this document to their authorizations for a dock project (new construction, repair, or replacement) at a private residence located within 11 nautical miles of North Atlantic right whale critical habitat as measured in a radius from the center of the nearest inlet to open ocean described by Attachment 29, the North Atlantic Right Whale Educational Sign Zones (from Section 2.1.1.4 of JAXBO, pages 31 and 32, inclusive) (Reference: JAXBO PDC A2.4.). 5. Aids to Navigation. Aids to navigation must be approved by and installed in accordance with the requirements of the U.S. Coast Guard (i.e., 33 C.F.R., chapter I, subchapter C, part 66, Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act, and any other pertinent requirements) (Reference: JAXBO PDC A2.5.). Page 98 www.dep.state.fl.us 6. Lighting for docks installed within visible distance of ocean beaches. If lighting is necessary, then turtle-friendly lighting shall be installed. Turtle-friendly lighting is explained and examples are provided on the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission website: http://myfwc.com/wildlifehabitats/managed/sea-turtles/lighting/ (Reference: JAXBO PDC A2.8.). 7. Construction Location. Project construction shall take place from uplands or from floating equipment (e.g., barge); prop or wheel-washing is prohibited (Reference: JAXBO PDC A2.9.). 8. Regarding submerged and emergent aquatic vegetation, the design and construction of a Project must comply with the following: a. A pile supported structure (i) that is located on a natural waterbody (i.e., outside an artificial waterway that was excavated for boating access and is bordered by residential properties) and (ii) that is within the range of seagrass (estuarine waters within all coastal counties except for Nassau, Duval, St Johns, Flagler and Volusia north of Ponce Inlet), will be constructed to the following standards: (1) Must comply with or provide a higher level of protection than, the protective criteria in the joint U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’/National Marine Fisheries Service’s “Construction Guidelines in Florida for Minor Piling-Supported Structures Constructed in or over Submerged Aquatic Vegetation (SAV), Marsh or Mangrove Habitat” updated November 2017 (Attachment 5). (2) In addition to (1), above, IF the project is within range of Johnson’s seagrass (the range of Johnson’s seagrass is defined as Turkey Creek/Palm Bay south to central Biscayne Bay in the lagoon systems on the east coast of Florida), THEN the design and construction shall comply with, in some cases, the more restrictive requirements within paragraph 8.c., below (Reference: JAXBO PDC A2.17). b. For all other Projects, (1) Within the range of Johnson’s seagrass (the range of Johnson’s seagrass is defined as Turkey Creek/Palm Bay south to central Biscayne Bay in the lagoon systems on the east coast of Florida), the presence of submerged aquatic vegetation will be determined utilizing the “Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Survey Guidelines” (Attachment 7). If no survey performed, aquatic vegetation, including Johnson’s seagrass, will be presumed to be present for purposes of this Special Condition. (2) Outside the range of Johnson’s seagrass but within the range of seagrass (estuarine waters within all coastal counties except for Nassau, Duval, St Johns, Flagler and Volusia County north of Ponce Inlet) and within tidal waters, the presence of seagrass and tidal freshwater submerged aquatic vegetation will be determined using the “Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Survey Guidelines” (Attachment 7) unless a site visit or aerial photography observes absence during the growing season (if water depth and clarity allows) or aquatic vegetation has not been found in the vicinity in the past. (3) Pile-supported structures, IF aquatic vegetation is present (including seagrass, tidal freshwater submerged aquatic vegetation and emergent vegetation), THEN must comply with or provide a higher level of protection than, the protective criteria in the joint U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’/National Marine Fisheries Service’s “Construction Page 99 www.dep.state.fl.us Guidelines in Florida for Minor Piling-Supported Structures Constructed in or over Submerged Aquatic Vegetation (SAV), Marsh or Mangrove Habitat” updated November 2017 (Attachment 5). (4) In addition to (1) to (3) above, IF the proposed dock or proposed structure is within range of Johnson’s seagrass (the range of Johnson’s seagrass is defined as Turkey Creek/Palm Bay south to central Biscayne Bay in the lagoon systems on the east coast of Florida), and IF the proposed dock or proposed structure falls within the following scenarios, THEN the design and construction shall comply with, in some cases, the more restrictive requirements within paragraph 8.c.,below. (Reference: The following replicates “Scenario B” as defined within A2.17., PDCs for Docks or Other Minor Structures of JAXBO.): (i) Dock replacement in the exact footprint (i.e., same location/configuration/size) as the previous dock and: (a) within Johnson’s seagrass critical habitat with No current seagrass survey (completed no earlier than 1 year before submitting the application); or, Johnson’s seagrass under the dock; or, Native seagrass, other than Johnson’s seagrass, under the dock; or, (b) within the Range of Johnson’s seagrass (outside of critical habitat) with No current seagrass survey or,Johnson’s seagrass under the dock, (ii) New docks or dock expansions and: (a) within Johnson’s seagrass critical habitat; or, (b) within the Range of Johnson’s seagrass (outside of critical habitat) with: No current seagrass survey (completed no earlier than 1 year before submitting the application) or, Johnson’s seagrass within property limit. c. The following additional restrictions apply when required by paragraphs 8.a.(2) or 8.b.(4), above (Reference: The following replicates the “Dock PDCs for Scenario B” within A2.17. PDCs for Docks or Other Minor Structures of JAXBO.): (1) To avoid and minimize impacts to Johnson’s seagrass and native, non-listed seagrasses to the maximum extent practicable: (i) The dock must be positioned to avoid and minimize effects to Johnson’s seagrass. (ii) Over any area that contains Johnson’s seagrass or native, non- listed seagrasses, the dock shall be oriented in a north-south orientation to the maximum extent that is practicable to allow maximum sunlight under the structure. (iii) If practicable, terminal platforms shall be placed in deep water, waterward of Johnson’s seagrass beds or native, non-listed seagrasses beds or in an area devoid of Johnson’s seagrass or native, non-listed seagrasses. (iv) Piles must be spaced a minimum of 10 ft apart in any area that contains Johnson’s seagrass to minimize direct impacts. (v) Piles shall be installed in a manner that will not result in the formation of sedimentary deposits (e.g., donuts or halos) around the newly installed pilings. (vi) No covered boat lifts are allowed over any Johnson’s seagrass. (2) Decking options: Deck surfaces (parallel with the water) that are located waterward of the MHWL must be constructed of grated materials or plank construction or a Page 100 www.dep.state.fl.us combination of the both methods (e.g. plank decking on the walkway and grated decking on the terminal platform). These decking options are described below: (i) For grated decking: (a) Height requirement: The surface of the structure, including the dock walkway (the over- water narrow portion connecting the terminal platform to the shore and any over-water ramp required for access) and the dock, must be a minimum of 3 ft above MHW when constructed with grated decking. (b) Size limitations: The dock walkway is limited to a width of 4 ft. The terminal platform is limited to a total area of 160 ft². Marginal docks are limited to a width of 5 ft. The 5 ft width restriction is measured from wet side of the seawall. For example, if a seawall cap is 3 feet overwater then the dock would be limited to 2 feet. (c) Material description: Decking materials shaped in the form of grids, grates, lattices, etc., to allow the passage of light through the open spaces. These materials must provide a minimum of 43% open space. (ii) For plank decking: (a) Height requirement: The surface of the structure, including the dock walkway (the over- water narrow portion connecting the terminal platform to the shore and any over-water ramp required for access) and the dock, must be a minimum of 5 ft above MHW when constructed of plank decking. (b) Size limitations: The dock walkway is limited to a width of 4 ft. The terminal platform is limited to a total area of 120 ft². Marginal docks are limited to a width of 5 ft. (c) Material description: Deck boards may be constructed of any material. Deck Boards must be installed to provide a minimum of a 0.5-in gap between individual deck boards. d. Aids to Navigation in Acropora critical habitat. The distance from Aids to Navigation (ATONs) to ESA-listed corals and Acropora critical habitat shall ensure there are no impacts to the corals or the essential feature of Acropora critical habitat from the movement of buoys and tackle. The appropriate distance shall be based on the size of the anchor chain or other tackle to be installed to secure the buoy to its anchor, particularly when the design of the ATON does not prohibit the contact of tackle with the marine bottom. In all cases, buoy tackle will include flotation to ensure there is no contact between the anchor chain or line and the marine bottom (Reference: JAXBO PDC A2.10.). General Conditions for Federal Authorization for SPGP V-R1 1. The time limit for completing the work authorized ends on July 26, 2021. 2. You must maintain the activity authorized by this permit in good condition and in conformance with the terms and conditions of this permit. You are not relieved of this requirement if you abandon the permitted activity, although you may make a good faith transfer to a third party in compliance with General Condition 4 below. Should you wish to cease to maintain the authorized activity or should you desire to abandon it without a good faith transfer, you must obtain a modification of this permit from this office, which may require restoration of Page 101 www.dep.state.fl.us the area. 3. If you discover any previously unknown historic or archeological remains while accomplishing the activity authorized by this permit, you must immediately notify this office of what you have found. We will initiate the Federal and State coordination required to determine if the remains warrant a recovery effort or if the site is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. 4. If you sell the property associated with this permit, you must obtain the signature of the new owner on the enclosed form and forward a copy of the permit to this office to validate the transfer of this authorization. 5. If a conditioned water quality certification has been issued for your project, you must comply with the conditions specified in the certification as special conditions to this permit. 6. You must allow representatives from this office to inspect the authorized activity at any time deemed necessary to ensure that it is being or has been accomplished in accordance with the terms and conditions of your permit. Further Information: 1. Limits of this authorization. a. This permit does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, State, or local authorizations required by law. b. This permit does not grant any property rights or exclusive privileges. c. This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others. d. This permit does not authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal projects. 2. Limits of Federal Liability. In issuing this permit, the Federal Government does not assume any liability for the following: a. Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of other permitted or unpermitted activities or from natural causes. b. Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of current or future activities undertaken by or on behalf of the United States in the public interest. c. Damages to persons, property, or to other permitted or unpermitted activities or structures caused by the activity authorized by this permit. d. Design or Construction deficiencies associated with the permitted work. e. Damage claims associated with any future modification, suspension, or revocation of this permit. 3. Reliance on Applicant’s Data: The determination of this office that issuance of this permit is not contrary to the public interest was made in reliance on the information you provided. Page 102 www.dep.state.fl.us 4. Reevaluation of Permit Decision: This office may reevaluate its decision on this permit at any time the circumstances warrant. Circumstances that could require a reevaluation include, but are not limited to, the following: a. You fail to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit. b. The information provided by you in support of your permit application proves to have been false, incomplete, or inaccurate (see 3 above). c. Significant new information surfaces which this office did not consider in reaching the original public interest decision. 5. Such a reevaluation may result in a determination that it is appropriate to use the suspension, modification, and revocation procedures contained in 33 CFR 325.7 or enforcement procedures such as those contained in 33 CFR 326.4 and 326.5. The referenced enforcement procedures provide for the issuance of an administrative order requiring you comply with the terms and conditions of your permit and for the initiation of legal action where appropriate. You will be required to pay for any corrective measures ordered by this office, and if you fail to comply with such directive, this office may in certain situations (such as those specified in 33 CER 209.170) accomplish the corrective measures by contract or otherwise and bill you for the cost. 6. When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time the property is transferred, the terms and conditions of this permit will continue to be binding on the new owner(s) of the property. To validate the transfer of this permit and the associated liabilities associated with compliance with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign and date the enclosed form. 7. The Permittee understands and agrees that, if future operations by the United States require the removal, relocation, or other alteration, of the structures or work herein authorized, or if, in the opinion of the Secretary of the Army or his authorized representative, said structure or work shall cause unreasonable obstruction to the free navigation of the navigable waters, the Permittee will be required, upon due notice from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, to remove, relocate, or alter the structural work or obstructions caused thereby, without expense to the United States. No claim shall be made against the United States on account of any such removal, relocation or alteration. Page 103 www.dep.state.fl.us Department of the Army Permit Transfer for SPGP V-R1 PERMITEE: _________________________________________________ PERMIT NUMBER: ___________________________________ DATE: ___________ ADDRESS/LOCATION OF PROJECT: ______________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________________ (Subdivision) (Lot) (Block) When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time the property is transferred, the terms and conditions of this permit will continue to be binding on the new owner(s) of the property. Although the construction period for works authorized by Department of the Army permits is finite, the permit itself, with its limitations, does not expire. To validate the transfer of this permit and the associated responsibilities associated with compliance with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign and date below and mail to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Enforcement Branch, Post Office Box 4970, Jacksonville, FL 32232-0019. ___________________________________________ _____________________ (Transferee Signature) (Date) _____________________________________________________________________ (Name Printed) _____________________________________________________________________ (Street address) ______________________________________________________________________ (Mailing address) ______________________________________________________________________ (City, State, Zip Code) Page 104 www.dep.state.fl.us STANDARD MANATEE CONDITIONS FOR IN-WATER WORK 2011 The permittee shall comply with the following conditions intended to protect manatees from direct project effects: a. All personnel associated with the project shall be instructed about the presence of manatees and manatee speed zones, and the need to avoid collisions with and injury to manatees. The permittee shall advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties for harming, harassing, or killing manatees which are protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act, the Endangered Species Act, and the Florida Manatee Sanctuary Act. b. All vessels associated with the construction project shall operate at "Idle Speed/No Wake” at all times while in the immediate area and while in water where the draft of the vessel provides less than a four-foot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will follow routes of deep water whenever possible. c. Siltation or turbidity barriers shall be made of material in which manatees cannot become entangled, shall be properly secured, and shall be regularly monitored to avoid manatee entanglement or entrapment. Barriers must not impede manatee movement. d. All on-site project personnel are responsible for observing water-related activities for the presence of manatee(s). All in-water operations, including vessels, must be shutdown if a manatee(s) comes within 50 feet of the operation. Activities will not resume until the manatee(s) has moved beyond the 50-foot radius of the project operation, or until 30 minutes elapses if the manatee(s) has not reappeared within 50 feet of the operation. Animals must not be herded away or harassed into leaving. e. Any collision with or injury to a manatee shall be reported immediately to the FWC Hotline at 1-888-404-3922. Collision and/or injury should also be reported to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in Jacksonville (1-904-731-3336) for north Florida or Vero Beach (1-772- 562-3909) for south Florida, and to FWC at ImperiledSpecies@myFWC.com f. Temporary signs concerning manatees shall be posted prior to and during all in-water project activities. All signs are to be removed by the permittee upon completion of the project. Temporary signs that have already been approved for this use by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) must be used (see MyFWC.com/manatee). One sign which reads Caution: Boaters must be posted. A second sign measuring at least 81/2" by 11" explaining the requirements for “Idle Speed/No Wake” and the shut down of in-water operations must be posted in a location prominently visible to all personnel engaged in water-related activities. Questions concerning these signs can be sent to the email address listed above. Page 105 www.dep.state.fl.us Page 106 www.dep.state.fl.us UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE Southeast Regional Office 263 13th Avenue South St. Petersburg, FL 33701 SEA TURTLE AND SMALLTOOTH SAWFISH CONSTRUCTION CONDITIONS The permittee shall comply with the following protected species construction conditions: a. The permittee shall instruct all personnel associated with the project of the potential presence of these species and the need to avoid collisions with sea turtles and smalltooth sawfish. All construction personnel are responsible for observing water-related activities for the presence of these species. b. The permittee shall advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties for harming, harassing, or killing sea turtles or smalltooth sawfish, which are protected under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. c. Siltation barriers shall be made of material in which a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish cannot become entangled, be properly secured, and be regularly monitored to avoid protected species entrapment. Barriers may not block sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish entry to or exit from designated critical habitat without prior agreement from the National Marine Fisheries Service’s Protected Resources Division, St. Petersburg, Florida. d. All vessels associated with the construction project shall operate at “no wake/idle” speeds at all times while in the construction area and while in water depths where the draft of the vessel provides less than a four-foot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will preferentially follow deep-water routes (e.g., marked channels) whenever possible. e. If a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish is seen within 100 yards of the active daily construction/dredging operation or vessel movement, all appropriate precautions shall be implemented to ensure its protection. These precautions shall include cessation of operation of any moving equipment closer than 50 feet of a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish. Operation of any mechanical construction equipment shall cease immediately if a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish is seen within a 50-ft radius of the equipment. Activities may not resume until the protected species has departed the project area of its own volition. f. Any collision with and/or injury to a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish shall be reported immediately to the National Marine Fisheries Service’s Protected Resources Division (727-824-5312) and the local authorized sea turtle stranding/rescue organization. Page 107 www.dep.state.fl.us g. Any special construction conditions, required of your specific project, outside these general conditions, if applicable, will be addressed in the primary consultation. h. Any collision(s) with and/or injuries to any whale, or sturgeon occurring during the construction of a project, shall be reported immediately to NMFS’s Protected Resources Division (PRD) at (727-824-5312). i. Reports to NMFS’s Protected Resources Division (PRD) may be made by email to takereport.nmfsser@noaa.gov. j. Sea turtle and marine stranding/rescue organizations’ contact information is available by region at http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/health/networks.htm. k. Smalltooth sawfish encounters shall be reported to http://www.flmnh.ufl.edu/fish/sharks/sawfish/sawfishencounters.html. l. All work must occur during daylight hours. Page 108 Permit Number50-345492-004-EESoutheast DistrictPage 109 Permit Number50-345492-004-EESoutheast DistrictPage 110 Permit Number50-345492-004-EESoutheast DistrictPage 111 Permit Number50-345492-004-EESoutheast DistrictPage 112 Permit Number50-345492-004-EESoutheast DistrictPage 113 PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Fred Rosen 10.16.2020 Page 114 From:Fred M. Rosen To:Marshall Labadie Cc:Kathleen Kennedy; Douglas Hillman; Peggy Gossett-Seidman; Paul Resnick; Greg Babij; Evalyn David; John Shoemaker; Lanelda Gaskins; Ingrid Allen; Marc Siegel; David Axelrod Subject:Touchette Date:Friday, October 16, 2020 7:21:02 PM Once again Mr. Touchette spits in our face and is laughing at our town. He spit in the face of the memory of Mayor Carl Feldman by completely ignoring him when Carl became sick. We, as a community are failing a percentage of our residents who are unable to sell their homes or nearby buildings to be able to look out their windows and not see this sideways monstrosity. Once again, he and his lawyers merrily file more applications to change the look or make some absurd changes without tearing the structure down and offering an application to build a boat lift that conforms to the community without spitting in the face of our Commissioners, our town manager, our building and code enforcement people and the people that have been living with his total disregard for his complex, his community and his town. Please!!!!!! DO NOT ALLOW ANY ADDITIONAL APPLICATIONS TO BE PRESENTED UNTIL TO AGREES TO MAKE THE STRUCTURE STRAIGHT IN AND OUT AND AGREES TO CONFORM WITH THE OTHER STRUCTURES IN THE COMMUNITY!! I urge our Commissioners to put a stop to this blatant disregard of his community. If Carl Feldman had not fallen ill, he would have put a stop to this nonsense in a heartbeat. Let’s honor our former mayor and show respect to the people impacted by this scofflaw and put and end to this. We have fine town attorneys. Let’s put Glen to work and urge our commissioners and members of the Planning Board to stand up to this nuisance. Fred Rosen 732-614-1743 4740 South Ocean Blvd. Unit 1015 Highland Beach Florida 33487 email fredrosen@icloud.com Page 115 PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Paul Resnick 10.20.2020 Page 116 Page 117 Page 118 PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) March Siegel 11.03.2020 Page 119 From:Marc Siegel To:Public Comments; Lanelda Gaskins Subject:Application No. 20-0014 Planning Board Meeting 11.12.2020 Public Comments Date:Tuesday, November 3, 2020 12:26:37 PM Once again, the applicant tries to push the governmental process by continuing to apply for an already permit decline as well as code violations. The applicant residing at 1006 Grand Court continues to show his disrespect and lack of concern for the town of Highland Beach as well as his neighbors in his community. His perseverance and refusal to abide by the town codes and the disapproval by his neighbors shows total disregard for policy and community concerns. The applicant installed a massive boat lift structure without concern for authority and performing within the scope of town regulations and code violations. The response of the applicant was to simply offer a shoulder shrug and ignore disapproval. The structure impedes the movement of other much smaller pleasure boats within this very small "marina". The structure will be an eyesore for the area as well as block the once beautiful and tranquil views of the neighbors and residents of the adjacent condo dwellings in Braemar Isle. This size boat and intended structure belongs in a much larger marina where not only the marina can accommodate the super-size of the vessel but the structure to support this vessel might already be there for his use. In the present state of the North Marina of Boca Highland Beach Club, we simply cannot allow nor start to open the door to 40-70-foot vessels or lift structures to accommodate them. The compact cove environment just can't accommodate these massive boats. The resident has prolonged the permit process and worked with expired permits showing total disregard for the rules, town codes and regulations on record. I strongly disapprove all requests for permits to install his massive structure designed to lift his boat several feet above the high-water line. We certainly don't want nor to expect to see a "boatyard or drydock" appearance to our tranquil and relaxing views and visual pollution of the North Marina of our community. We hope that the Planning board objects to his requests for any type of permit as well as to take into consideration his prior behavior and refusal to follow the codes and their guidelines. PLEASE VOTE NO Marc N. Siegel Braemar Isle Condominium Page 120 PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Michael Mantelle 11.04.2020 Page 121 From:Michael Mantelle To:Lanelda Gaskins Subject:1006GrandCt Date:Wednesday, November 4, 2020 9:38:28 AM TO: Lanelda Gaskins, City of Highland Beach RE: Boat lift 1006 Grand Ct I am contacting you over concern regarding the potential of an oversized boat lift project being installed in the Marina at property 1006 Grand Ct. This is of great concern to us here at Braemar Isle. My understanding is this project has gotten to the developement stage without proper permits or the city of Highland Beach's consent. There appears to be no concern from this property owner about the impact on his neighbors or the safety of other boaters in this very small Marina area. It is dangerous enough navigating in this area and on the intercoastal already without this additional hazard. Thank you for your time to read my email. Kind regards Michael Mantelle 4740 S. Ocean Blvd 1616 Highland Beach, FL 33487 925-989-5741 Page 122 PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) James Mills 11.04.2020 Page 123 From:James M To:Lanelda Gaskins Subject:Boat lift 1006 Date:Tuesday, November 3, 2020 7:05:21 PM Hello, We don’t understand why this is Even been considered. The owners of The property never had proper permits to build a structure that was built . Why has an order to remove not Been issued . . We feel the town could have done a better job by not allowing this to go so Far . James Mills HIGHLAND BEACH RESIDENT NOW . Page 124 AUGUST 13, 2020 PLANNING BOARD PACKET & MEETING MINUTES DEVELOPMENT NO. 19-0001 Page 125 TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH AGENDA MEMORANDUM MEETING TYPE: Planning Board Meeting MEETING DATE 08/13/2020 SUBMITTED BY: Ingrid Allen, Town Planner SUBJECT: Development Order Application No. 19-0001 – 1006 Grand Court SUMMARY: At the July 9, 2020 Planning Board meeting, the Board made a motion to continue the subject item to the August 13, 2020 Board meeting in an effort to have the Applicant reach a compromise with his neighbors. On July 28, 2020, the Town received an email from the Applicant’s attorney, Michael S. Weiner, indicating that his firm must withdraw from the subject matter as a result of a “…recent development creating a conflict of interest…” On July 29, 2020, the Town received an email from the Applicant, Richard Touchette, requesting a postponement of his item in order to give him time to “…hire a new lawyer.” On August 6, 2020, the Town received a letter from the Applicant’s new attorney, Ms. Ele Zachariades, requesting a postponement of the August 13th Board hearing “…in order to provide an opportunity to get up to speed and speak with the neighbors.” The request for postponement will be considered by the Planning Board at the August 13th Planning Board meeting. Since the July 9, 2020 Planning Board meeting, the Town has received additional public comment on this item which is attached to this memorandum. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A ATTACHMENTS: Correspondence from Michael S. Weiner (July 28, 2020). Correspondence from Richard Touchette requesting postponement of item (July 29, 2020). Correspondence from Ele Zachariades (August 6, 2020) Additional public comment received since the July 9, 2020 Planning Board meeting. Page 126 Page 127 From:Michael Weiner To:Beverly Wright; Ingrid Allen; Jeff Remas; Pamala Ryan Cc:Spencer Sax; Louis Caplan Subject:1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, Florida; Boat Dock Date:Tuesday, July 28, 2020 11:56:29 AM To all: We wish to inform you that because of a recent development creating a conflict of interest, Sachs, Sax and Caplan, P.L. must withdraw from this matter. Mr. Touchette has been informed and we are told that his is seeking substitute counsel. We shall send a written confirmation so that this withdrawal may easily be made part of the record. Thank you for your considerations. Michael S. Weiner, Esquire Sachs Sax Caplan, P.L.  6111 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 200 Boca Raton, FL 33487 mweiner@ssclawfirm.com  | www.ssclawfirm.com 561-994-4499 Office 561-237-6819 Direct 561-994-4985 Fax   P Please consider the environment before printing this email Tax Advice Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS under Circular 230, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments), unless otherwise specifically stated, was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (1) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (2) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any matters addressed herein. Confidentiality: The email message and any attachment to this email message may contain privileged and confidential information, intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copy of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you receive this communication in error, please immediately notify the sender by return email and delete this message. Page 128 From:Richard Touchette To:Ingrid Allen Subject:Fwd: Board Hearing Date:Wednesday, July 29, 2020 11:29:55 AM > Mrs Ingrid Allen > As I explained to you on the phone, my lawyer can not represent me anymore due to a conflict of interest. > Can we postpone the next board hearing that was scheduled in August in order to give me time to hire a new lawyer. > Thank you > > Richard Touchette > 514 944-6565 Page 129 Page 130 Page 131 Page 132 Page 133 Page 134 Page 135 Page 136 Page 137 Page 138 Page 139 Page 140 Page 141 Page 142 Page 143 Page 144 Page 145 Page 146 Page 147 Page 148 Page 149 Page 150 Page 151 Page 152 Page 153 Page 154 ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT RECEIVED SINCE THE JULY 9, 2020 PLANNING BOARD MEETING (19-0001) Kathleen Kennedy 08.06.2020 Page 155 1 Beverly Wright From:Kathleen Kennedy <kkboca@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, August 6, 2020 3:34 PM To:dzaxelrod@gmail.com; gldnbrg@gmail.com; golfdemoss@aol.com; msirm1@gmail.com; John Boden; Harry Adwar (Hadwar@msn.com); rbrown@acslabtest.com; Evalyn David; John Shoemaker; Marshall Labadie; Ingrid Allen; Lanelda Gaskins; Beverly Wright; Public Comments; hbpublicrecords; Ganelle Thompson; Terisha Cuebas; Barry Donaldson; Greg Babij; Peggy Gossett-Seidman; Rhoda Zelniker; Douglas Hillman; Kathleen Kennedy Subject:Support Needed to Oppose Superstructure to be Built at 1006 Grand Ct., Highland Beach Attachments:Violations of City and State code to build Superstructure at 1006 Grand Ct.pdf; 07.29.2020 Planning Board Meeting Exhibits.1005 Grand Court Public Comment.pdf Hello,     My name is Kathleen Kennedy and I am the owner of 1005 Grand Ct. in Highland Beach, located in the subdivision Grand  Cay Estates in Boca Highland. I had moved to Highland Beach in 1985 and have been fortunate to have lived and raised  two children here.    About three years ago, I purchased a home in Boca Highland and have enjoyed living here. However, because of a  boatlift/superstructure built by my next door neighbor with highly questionable approval and without notice to  surrounding property owners or impact studies, my view of the Intercoastal has been obstructed by my neighbor's giant  structure that has significantly and negatively impacted my property value and quality of life.  While the process to build  this superstructure began over four years ago, and construction over two years ago, the approval process has been  frighteningly neglectful and ignorant of proper codes and requirements. With potential acceptance by the Board, this  eyesore has completely restricted access to my waterfront property as well as neighboring properties. In addition, my  neighbors’ views will be blocked as mine has been. As a result, all neighboring properties will be devalued.     Attached to this email is a letter I have sent to the City. It outlines some of the numerous violations that have taken  place in serving this one resident to the detriment of all others.  I am including a petition at the bottom of this email for  your support. Please write your name and hit “reply all” so that your voice is heard. Please note that I am sending this  email to City officials but I’ve blind copied my neighbors to keep your information private.     Our city code and its process for administering permits is highly flawed and requires immediate attention.  I’ve done my  best to compose a comprehensive outline of the issues and numerous failures by the City to adhere to their own rules  and processes. I realize that I have included a lot of information about this matter in the attached documents; however, I  believe we all need to be fully informed as this impacts all of us. On August 13, 2020, another meeting regarding this  matter had been scheduled. Without your support, I fear that the City will continue to ignore their responsibilities and  duties. and overlook the rules and requirements to which they are bound in protecting our rights as property owners.  Furthermore, inaction will undoubtedly set a dangerous precedent, allowing the same gross failures to occur while  further weakening the value of our waterfront homes and community.     I sincerely hope you will take a few minutes to review the attached documents, particularly my letter to the Board/City,  and join me in protecting our rights and forcing the City to comply with their own set of standards.       Respectfully,    Kathleen Kennedy    Page 156 2           Highland Beach Petition:    I have been provided with information regarding the proposal to build a boatlift/superstructure at 1006 Grand Ct.,  Highland Beach, FL 33487.  According to information I have been provided, I am very concerned about the improprieties  and failures by the City of Highland Beach to adhere to the existing codes and requirements permitting such a structure  to be built. I am also concerned about negative effects on property values, navigational safety, neglect to protect right to  view of the waterways, and setting precedent for similar future acts.     By writing my name, I am enacting my right to oppose any and all structures be built at 1006 Grand Ct. at this time  without a full public review and reassessment of this project from its inception. I am also opposed to any variance or  changes to the application submitted by 1006 Grand Ct. under consideration by the City including permitting the  structure to be built over 4ft.       Name:                Think Green: Please do not print this email unless absolutely necessary   The information contained in this message may be privileged and confidential and   protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or   an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient,   you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copy of this   communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,   please notify us immediately by replying to the message and deleting it from your   computer.      Page 157 8/6/20 RE: Proposed Plan and Changes to Build a Superstructure/Boatlift at 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, FL 33487 Dear Highland Beach Planning Board, Highland Beach Elected Officials and Neighbors, Thank you for your prompt attention and consideration of this matter relative to the facts and concerns outlined below. At its last meeting on 7/9/20, the Highland Beach Planning Board (Board) failed to bring forth and review numerous and significant issues and complaints regarding the above matter, relegating the entire discussion solely to discuss the height of the superstructure/dock. However, the initial process that led to questionable permission for this structure to be built at all, is fraught with clear and significant oversights, procedural inadequacies and failures, and had neglected to enforce the rules, regulations and requirements pertaining to building a superstructure/dock in Grand Cay Estates, Highland Beach, FL. The entire community of Grand Cay Estates has been informed of the facts of this case so they may voice their opinions and adequately advocate for their rights as we all follow the impending decisions made by the Board on this matter. Mr. Touchette of 1006 Grand Ct., submitted an initial plan in 2017 requesting to build an 8 pile, 4ft. boatlift with a 15ft. variance. However, this plan was later changed to include a 10 pile, 12ft. boatlift. Grand Cay Estates neighbors were never notified of Mr. Touchette’s initial plan or his altered plan to build a superstructure, as required through proper permitting and City procedures. Moreover, the change in the planned superstructure effectively moves Mr. Touchette’s property line into the 1005 Grand Ct. property line. Mr. Touchette’s submission for his plan revision reflects a completely different project that permits him to relocate and alter the dimensions of the structure. Mr. Touchette’s superstructure directly affects the properties around it by negatively impacting property values and creating a navigational hazard, as the pilings sit far into the narrow fairway/waterway. By reviewing the following concerns, you will undoubtedly become aware that Mr. Touchette’s plans to build a superstructure at 1006 Grand Ct. necessitates a full review of the process, policies and procedures that, left unaddressed, will set a dangerous precedent for Grand Cay Estates and City residents with waterfront properties. 1. Information submitted to the Board by Mr. Touchette never included mention of moving the location of the boatlift. The Board must clarify both when and under what circumstances his original and newly submitted plans were publicly presented for approval. 2. The Highland Beach Nuisance Code stipulates that anything potentially causing a substantial deterioration of the value of properties in the neighborhood must be assessed. Page 158 Mr. Touchette’s proposed boatlift completely blocks the view of 1005 Grand Ct., impedes other residence’s views, and has already negatively impacted property value due to this matter. 3. Applied Technology Management Design Engineering Consulting (ATM) completed a Technical Review (6/5/20) of Mr. Touchette’s second plan submission. The Review noted that the superstructure causes a complete obstruction of view on the adjacent property (1005 Grand Court) as well as the properties behind and directly across the proposed boatlift. According to ATM, “Code provisions include consideration of impacts to adjacent properties including to views. The height of the pilings and the elevation of the raised vessel are relevant to these provisions.” In addition, Supplemental district regulations state, “The planning board must also find that the lifting device will provide adequate protection of neighboring property and that there is no infringement of standard navigation practices.” Clearly, code was not adhered to as the view of the waterway from neighboring properties will be entirely or greatly obstructed and impact safe navigation around the superstructure. 4. To adequately determine navigational safety, a survey between the southernmost post of the dock located at 1006 Grand Ct. to the deeded dock slip across the canal needs to be conducted. This will confirm that Mr. Touchette’s superstructure infringes upon and impedes navigational safety and creates a hazard for both the residences and boat owners. It has been determined by ATM that the fairway width is likely in violation: “Existing canal dimensions for this size/class of vessel are very tight and beyond general design standards.” 5. To ascertain the impact of Mr. Touchette’s proposed superstructure’s location change, documented approval should be required by all relevant city, state and EPA agencies. It is noted that updated surveys, HOA approval, FDEP permit and updated NAVD calculations for Mr. Touchette’s revised location for the superstructure are required, but were never completed nor enforced. 6. On 10/11/2017, the Board’s Additional Notes clearly state, “Request is for modification of the installation of an 8-post boatlift to a 10-post boatlift in the same location as the original lift that was approved - no other changes…” However, the location of the superstructure was in fact, changed. Therefore, Mr. Touchette’s submitted plans for the changes in the proposed superstructure, by definition, cannot be accepted or approved. 7. At the 7/9/20 Board meeting, Mr. Touchette was asked to discuss his plan with his neighbors, in particular Ms. Kathleen Kennedy, owner of 1005 Grand Ct.. He has yet to contact Ms. Kennedy, and has not been responsive to her attempts to discuss this matter. Page 159 8. The Board had approved 4ft. high pilings for Mr. Touchette’s boatlift. However, he disregarded the Board’s approval and independently built a frame for a boatlift consisting of over 12ft. high pilings. 9. Mr. Touchette’s 10/19/16 DOEP permit is expired. 10. It strongly appears that Mr. Touchette was not completely forthcoming and had omitted and/or falsified information he supplied to the Board in his attempt to gain approval for a superstructure. In addition to withholding information that he intended to move and increase the height of the structure, Mr. Touchette wrote in an email (dated 10/22/19) to Mary McKinney that he was incurring a monthly expense of $1900 to store his boat. Please note, that in the Board meeting on 7/9/20, Mr. Touchette explicitly stated that he still has yet to buy a boat he proposes to keep on the boatlift. It is incumbent upon the Board to review all policies and procedures under which Mr. Touchette’s superstructure has found some degree of support without having undergone or having adhered to existing rules and regulations. In doing so, the Board would be acting in the best interest of all Highland Beach waterfront properties and residents, adhere to and protect property owners, keep our navigational safety standards high and uphold property values. Your Neighbor, Kathleen Kennedy Attention: David Axelrod dzaxelrod@gmail.com Eric Goldenberg gldnbrg@gmail.com Brian DeMoss golfdemoss@aol.com Ilyne Mendelson msirm1@gmail.com John Boden jboden@elderissues.com Harry Adwar hadwar@msn.com Roger Brown rbrown@acslabtest.com Commissioners: Mayor Hillman dhillman@highlandbeach.us Page 160 Vice Mayor Babij gbabij@highlandbeach.us Commissioner Gossett-Seidman pseidman@highlandbeach.us Commissioner David edavid@highlandbeach.us Commissioner Shoemaker jshoemaker@highlandbeach.us Town Staff, Attorney and Expert Marshall Labadie, Town Manager mlabadie@highlandbeach.us Ingrid Allen, Town Planner iallen@highlandbeach.us Lanelda Gaskins, Town Clerk lgaskins@highlandbeach.us Beverly Wright, Deputy Town Clerk bwright@highlandbeach.us Town’s Email for public comments: publiccomments@highlandbeach.us Len Rubin, Town Attorney len@lgrubinpa.com Mike Jenkins, Town’s Marine Expert MJenkins@appliedtm.com Page 161 Page 162 Page 163 Page 164 Page 165 Page 166 Page 167 Page 168 Page 169 Page 170 Page 171 Page 172 Page 173 ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT RECEIVED SINCE THE JULY 9, 2020 PLANNING BOARD MEETING (19-0001) Robert Verola 08.06.2020 Page 174 Page 175 Page 176 Page 177 Page 178 Page 179 Page 180 Page 181 Page 182 Page 183 Page 184 Page 185 Page 186 Page 187 Page 188 Page 189 Page 190 Page 191 Page 192 ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT RECEIVED SINCE THE JULY 9, 2020 PLANNING BOARD MEETING (19-0001) Marc Siegel 08.06.2020 Page 193 Page 194 Page 195 Page 196 PLANNING BOARD STAFF REPORT MEETING OF: JULY 9, 2020 TO: PLANNING BOARD FROM: INGRID ALLEN, TOWN PLANNER SUBJECT: APPLICATION BY RICHARD TOUCHETTE REQUESTING AN AMENDMENT TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED TEN POST PLATFORM BOAT LIFT (APPLICATION NO. 39412) IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE HEIGHT OF THE BOAT LIFT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1006 GRAND COURT. (APPLICATION NO. 19-0001) Property Owner: 1006 Grand Court LLC 1006 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487 Applicant: Richard Touchette 1006 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487 Property Characteristics: Comprehensive Plan Land Use: Multi Family Low Density Zoning District: Residential Multiple Family Low Density (RML) Parcel PCN#: 24-43-47-09-00-002-0090 I. GENERAL INFORMATION: HIGHLAND BEACH BUILDING DEPARTMENT 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 Ph: (561) 278-4540 Fx: (561) 265-3582 Page 197 Adjacent Properties: PARCEL ZONING DISTRICT FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION North Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density South Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density East Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density West Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (RML) Multi Family Low Density Background: On February 8, 2017, the Planning Board approved a request (Application No. 39412) to install a 40,000 lb., eight (8) post platform boat lift (Attachment No. 1). On October 11, 2017, the Planning Board approved a request (Application No. 39412) to add two (2) additional posts to the previously approved eight (8) post platform boat lift (Attachment No. 2). Note that according to Town electronic records, the Planning Board item packet did not include a boat lift detail sheet (DTL-1). On May 23, 2019, the Town’s Building Official, Jeffrey Massie, issued a Stop Work Order on Permit No. 39412. According to Mr. Massie, the bottom elevation for the boat lift beam is four (4) feet and therefore “…placing the bottom of the boat lift beam at any elevation other than four (4) feet, whether it be lower or higher…” would constitute work not according to plans as defined in Florida Building Code 107.4 (Attachment No. 3). The Applicant is requesting an amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat lift (Application No. 39412) in order to increase the height of the boat lift. The Applicant’s Development Order Application (DO No. 19-0001) indicates that the height of the lifting pilings are to be modified and that the revised plans distinguish between the height of the boat lift pilings from the height of the existing dock pilings. The boat lift detail (sheet DTL-1) approved by the Planning Board, as noted above, indicates the height of the boat lift piling and the existing dock pilings at four (4) feet above the existing wood dock. The proposed boat lift detail (sheet DTL-1) provided by the Applicant electronically on May 11, 2020 (hardcopy provided on June 22, 2020) reflects the height of the boat lift pilings at 12 feet above the existing dock decking while the existing dock pilings are shown at four (4) feet above the existing dock decking. As a result, the proposed boat lift pilings are eight (8) feet higher than previously approved by the Planning Board. II. REQUEST AND ANALYSIS: Page 198 The Town Code does not provide a maximum height for dock or lift pilings. Section 30-131 of the Town Code defines “boat lifts” as the bottom of the keel of any boat shall not be hoisted greater than one foot above the minimum seawall elevation and in no case shall the lift be higher than the superstructure of the boat when lifted. In addition, Section 30-68(h) of the Town Code provides the following provisions regarding mooring facilities (Section 30-68(h)(1) of the Town Code indicates that dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, docks and moorings are collectively “mooring facilities”): -Section 30-68(h)(1)(c) They will not create a hazardous interference with navigation (this is addressed below under the Town’s consultant review), endanger life or property, or deny the public reasonable visual access to public waterways. -Section 30-68(h)(4) Shall not cause a hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the adjacent property owners or public reasonable visual access to the public waterway. Pursuant to Section 30-68(h)(3) of the Town Code, the Building Official may request evidence, prepared by a recognized marine expert, demonstrating the proposed mooring facilities will not be a hazard to navigation and will not deny reasonable visual access to public waterways. Accordingly, the Applicant’s May 11, 2020 revised plans (provided electronically) were reviewed by Applied Technology & Management, Inc. (ATM) a coastal and marine engineering consultant. Dr. Michael G. Jenkins, ATM’s Coastal Engineering Principal , provided a technical review report (Attachment No. 4) which includes the following review findings: Boat Lift Height: 1. The top of the lift beam is not shown on sheet DTL-1 but appears to be proposed in sheet DTL-2. The elevation of the lift beam relative to the design and any fixed datum is not provided. This is a material change in the structure. 2. Regarding the requested elevation, the information provided by the Applicant is insufficient to determine if the lift beam or pile height, as proposed, is necessary to meet the design intent. 3. The draft of the vessel is not presented in any supporting documentation as is the elevation relative to the lift beam. Given the intent of the lift is to raise the vessel above a nominal water level, the draft of the vessel is a determining factor in the height that the vessel needs to be raised and consequently the height of the pilings and superstructure needed for the boat lift. 4. No justification for the revised plan dimensions in terms of function or need. 5. The proposed design of the boat lift shows a keel lift elevation of approximately five (5) feet above Mean High Water (MHW). It is unclear why the vessel needs to be raised to this height. The Town Code includes consideration of impacts to adjacent properties including views and therefore the height of the piles and elevation of the raised vessel are relevant to these provisions and require justification regarding the proposed design elevations. Dr. Jenkins recommends that as a basis for design evaluation and justification of impacts, additional information and justification is needed with regards to the lift pile elevation, the inclusion of a lift beam at the top of the structure, and the design elevation for the vessel when lifted. Page 199 On June 15, 2020 the Applicant provided a response letter (dated June 12, 2020) to ATM’s report (Attachment No. 5). While ATM’s findings still stand, the following responses provided by David Nutter of B & M Marine Construction are detailed along with staff comment: 1. Mr. Nutter indicates that the lift piling height is not typically called out on plans but is approximately seven (7) feet higher than a dock surface. Therefore, Mr. Nutter indicates that the change in lift piling height is not four (4) feet to twelve feet but instead seven (7) feet to twelve feet. Staff comment: The plans approved by the Planning Board indicate the height of the lift piling and existing wood pilings at four (4) feet from the existing wood dock. Based on these approved plans, the Applicant’s proposed change to the lift pilings is from four (4) feet to twelve feet. 2. Mr. Nutter indicates that the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) and the Army Corps of Engineers have approved both the initial (eight) 8 post and subsequent 10 post boat lift. Staff comment: The Applicant had previously obtained FDEP approval (Self Certification File No. 0355323001EE); however, based on the Applicant’s most recent FDEP self-certification document on file, dated June 24, 2017, the self-certification automatically expired since construction of the project was not completed within one (1) year from the self certification date. As noted above, the Town’s coastal and marine engineering consultant, ATM, recommends that as a basis for design evaluation and justification of impacts, additional information and justification is needed with regards to the lift pile elevation, the inclusion of a lift beam at the top of the structure, and the design elevation for the vessel when lifted. If the Planning Board decides to approve the Applicant’s request, staff recommends the following conditions which are based on the Applicant’s plans set, date stamped received by the Building Department on June 22, 2020: 1. Following approval by the Planning Board and prior to initiation of construction, the Applicant will be required to obtain a building permit (prior permit No. 39412 expired on May 30, 2020) from the Town of Highland Beach Building Department. 2. Prior to issuance of a building permit and pursuant to Section 30-35 of the Town Code of Ordinances, costs incurred by the Town’s expert, ATM, must be fully reimbursed by the Applicant. 3. Prior to issuance of a building permit, the Applicant shall provide approvals by both the Florida Department of Environmental Protection and the United States Army Corps of Engineers. 4. Pursuant to Section 30-21(g)(2) of the Town Code, completion of all conditions of approval shall occur within two (2) years following the date of approval by the Planning Board. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (561) 637-2012 or iallen@highlandbeach.us III. Recommendation Page 200 Page 201 Page 202 8/8/20,19 /. AT&T Yahoo Mail -Fwd: 1006 Grand Court-Boat lift ---- Provide a brief descrh,tion of the project: Request for 2nd modification for' height of lift pilings - revision to plans to show height of lift 9ilings as differentand sepa·rate from height of existitfi dock pilings; plans to show an specify that _height of 11ft ��u1pment to be ."? _h1gh�r an sL1perstructure of vessel as per Code of Ordinances, Section 30-1 �1. Defin1t1ons of Terms:-3'., ,. . I.give permissi,on to the_ me1nbers of the Planning Board an� staff to inspect the property for. the purpose of this ·app_lic.ition. i dec:lare tlla� ail stateme,nts_ n,ade he.rein are tnl�, based._ upo,u· tbe b.cs:t ava�la�le . inform.ation, and f understan_d that wHlful false statementSand the like are misderi1eanors of th� _second degree,�ri��r Se�,ti�n 837 .. 0A,fiori4,a S_t�hit�s: Such\villful f!llse_stut�rti.ents(li�yjeopardize thtvai1dity of . my Apppcatiqn O(Jmj· dec_is:ion issueq ·the,r�<>fli . I hi_ive_ ·ru11y read lQ_e. infomiaUon outlinin,g the �OardPf9���ur_�� Jlll�, applicalib!l requfrements.· With this app }.�.at�_on, l an1 sui:miitiing the nf!ces:sary s_: upporting matenals listed .. · . . . '\. \ , . . . ,\PPlicaai'sSi�•\aaire:���� D.ate:IIU�, J chH . . . . . . . . - 7· ,• : .. ·. ' -_-.• -.---- . . . --.-.: .. - -. - ... - - - - - - -. - - ---- --- - - - - . .. -- - - .. - - -. - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - -. -. -. By :�-:A· �Jb.!,..W..:C::.����� . . . . . . . . Prelintlnary R.eview: _._' final Re�iew: _·_. Amended Site Plan: --,-��!!=---=:::----- 0 Plans meet Town ofHighlaitd Beach Zoatng and other governme�tal agencies requirements. -.. -.. •. :· .. . .· . . -· ·._. .. ; ' □Plans; til�t ToWJtPf #ighJ�d;. �each Zoning requiremerits, h�wever, approvals are pending with other ·governmental agencies requirnments. D ··:Plans.do not meet Town ofHighlnnd Beach Zoning requirements. Building Otficial Sign��t1re: -----------------,---. Date: _____ _ Date: fuJ/'4 2,0LOJUN 16 2020 Page 203 REQUIRED ATTACHMENT TO THE DEVELOPMENT ORDER APPLICATION Before any Development Order shall be issued the Board shall make written findings certifying compliance with the specific rules governing individual Development Orders, and that satisfactory provisions and arrangements have been made concerning the following, where applicable: Infonnation you provide will assist the Planning Board to determine whether your application meets the minimum criteria for obtaining a Development Order as described in Chapter 30 Zoning Code, Article 3 Development Review of the Code of Ordinances. Use additional pages if necessary. The Planning Board will not consider reference to a development order a complete response to the issue. Address the issues one at a time and be as detailed as possible. Attach additional sheets if necessary. A.Building orientation: Buildings shall be oriented to enhance the appearance of the streetscape.l.Building orientation shall ensure that service areas are placed out of view from public rights-of-way, parking areas, and adjacent properties. Where, because of site constraints service areas can not be so located, such areas shall be screened fromview by vegetative or structural means. Any structural screening shall be architecturally compatible with the principal building in terms of style, colors, construction materials, and finish. 2.Mass, bulk, and scale of all structures shall be compatible with other structures and uses both in the same zoning district and in the neighborhood. NA -installation of boat lift -no change to �uilding This modification will not impact or effect building onentaflon. B.Refuse service areas:l.Refuse service areas shall be located in a manner that minimizes impacts to adjacent residential properties. 2.Refuse service areas shall be screened from adjacent properties and right s-of-way by an enclosure that is constructed of durable building materials such as concrete, stone, or brick. The enclosure sh(lll be faced with the same style as the �ade of the primary structure on the site. The gate to the enclosure shall have a similar appearance as the fa�dc of the building. The enclosure shall be the same color as the primary structure. 3.Enclosures shall be large enough and located in a manner that service vehicles can access the dumpster while it is in the enclosure.NA • installation of boat lift -no change to upland areas This modificat ion will not impact or effect refuse areas. C.Mechanical equipment op eration and location:I.Mechanical equipment shall be located in a manner that minimizes impacts to adjacent residential properties. 2.Mechanical equipment, including equipment located on roofs shall be screened from view of adjacent residential properties and rights-of-way. Screening shall be of a material that is consistent with the architectu� of the buiJ.ding. NA -installation of boat lift -no change to building accessories or equipment This modification will not impact or effect mechanical equipment. D.Lighting:l.Outdoor lighting shall be manged so that the light source is shielded from adjacent residential properties and rights-of-way. Light fixtures shall a type that directs the light downward. 2.Outdoor lighting shall be arranged so that no portions of adjacent residential properties are covered by the light shadow. There shall be no glare or spillover effect of lighting from the property on which a development order is approved to adjacent properties, and all lighting shall comply with the Palm Beach County Code, relating to safeguarding nesting female andhatchling marine turtles from sources of artificial light Page 204 -NA -installation of boat lift -no change to site lighting This modification will not impact or effect lighting. E.Landscaping and trees: Please refer to Chapter 28 Xeriscape-Landscape Requirements, Installation and Maintenancein the Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinances.NA -installation of boat lift -no change to landscaping This modification will not impact or effect landscaping or trees. F, Signs: Please refer to Chapter 23 Signs and Advertisement in the Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinances.NA -installation of boat lift -no change to signage ..... This modification will not impact or effect signage. G.Walls a,nd Fences: Please refer to Chapter 6 Building and Structures; Article 5 Seawalls; Bulkheads; Retaining Wallsin the Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinances.Additional Notes: NA --installation of boat lift-no change to or installation of walls or fences This modification will not impact or effect walls or fences. Request is for modification of the installation of an 40000Ib 8-post boatlift to a 40000Ib 10-post boatlift in the same location as the original lift that was approved - no other changes to the upland property are expected or included in this request This second modification is for the height of the lift pilings and lift equipment, to be hi her than that allowed b the Code of Ordinances, Section 30-131, Definitions of Terms. The location, position, imens1ons, size an capacI o I wt remain as approved previously with the first modification noted above. Page 205 ---·· ----�(-·-·-1111111111111111111111 CFN 201.001.93112 OR BK 23864 PG 0738 nus INSTRUMENf PREPARED BY AND RETURN TO: RECORDED 05/25/2018 11: 44: 57 Edgar A. Benes, Esq. Pal■ Beach County, Florida 1 A. BENES, P.A.AftT 3, 101,108. H W CORPORA TE BL VD Doc Sta■p 21, 781.110 RATON. FLORIDA 33431 Sharon R. Bock, CLERK & CO"PTROLLER Jppraisers Parcel Identification (Folio) N�bers: 24-43-47-09-00--08'40ff38 - 739; <2pgs) �o \?,.1, Space Above This Line For Recording Data ____ �----- THIS ,,.-z,�.n.i., DEED, made the 14th day of May, 2010 by Clair Vaoderschaaf, a herein called the Grantor, to 1006 Grand Court LL� a Florida limited y, whose post office address is 101, Rue Lenoir, Suite A-501, Montreal, Quebec, Ca.oa:u.,p4C 2Z6, hereinafter called the Grantee: (Wherever us herein the terms ''grantor" dnd ''grantee" include all the parties to this instrument and tlii§iJeirs, legal representatives and assigns of individuals, and the successors and assigns of co,f'�ns) W I T N E S S E T :�:"�-�' .. nt the Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN AND ·00/I00'S ($10.00) Do,Y-"':>'"-""'d other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is herebyacknowledged, hereby �gains, sells, aliens, remises, releases, conveys and confmns unto the Grantee all that ce,'W'��d situate in PALM BEACH County, State of Florida, viz.: A parcel of land in Sec 9, Township 47 South, Range 43 East, Palm Beach County, Florida, being mo�ularly d�ribed as follows: Commencing at the point of • tion of the North line of said Section 9 and the West right-of-way line of State A-1-A as laid out and in use (100-foot rigbt-of-way); thence South 89 ° 52' 10" 'w;..6#:inloug said North line of Section 9, a distance of 470.58 feet; thence South 000 0 ,,._,.,..,.,.ast, a distance of 123.95 feet to the Point of Beginning; thence South 29 ° 17' 3 ' , a distance of 95.93 feet; thence South 55° 27' 31" West, a distance of 221.46 feet; thence South 46° 03' 41" West, a distance of 10.32 feet; thence North 29° 37' 29" West, a distance of 52.43 feet; thence North 60° 14' 43" East, a distance of 68.28 feet; thence North 2!)0 00' 02" West, a distance of 38.58 feet; thence North 51° 10' 50" East, a distance of 164.62 feet to the Point of Beginning. a/k/a Lot 6 and the southeasterly 35.68 feet of Lot 7, Grand Cay Estates, unrecorded. Subject property is not now nor bas ever been the Homestead Property of Clair Vanderscbaaf. Clair Vanderscbaaf resides at 1622 Glen Echo Road, Nashville, TN 37215. SUBJECT TO easements, restrictions, reservations, conditions, declarations, limitations, easements, right of way and zoning ordinances, if any, provided that this shall not serve to re-impose same and taxes for the current year and all subsequent years. File No: 2811-063 Page 206 ( TOGETHER, with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. "'!i'�")"1:1e grantor hereby covenants with said Grantee that the grantor is lawfully seized of said l&mMIJ)1ee simple; that the Gnmtor has good right and lawful authority to sc;ll and convey said Ian , . d hweby warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all �s whomsoever; and tliat said land is free of all encumbrances, except taxes accruing subseq�o December 31, 2009. . IN �REOF, the said grantor has si gned and sealed these presents the day and year first ab�n. Signed, sealed �ivered in the presence of: Clair Vanderschaaf 1622 Glen F.cho Road, Nashville, TN 3721S Witness #2 Printed Name @ STATE OF TENNESSEE �COUNTY OF .(vr#E.,eP-oA!!P � The foregoing instrument was acknowl�before me this _Lfj_ day of May, 2010 by Clair . Vanderschaaf who is personally known to me or has produced _________ _ ::-�i-� �,\\\11111111,,,,, N Public �,,, \. MOJl�'''"" #',."\ .. � ....•.. If;,,..� f�/··sTATE····:::-� Jud b•fYkrt-lW-::: --s_. OF \ 'i - • • -Printed Notary Namei* i TENNESSEE }* i s : NOTARY �-s\ •••• PU8UC •• � �� .. .. � riJ,. •• •• � '"+f..l'(i:······· !,.\# "Vlittn,1111111\"''� File No: 2811--063 My Commission Expi, -�, May 21, 2011 P::1ae 2 of 2 Page 207 WINCHESTER DESIGN GROUP INC. NAVAL ARCHITECTURE AND MARINE ENGINEERING 11948 NORTH 152nd STREET JUPITER, FLORIDA 33478-3577 TEL: 954 977-9777 / 561 744-770 FAX: 954 977-3166 Attn: Richard Touchette Via email: jetversion@hotmail.com January 21st, 2020 Ref: Fountain Powerboats, 48 EC (Express Cruiser) Dear Richard, [Pa� ©���4�f{j' MAY 11 2020 HIGHLAND BEAChBUILDING DEPARTMENT This letter is to confirm that I have communicated with Iconic Marine Group, builders of the Fountain 48 Express Cruiser to confirm dimensions of the 2000 to 2009 model, specifically the overall height of the boat to the top of the superstructure. Iconic has stated that when the vessel's keel line is horizontal, the height from the lowest part of the keel to the tallest part of the superstructure is twelve feet, two inches, (12'-2"). Definition -"Superstructure" As a naval architect trained in yacht design, the term "superstructure" is defined as being the fixed portion of the sides and roof of any deckhouse, cabin, cabin top, coachroof or other accommodation generating space that is located above the main deck. If there are additional decks above the main deck, then the additional deck would also be included in the term "superstructure". From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superstructure :- A superstructure is an upward extension of an existing structure above a baseline. This term is applied to various kinds of physical structures such as buildings. bridges. or ships having the degree of freedom zero (in the terms of theory of machines). Specifically Aboard ships and large boats :-As stated above, superstructure consists of the parts of the ship or a boat. including sailboats. fishing boats. passenger ships. and submarines. that project above her main deck. This does not usually include its masts or any armament turrets. The drawing over page shows a side view of the Fountain 48 Express Cruiser with five items called out in red. Those five items are as follows:- 1/ The drawing shows two arrows to the "Top of Fixed Fiberglass Roof-Highest Point of Superstructure". This is the top of the superstructure by any nautical definition including the wikipedia definition shown above. 2/ The drawing shows a single arrow to the "Top of the Forward Deck-Not to be confused with the top of the superstructure ". This forward deck is the main deck in the forward part of the boat. Under any nautical definition, including the wikipedia definition above. this deck is not part of the superstructure. The superstructure is any fixed portion of the deck house or cabin structure above this deck. So, the fixed windows, fixed roof. etc., located above this deck all are defined as part of the superstructure. Page 208 WINCHESTER DESIGN GROUP INC. NAVAL ARCHITECTURE AND MARINE ENGINEERING I &@j�©�DW/�fQ)I' MAY 11 2020 3/ The drawing shows an angular measurement of "1.7 deg. tr m". H™ ,%1�1�,.of 1 :3 7 degrees, is the maximum bow up angle that still allows the overall h · tJt t'Cfea,.M)� as when the boat is level. The ability of the boat to maintain the overall heig range of trim is due to the stepped hull design of the Fountain. This stepped hull allows for a small amount of bow up storage trim without increasing the overall height. 4/ The drawing shows a vertical dimension of "12 ' 2" per Iconic Marine". This is the dimension from the underside of the keel to the top of the superstructure. 5/ The drawing shows a vertical dimension "Overall Height Remains Constant up to 1.7 degrees Bow Up Trim". This is the constant height measurement discussed in item 3/ above. Please see over page for the above described drawing. In conclusion, the overall height of the 2002 to 2009 model Fountain 48 SC (Express Cruiser, from the underside of the deepest point on the keel to the highest point of the permanent superstructure is shown by the builder to be twelve feet and two inches. Please do not hesitate to call or write if you have any questions. Sincerely, � ••ctroolcSlgMt,�to,,~u '"" Peter Gimpel President PG/je Page 209 CNERAI.L MElCHT OOWNS CONSTAAi UP TO 1.7 DEGREES BOif UP TRll,I D-�� TOP Of flXEO flllERGtASS ROOF -ttGl£ST POIIT Of 5IJf'ERSl1lUCT\ TOP OE F0AWNIO DEC>< HOT TO 8( CONfV$E0 WITH T0fl' OF SUP'EftSTftUCT\ ITI == """" n.llllMMQIHOWl'OIICMIW.1.teCiKTO!lltEIXIO TO:llllltM0011.l'ICll.lffMil ... DPREIICfl..atM �rtJCDC-.CUll'IENTaaJliOIO,fl,e PCUffAINMNll!C'JF�TI. THl�Ma01ttCWaTHIIWllliUrll9CM'�,.-. ltM.TSTU.w.wf .... MCWBWJ,tealTATHOf l,oallWtlHl!HDaHT'MetMCNmNl'H.. .aaJJN3'1.flDl8>snumJllll'lffltl.Mlll)teafl' CR"-'ICMAJIOIMJ'MI..C...altA!'Cll:I) ffllLIC1\IIIEWITH LMTIDHDOHT'.1HIAC1\W. \UNI. WJ11T•CHeCICl!Df'1011t.""''IOITO,._ICCIJC...wfe --- WINCHESTER DESIGN GROUP M'f.lt.�W,i,lall.lall:- Page 210 Page 211 Page 212 Page 213 Page 214 HIGHLAND BEACH BUILDING DEPARTMENT 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 Ph: (561) 278-4548 DATE: January 31, 2017 TO: Planning Board MEmNG OF: February 8, 2017 SUBJECT: 1006 Grand Court FROM: Kenneth Bauer, Building Official I.GENERAL INFOIMATION: AppUcant Richard Touchette Property Owner Name: Address: 1006 Grand Court LLC/Touchette 1001 Rue Lenoir Ste A50 l Montreal QC H4C 27 6, Canada PLANNING BOARD STAFF REPORT Property Charaderisttcs Zoning District: Site Location: RML Residential Multiple-Family Low Density 1006 Grand Court Parcel PCN#: 24-43-47-09-00-002-0090 Request The applicant is proposing the installation of a Platform Boat Lift. Page 215 PLANNING BOARD 1006 Grand Court Property Application # 39412 II.ZONING AND LAND USE: January 31, 2017 Page 2 of 3 The table below lists the zoning district, existing land use for the subject site and surrounding area. I Parcel Zoning District Existing Land Use Subject SHe RML, Residential Multiple-Family RML, Residential Multiple-Family Low Density Low Density I RML, Residential Multiple-Family RML, Residential Multiple-Family North Low Density LowDensitv South RML, Residential Multiple-Family RML, Residential Multiple-Family Low Density Low Density East RML Residential Multiple-Family RML, Residential Multiple-Family Low Densitv Low Density West RML, Residential Multiple-Family RML, Residential Multiple-Family Low Density (Water) Low Density {Water) Ill. ANALYSIS: Existing Condition The subject property consists of Single Family Residence. Proposed Changes The applicant is proposing the installation of a 40,000 lb., eight-post platform boat lift. Development Standards Highland Beach Code of Ordinances, Property Development Regulations, Section 30-68(h). , � • I• • -,.., ,IV. •�PMMENDA'JK)NS; •' .. ., . . . ' . ' '.,' ,;, ... ,' . ��· ,,: � ...... - ... �,-, _, , .. ; The Town of Highland Beach Building Department has reviewed the construction documents submitted by the applicant and has found that the proposed Boatlift Installation does comply with the Highland Beach Code of Ordinances. Page 216 PLANNING BOARD 1006 Grand Court Property Application # 39412 V.OTHER MATTERS: January 31, 2017 Page 3of 3 The Building Official has reviewed the application and submitted documents on January 31, 2016, and hereby certifies the following action was taken: [8J Plans meet Town of Highland Beach Zoning and other governmental agencies requirements. D Plans meet Town of Highland Beach Zoning requirements; however, approvals are pending before the Town of Highland Beach will issue permits, with other governmental agencies as listed: D Plans do not meet Town of Highland Beach Zoning requirements. Should you have any further questions with regards to the matter please feel free to contact me at (561) 278-4540 or kbauer@hlghlandbeach.us Respectfully Submitted, Kenneth Bauer, Building Official Town of Highland Beach <. Page 217 Transmit To: Valerie Oakes. Town Clerk Date: December 07, 2016 Application No: #39412 Mr. Richard Touchette Applicant/Owner: Applicant-1006 Grand Court. LLC / Touchette. Owner- Property Address: 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, FL 33487 Submit Application: PLANNING BOARD Application Type: Site review/Public hearing Description of Application: Applicant proposes installation of a 40,000 lb., 8 post platform boatlift, at subject property, 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach. Florida, in the RML (Residential Multi-Family Low Density) zoning district. :.=----O�FFICIAL HAS REVIEWED THE ABOVE MATTER DATED December 07. 2016, AND ..,c-,..::.-,__�t=-I THAT THE FOLLOWING ACTION WAS TAKEN: Plans meet own of Highland Beach Zoning and other governmental agencies requirements. Plans m t Town of Highland Beach Zoning requirements; however, approvals are pending with other go mental agencies. Plans do not meet Town of Highland Beach Zoning requirements. Recommendation: The Building-Departn,ent bas r�vie\Ved the submitted. construction docun,entsJor t��. proposed installation. of a..40,000 16 •• 8 postplatform boatlift, at subject property. the installation meets requirements of Highland Beach. Code of Qrdinances. Section• 30�68(h); EVER ACTION IS REQUIRED TO COMPLETE THE SUBJECT MATTER, i.e., , TRANSMIT TO QUASI-JUDICIAL BOARD, cfC. g Official CLERK'S OFFICE USE ONLY: Date of Hearing/Regular Meeting: al¼ 7 Date Received: \ 2--;1 l V' Page 218 DOROTHY JACKS== . tm::er:r1l"IIY:ftl&ilt@'IW Oft Cf A, AAS Palm Beach County Propetty·�aiser Location Address 1006 GRAND CT Municipality HIGHLAND BEACH Parcel Control Number 24-43-47-09-00-002-0090 Subdivision Official Records Book 23864 Page 738 Sale Date MAY-2010 Homestead Exemption Ill r��\GF.ri��� ,.Jr,J J fi di.O f1 i ! !-fii�;-tL . .1.i\•r. �� ::� 1\(::1 ! • c��i!L:_�1rd:: �·:.:?; .. /.t�--r.\1f:·f'-1-r ir .. .-- ....... -..... .. legal Descript'on 9-47-43, LT 6 & SELY 35.68 FT OF LT 7 UNREC GRAND CAY ESTS IN N 1/2 OF1 GOV LT 2 AS IN ORl 0274P1371 Mailing address Owners l 006 GRAND COURT LLC 1001 RUE LENOIR STE AS0l MONTREAL QC H4C 226 CANADA Sales Date Price OR Book/Page Sale Type Owner MAY-2010 $3,l 00,000 23864 / 00738 WARRANTY DEED 1006 GRAND COURT LLC DEC-2007 $4,000,000 2231 S / 01438 WARRANTY DEED VANDERSCHMF CLAIR JAN-2004 $10 16483 / 00263 QUIT CLAIM SOLLINS CHARLES D & DEC-2003 $2,675,000 16483 / 00260 WARRANTY DEED SOLLINS CHARLES D & AUG-2003 $2,500,100 15798 / 01898 CERT OF TITLE WACHOVIA BANK 1 2 No Exemption Information Available. Number of Units l *Total Square 11614 Acres 0.4099 Feet U C d 0100 -SINGLE z . RMM • Multi-Famlly Medium-Density ( 24-HIGHLANDse O e FAMILY onmg BEACH ) Tax Year 2016 201S 2014 Improvement Value $2,956,880 $2,995,479 $2,695,829 Land Value $551,600 $424,308 $375,494 Total Market Value $3,508,480 $3,419,787 $3,071,323 All values are as of January 1st each year Tax Year 2016 2015 2014 Assessed Value $3,330,839 $3,028,035 $2,752,759 Exemption Amount $0 $0 $0 Taxable Value $3,330,839 $3,028,035 $2,752,759 Tax Year 2016 2015 2014 Ad Valorem $60,497 $59,514 $55,771 Non Ad Valorem $170 $170 $175 Total tax $60,667 $59,684 $55,946 See f� 4 or na (r) tO\J\h'\er-s http://pbcgov.com/papa/Asps/PropertyDetail/PropertyDetail.aspx?parceI=24434709000020090& Page 1 of I ) 1/5/2017 Page 219 Detail by Enti� Name Florida Department of State Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Q�.m_\l By Document Number. / Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company 1006 GRAND COURT LLC Filing lnfonnation Document Number FEI/EIN Number Date Flied Effective Date State Status Last Event Event Date Flied Event Effective Date Principal Address 1006 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487 Changed: 04/12/2013 Mailing Address 103 Beloeil street L10000045722 46-0525501 04/28/2010 04/28/2010 FL ACTIVE LC AMENDMENT 11/08/2011 NONE Outremont, Quebec H2V221 CA Changed: 04/12/2013 Registered Agent Name & Address EDGAR A. BENES, P.A. 2300 NW CORPORATE BLVD SUITE 322 BOCA RATON, FL 33431 Authorized Person(s) Detail Name & Address TitleMGRM AMEREIT LP Page I of2 DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=EntityName&directionTy... 1/5/2017 Page 220 Detail by Enti� N arne1 Q3 Beloeil street Outremont, Quebec H2V2Z1 CA Annual Reports Report Year 2014 2015 2016 Filed Date 04/07/2014 02/06/2015 04/06/2016 Document Images 04/06/2016 --ANNUAL REPORT 02/06/2015 --ANNUAL REPORT 04/07/2014 --ANNUAL REPORT 04/12/2013 --ANNUAL REPORT 02/01/2012 --ANNUAL REPORT 11/08/2011 --LC Amendment 01/05/2011 --ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format View image in PDF format View image in PDF format View image rn PDF formal View image rn PDF format View image m PDF format View image in PDF format 04/28/2010 --Flonda Limited Liability! .... __ vi_ew_,m_a_g_e_m_P_D_F_f_or_m_a_t _ ___, Florida Department of State D1v1�1on of Corporations Page 2 ofi http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=EntityName&directionTy... 1/5/2017 Page 221 Revenu Quebec -Information statement Quebec Search for an enterprise In the Register Page 222 Page 223 Revenu Quebec -Information statement Attorney No information was dedared. Administrators of the property of others There is no administrator of the property of others. Establishments No establishment was dedared. Documents being processed Page 3 of 4 No document is currendy being processed by the Enterprise Registrar. Index of documents Documents maintained Type of document Annual updating dedaration for 2016 Annual updating declaration for 2015 Annual updating declaration for 2014 Annual updating declaration for 2013 Annual updating declaration for 2012 Dedaration of registration Index of names Date of update of the index of names Name AMEREIT S.E.C. AMEREITL.P. Other names used in Quebec There are no other names used in Quebec 2011-05-27 Date filed in the Register 2016--04-13 2015-06-15 2014-03-11 2013-06-18 2012-06-04 2011-05-27 Date of declaration Date of of name declaration of 2011-05-27 Active © Revenu Quebec, 2015 Page 224 Application #--+-----I request a hearing ]\8[<y111 .1f1tti"l1\Jlf � ning Ordinances of the Town of Highland Beach. This request relates to the prope YflV tjip� s t forth in this application.PROPERTY INFORMAT ION ASSOCIATED WITH THIS APPLICATION Address: 1006 Grand Court PCN: 24-43-47-09-00-000-0090 Full �2al Description of the Propero [as d�rlbed in the deed] or reference to an attachment:9-47-43 Lot 6, Lot 7 Grand Cay Estates 1n N 1/2 of Govt Lot 2 Zoning District: RMM -Multi Family Medium Density PROPERTY OWNER INFORMATION I Name: 1006 Grand Court LLC/fouchette What is the location of the installation? □lntracoastal Waterwa (ICW) M Interior Canal/Basin □ NI AI Phone: 514-944-6565 I Fax: Mailing Addr�: 1001 Rue Lenoir Ste A501, Montreal QC H4C 276 Canada Email Address: APPLICANT INFORMATION I Name: Richard Touchette I Phone: 514-944-6565 j Fax: Mailing Add.re�: 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, FL 33487 Email Address: nutt3839@bellsouth.net (David Nutter@ B & M Marine Construction) 95-Y-r;.21 ,,,, /?a rJ ARCHITECT/DESIGNER I INFORMATION Name: j Phone: I Fax: Mailing Addre�: Email Address: DEVEOPMENT ORDER REQUEST I Rezoning: Special Exceptions: □Rezoning by a Property Owner or Party Other than □Boat Basinsthe Town Mi Boat LiftsSite Plan: □Change of Nonconforming Use□Site Plan Multifamily and Non-Residential □Dwelling, Single-Family, Zero Lot Line□Essential Public Service Structures□Site Plan Review, Major Modification □Houses of Worship□Site Plan Single-Family, Located on a Single Lot □Off-Premises Parking□Site Plan Single-Family, Located within a Larger □Perpendicular Docking of BoatsProject Other: □Post Offices□Recreation Facilities, PublicoUtility Facilities . Page 225 Provide a brief description of the project: '.X�:'.:H\:>:lL-2:op.--,: l\ fT 0¼�.:> .:J J /.h 3-]u5i) I give p ermission to the members of the Planning Board and staff to inspect the property for the purpose of this application. I declare that all statements made herein are true, based upon the best available information, and I understand that willful false statements and the like are misdemeanors of the second· degree under Section 837 .06, Florida Statutes. Such willful false statements may jeopardize the validity of my application or any decision issued thereon. I have fully read the information outlining the Board procedures and application requirements. With this application, I am submitting the necessary supporting materials listed. Building Department Use: own of Highland Beach Zoning and other governmental agencies requirements. eet To wn of Highland Beach Zoning requirements, however, approvals are pending with other governmental agencies reg · ements. D Plans do not meet To ning requirements. Date Public Notices Mailed: _______________ _ Date: I 2-l '1 / 1 �Date Legal Advertisement Published: _____________ _ 21 J' i.l � � Page 226 REQlliRED ATTACHMENT TO THE DEVELOPMENT ORDER APPLICATION Before any Development Order shall be issued the Board shall make written findings certifying compliance with the specific rules governing individual Development Orders, and that satisfactory provisions and arrangements have been made concerning the following, where applicable: Information you provide will assist the Planning Board to determine whether your application meets the minimum criteria for obtaining a Development Order as described in Chapter 30 Zoning Code, Article 3 Development Review of the Code of Ordinances. Use additional pages if necessary. The Planning Board will not consider reference to a development order a complete response to the issue. Address the issues one at a time and be as detailed as possible. Attach additional sheets if necessary. A.Building orientation: Buildings shall be oriented to enhance the appearance of the streetscape.1.Building orientation shall ensure that service areas are placed out of view from public rights-of-way, parking areas, andadjacent properties. Where, because of site constraints service areas can not be so located, such areas shall be screened fromview by vegetative or structural means. Any structural screening shall be architecturally compatible with the principalbuilding in terms of style, colors, construction materials, and finish.2.Mass, bulk, and scale of aU structures shall be compatible with other structures and uses both in the same zoning district andin the neighborhood. NA -installation of boatlift -no change to building B.Refuse service areas:1.Refuse service areas shall be located in a manner that minimizes impacts to adjacent residential properties.2.Refuse service areas shall be screened from adjacent properties and rights-of-way by an enclosure that is constructed ofdurable building materials such as concrete, stone, or brick. The enclosure shall be faced with the same style as the fa�ade ofthe primary structure on the site. The gate to the enclosure shall have a similar appearance as the fa�ade of the building. Theenclosure shall be the same color as the primary structure.3.Enclosures shall be large enough and located in a manner that service vehicles can access the dumpster while it is in theenclosure.NA -installation of boatlift -no change to upland areas C.Mechanical equipment operation and location:1.Mechanical equipment shall be located in a manner that minimizes impacts to adjacent residential properties.2.Mechanical equipment, including equipment located on roofs shall be scree_ned from view of adjacent residential propertiesand rights-of-way. Screening shall be of a material that is consistent with the architecture of the building.NA -installation of boatlift -no change to building accessories or equipment D.Lighting:1.Outdoor lighting shall be arranged so that the light source is shielded from adjacent residential properties and rights-of-way.Light fixtures shall a type that directs the light downward.2.Outdoor lighting shall be arranged so that no portions of adjacent residential properties are covered by the light shadow.There shall be no glare or spillover effect of lighting from the property on which a development order is approved to adjacentproperties, and all lighting shall comply with the Palm Beach County Code, relating to safeguarding nesting female andhatchling marine turtles from sources of artificial light.31 Pa g � Page 227 NA -installation of boatlift -no change to lighting E. Landscaping and trees: Please refer to Chapter 28 Xeriscape-Landscape Requirements, Installation and Maintenancein the Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinances.NA -installation of boatlift -no change to landscaping F.Signs: Please refer to Chapter 23 Signs and Advertisement in the Town of Highland Beach Cod e of Ordinances.NA -installation of boatlift -no change to signage G.Walls and Fences: Please refer to Chapter 6 Building and Structures; Article 5 Seawalls; Bulkheads; Retaining Wallsin the Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinances.NA -installation of boatlift -no change to or installation of wall s or fences Additional Notes: Request is for installation of an 8-post boatlift -no other changes to the upland property are expected or included in this request 41 Pa g � Page 228 Town of Highland Beach 3614 SOUTH OCEAN BOULEVARD • HIGHLAND BEACH, FLORIDA 33487 61 278-4540 • ��;-r::::z":zi;j,:GlJS.t::..::::[5)=-i Pennit# PERMI OCT 19 2016 Ano co HIGHLAND seAcH You are ereby d84tc9I,4lsjstjed i o 111Wij<IJIIWlr¥ ions 553.7.1.7 a BllQ.ff(fi)ras�d necessa b the Town ofHighlan uiJding Depart en, to retain a profess1ona engmeer or arc a Speci o tion checked below: D 1.l ·e been certified/soil treatment certification. □2. Verify that all setbacks and elevations have been certified.D 3. Make a visual inspection of all components which cannot be inspected after fabrication.D 4. Inspect all stee1 for size and placement prior to concrete placement.D 5. Verify that all shoring and re-shoring has been certified and to check that shoring is safe.D 6. To be present and monitor all concrete placements.X 7. �spect a11 structural components of building such as, but not limited to:� Footer and/or pilings b.Slabs -on grade, above or below grade.c.Beams and Columnsd.All structural and non-structural walls.e.Fire resistive ratings for __________________ _f.Floor and Roof Trussesg.Sheathing.D 8. Special Inspector is required to make weekly written reports to Building Department. □9. Copies of all Concrete Test reports are required to be sent to Building Department.□10. Other:-------------------------------The Special Inspector shall be responsible for compliance with all applicable Building and Fire Codes and shaH submit progress and inspection reports, including concrete test reports to the Building Department. The assignment of a Special Inspector does not relieve the permit holders responsibility for inspections and approval from the Town's Building Department prior to proceeding with the work. At completion of the �ork preformed by the Special Inspector, the Special Inspector shall submit a Certificate of Compliance to the Building Department, stating that the work was done in compliance with the applicable Building and Fire Codes and the approved plans and specifications. Final Inspection shall be made by the Building Department before a Certificate of Occupancy is issued. A signed and sealed copy of this document must be submitted to the Building Department prior to issuance of a building permit. Building Department Title Date C:\Documents and Settings\zburgess\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\GROD 12UC\Special Inspector F onn.doc 4/22/02 Revised: Page I of 1 Page 229 Florida Department of Environmental Protection Richard Touchette I 006 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487 SOUTHEAST DISTRICT OFFICE 3301 GUN CLUB ROAD, MSC 7210-1 WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406 561-681-6600Sent via e-mail: nutt3839@bellsouth.net Re: File No.: 50-0345492-002,003-EE File Name: Touchette Dear Mr. Touchette: Rick Scott Governor Carlos Lopez-Cantera Lt. Governor Jonathan P. Steverson Secretary On July 5, 2016, we received your application for an exemption to (1) install a boatlift; and (2) install two mooring piles. The project is located in a man-made can al, Class III Waters, adjacent to 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, FL 33487 (Section 09, Township 47 South, Range 25 East), in Palm Beach County (Latitude N 26° 23' 37.52", Longitude W 80° 04' 07.02"). Your request has been reviewed to determine whether it qualifies for ( 1) regulatory exemption, (2) proprietary authorization (related to state-owned submerged lands), and (3) federal approval that may be necessary for work in wetlands or waters of the United States. Your project qualifies for all three. However, this letter does not relieve you from the responsibility of obtaining other federal, state, or local authorizations that may be required for the activity. 1.Regulatory Review -VERIFIEDBased on the information submitted, the Department has verified that the activities as proposed are exempt, under Chapter 62-330.0Sl(S)(a) and (5)(b), Florida Administrative Code, from the need to obtain a regulatory permit under part rv of Chapter 373 of the Florida Statutes. This exemption verification is based on the information you provided the Department and the statutes and rules in effect when the information was submitted. This verification will expire after one year, and will not be valid at any other time if site conditions materially change, the project design is modified, or the statutes or rules governing the exempt activity are amended. However, the activity may still be conducted without further notification to or verification from the Department after the one-year expiration of this verification, provided: 1) the project design does not change; 2) site conditions do not materially change; and 3) there are no changes to the statutes or rules governing the exempt activity. In the event you need to re-verify the exempt status for the wwttv.dep.state. fl. us Page 230 .File No.: 50-0345492-002,003-EE File Name: Touchette Page 2 ofS activity after the one-year expiration of this verification, a new application and verification fee will be required. Any substantial modifications to the project design should be submitted to the Department for review, as changes may result in a permit being required. Conditions of compliance with the regulatory exemption are contained in Attachment A. 2.Proprietary Review -NOT REQUIREDThe activity does not appear to be located on sovereign submerged lands, and does not require further authorization under chapter 253 of the Florida Statutes, or chapters ·18-20 or 18-21 of the Florida Administrative Code. 3.Federal Review -SPGP APPROVEDYour proposed activity as outlined on your application and attached drawings qualifies for Federal authorization pursuant to the State Programmatic General Permit V, and a separate permit or authorization will not be required from the Corps. Please note that the Federal authorization expires on July 26, 2021. You, as permittee, are required to adhere to all General Conditions and Special conditions that may apply to your project." A copy of the SPGP V with all terms and conditions and the General Conditions may be found at http://www.saj.usace.army.mil/Divisions/Regulatory/sourcebook.htm. Authority for review -an agreement with the USACOE entitled "Coordination Agreement Between the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Jacksonville District) and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, or Duly Authorized Designee, State Programmatic General Permit", Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbor Act of 1899, and Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. Additional Information Please retain this letter. The activities may be inspected by authorized state personnel in the future to insure compliance with appropriate statutes and administrative codes. If the activities are not in compliance, you may be subject to penalties under Chapter 373, F.S., and Chapter 18-14, F.A.C. NOTICE OF RIGHTS This action is final and effective on the date filed with the Clerk of the Department unless a petition for an administrative hearing is timely filed under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, F.S., before the deadline for filing a petition. On the filing of a timely and sufficient petition, this action will not be final and effective until further order of the Department. Because the administrative hearing process is designed to formulate final agency action, the filing of a petition means that the Department's final action may be different from the position taken by it in-this notice. Petition for Administrative Hearing A person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department's action may petition for an administrative proceeding (hearing) under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, F.S. Pursuant to Rule 28-106.201, F.A.C., a petition for an administrative hearing must contain the following information: (a)The name and address of each agency affected and each agency's file oridentification number, if known;Page 231 .File No.: 50-0345492-002,003-EE File Name: Touchette Page 3 ofS (b)The name, address, any email address, any facsimile number, and telephone numberof the petitioner; the name, address, and telephone number of the petitioner'srepresentative, if any, which shall be the address for service purposes during the course ofthe proceeding; and an explanation of how the petitioner's substantial interests are or willbe affected by the agency determination;( c)A statement of when and how the petitioner received notice of the agency decision;( d)A statement of all disputed issues of material fact. If there are none, the petitionmust so indicate;( e)A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, including the specific facts thatthe petitioner contends warrant reversal or modification of the agency's proposed action;(f)A statement of the specific rules or statutes that the petitioner contends requirereversal or modification of the agency's proposed action, including an explanation of howthe alleged facts relate to the specific rules or .statutes; and(g)A statement of the relief sought by the petitioner, stating precisely the action thatthe petitioner wishes the agency to take with respect to the agency's proposed action.The petition must be filed (received by the Clerk) in the Office of General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000. Also, a copy of the petition shall be mailed to the applicant at the address indicated above at the time of filing. Time Period for Filing a Petition In accordance with Rule 62-110.106(3), F.A.C., petitions for an administrative hearing by the applicant must be filed within 21 days of receipt of this written notice. Petitions filed by any persons other than the applicant, and other than those entitled to written notice under Section 120.60(3), F.S. must be filed within 21 days of publication of the notice or within 21 days ofreceipt of the written notice, whichever occurs first. Under Section 120.60(3), F.S., however, any person who has asked the Department for notice of agency action may file a petition within 21 days of receipt of such notice, regardless of the date of publication. The failure to file a petition within the appropriate time period shall constitute a waiver of that person's right to request an administrative detennination (hearing) under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, F.S., or to intervene in this proceeding and participate as a party to it. Any subsequent intervention (in a proceeding initiated by another party) will be only at the discretion of the presiding officer upon the filing of a motion in compliance with Rule 28-106.205, F.A.C. Extension of Time Under Rule 62-110.106(4), F.A.C., a person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department's action may also request an extension of time to file a petition for an administrative hearing. The Department may, for good cause shown, grant the request for an extension of time. Requests for extension of time must be filed with the Office of General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000, before the applicable deadline for filing a petition for an administrative hearing. A timely request for extension of time shall toll the running of the time period for filing a petition until the request is acted upon. Page 232 Enclosures: Copies furnished to: Page 233 .File No.: 50-0345492-002,003-EE File Name: Touchette Page 5 of5 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned duly designated deputy clerk hereby certifies that this determination, including all copies, was mailed before the close of business on August 2, 2016, to the above listedpersons. FILING AND ACKNOWLEDGMENT FILED, on this date, pursuant to 120.52(9), Florida Statutes, with the designated Department Clerk, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged. Clerk August 2, 2016 Date Page 234 . Attachment A Chapter 62-330.051 Exempt Activities. The activities meeting the limitations and restrictions below are exempt from pennitting. However, if located in, on, or over state-owned submerged lands, they are subject to a separate authorization under Chapters 253 and 258, F.S., and Chapters 18-18, 18-20, and 18-21, F.A.C., as applicable. (5)Dock, Pier, Boat Ramp and Other Boating-related Work-(a)Installation or repair of pilings and dolphins associated with private docking facilities or piers thatare exempt under Section 403.813(l)(b), F.S.;(b)Installation of private docks, piers, and recreational docking facilities, and installation of localgovernmental piers and recreational docking facilities, in accordance with Section 403 .813( 1 )(b ), F .S.This includes associated structures such as boat shelters, boat lifts, and roofs, provided:1.The cumulative square footage of all structures located over wetlands and other surface watersdoes not exceed the limitations in Section 403.813(1)(b), F.S.; 2.No structure is enclosed on more than three sides with walls and doors;3.Structures are not used for residential habitation or commercial purposes, or storage of materialsother than those associated with water dependent recreational use; and 4.Any dock and associated structure shall be the sole dock as measured along the shoreline for aminimum distance of 65 feet, unless the parcel of land or individual lot as platted is less than 65 feet in length along the shoreline, in which case there may be one exempt dock allowed per parcel or lot. Page 235 Attachment B File No.: 50-0345492-002,003-EE ST ATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AL PROTECTION NOTICE OF DETERMINATION OF EXEMPTION The Department ofEnvironmental Protection gives notice that the projects to ( 1) instalJ a boatlift; and (2) install two mooring piles has been determined to be exempt from requirements to obtain an Environmental Resource Permit. The project is located in a man-made canal, Class III Waters, adjacent to 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, FL 33487 (Section 09, Township 47 South, Range 25 East), in Palm Beach County (Latitude N 26° 23' 37 .52", Longitude W 80° 04' 07.02"). A person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department's action may petition for an administrative proceeding (hearing) under sections 120.569 and 120.57 of the Florida Statutes. The petition must contain the information set forth below and must be filed (received by the clerk) in the Office of General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000. Mediation is not available. If a timely and sufficient petition for an administrative hearing is filed, other persons whose substantial interests will be affected by the outcome of the administrative process have the right to petition to intervene in the proceeding. Intervention will be pennitted only at the discretion of the presiding officer upon the filing of a motion in compliance with rule 28-106.205 of the Florida Administrative Code. In accordance with rule 62-110.106(3), F.A.C., petitions for an administrative hearing must be filed within 21 days of publication of the notice or receipt of written notice, whichever occurs first. Under rule 62-110.106(4) of the Florida Administrative Code, a person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department's action may also request an extension of time to file a petition for an administrative hearing. The Department may, for good cause shown, grant the request for an extension of time. Requests for extension of time must be filed with the Office of General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000 prior to the applicable deadli ne . A timely request for extension of time shall toll the running of the time period for filing a petition until the request is acted upon. Upon motion by the requesting party showing that the failure to file a request for an extension of time before the deadline was the result of excusable neglect, the Department may also grant the requested extension of time. The petitioner shall mail a copy of the petition to the applicant at the address indicated above at the time offiling. The failure of any person to file a petition for an administrative hearing within the appropriate time period shall constitute a waiver of that right. A petition that disputes the material facts on which the Department's action is based must contain the following infonnation: (a)The name and address of each agency affected and each agency's file or identification number, if known; (b)The name, address, and telephone number of the petitioner; the name, address, and telephone number of the petitioner's representative, if any, which shall be the address for service purposes during the course of the proceeding; and an explanation of how the petitioner's substantial interests are or will be affected by the agency determination; (c)A statement of when and how the petitioner received notice of the agency decision; ( d)A statement of all disputed issues of material fact. If there are none, the petition must so indicate;(e)A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, including the specific facts the petitioner contends warrant reversal or modification of the agency's proposed action; (f)A statement of the specific rules or statutes that the petitioner contends require reversal or modification of the agency's proposed action; and (g)A statement of the relief sought by the petitioner, stating precisely the action that the petitioner wishes the agency to take with respect to the agency's proposed action. A petition that does not dispute the material facts on which the Department's action is based shall state that no such facts are in dispute and otherwise shall contain the same information as set forth above, as required by rule 28-106.301. Under sections 120.569(2)(c) and (d) of the Florida Statutes, a petition for administrative hearing shall be dismissed by the agency if the petition does not substantially comply with the above requirements or is untimely filed. Complete copies of all documents relating to this determination of exemption are available for public inspection during nonnal business hours, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday, at the Southeast District office, 3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210· 1, West Palm Beach, Florida 33406. Page 236 General Conditions for Federal Authorization for SPGP V 1.The time limit for completing the work authorized ends on July 26, 2021. 2.You must maintain the activity authorized by this permit in good condition and in conformance with the terms and conditions of this permit. You are not relieved of this requirement if you abandon the permitted activity, although you may make a good faith transfer to a third party in compliance with General Condition 4 below. Should you wish to cease to maintain the authorized activity or should you desire to abandon it without a good faith transfer, you must obtain a modification of this permit from this office, which may require restoration of the area. 3.If you discover any previously unknown historic or archeological remains while accomplishing the activity authorized by this permit, you must immediately notify this office of what you have found. We will initiate the Federal and State coordination required to determine if the remains warrant a recovery effort or if the site is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. 4.If you sell the property associated with this permit, you must obtain the signature of the new owner on the enclosed form and forward a copy of the permit to this office to validate the transfer of this authorization. 5.If a conditioned water quality certification has been issued for your project, you must comply with the conditions specified in the certification as special conditions to this permit. 6.You must allow representatives from this office to inspect the authorized activity at any time deemed necessary to ensure that it is being or has been accomplished in accordance with the terms and conditions of your permit. Further Information: 1.Limi'ts of this authorization. a.This permit does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, State, or local authorizations required by law. b.This permit does not grant any property rights or exclusive privileges. c.This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others. d.This permit does not authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal projects. 2.Limits of Federal Liability. In issuing this permit, the Federal Government does not assume any liability for the following: a.Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of other permitted or unpermitted activities or from natural causes. Page 237 b.Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of current or future activities undertaken by or on behalf of the United States in the public interest. c.Damages to persons, property, or to other permitted or unpermitted activities or structures caused by the activity authorized by this permit. d.Design or Construction deficiencies associated with the permitted work. e.Damage claims associated with any future modification, suspension, or revocation of this permit. 3.Reliance on Applicant's Data: The determination of this office that issuance of this permit is not contrary to the public interest was made in reliance on the information you provided. 4.Reevaluation of Permit Decision: This office may reevaluate its decision on this permit at any time the circumstances warrant. Circumstances that could require a reevaluation include, but are not limited to, the following: a.You fail to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit. b.The information provided by you in support of your permit application proves to have been false, incomplete, or inaccurate (see 3 above). c.Significant new information surfaces which this office did not consider in reaching the original public interest decision. 5.Such a reevaluation may result in a determination that it is appropriate to use the suspension, modification, and revocation procedures contained in 33 CFR 325. 7 or enforcement procedures such as those contained in 33 CFR 326.4 and 326.5. The referenced enforcement procedures provide for the issuance of an administrative order requiring you comply with the terms and conditions of your permit and for the initiation of legal action where appropriate. You will be required to pay for any corrective measures ordered by this office, and if you fail to comply with such directive, this office may in certain situations (such as those specified in 33 CER 209.170) accomplish the corrective measures by contract or otherwise and bill you for the cost. 6.When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time the property is transferred, the terms and conditions of this permit will continue to be binding on the new owner(s) of the property. To validate the transfer of this permit and the associated liabilities associated with compliance with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign and date the enclosed form. 7.The Permittee understands and agrees that, if future operations by the United States require the removal, relocation, or other alteration, of the structures or work herein authorized, or if, in the opinion of the Secretary of the Army or his authorized representative, said structure or work shall cause unreasonable obstruction to the free navigation of the navigable waters, the Permittee will be required, upon due notice from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, to remove, relocate, or alter the structural work or obstructions caused Page 238 Department of the Army Permit Transfer for SPGP V Page 239 STANDARD MANATEE CONDITIONS FOR IN-WATER WORK 2011 The permittee shall comply with the following conditions intended to protect manatees from direct project effects: a.All personnel associated with the project shall be instructed about the presence of manatees and manatee speed zones, and the need to avoid collisions with and injury to manatees. The permittee shall advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties for harming, harassing, or killing manatees which are protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act, the Endangered Species Act, and the Florida Manatee Sanctuary Act. b.All vessels associated with the construction project shall operate at "Idle Speed/No Wake" at all times while in the immediate area and while in water where the draft of the vessel provides less than a four-foot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will follow routes of deep water whenever possible. c.Siltation or turbidity barriers shall be made of material in which manatees cannot become entangled, shall be properly secured, and shall be regularly monitored to avoid manatee entanglement or entrapment. Barriers must not impede manatee movement. d.All on-site project personnel are responsible for observing water-related activities for the presence of manatee(s). AU in-water operations, including vessels, must be shutdown if amanatee(s) comes within 50 feet of the operation. Activities will not resume until the manatee(s) has moved beyond the 50-foot radius of the project operation, or until 30 minutes elapses if the manatee( s) has not reappeared within 50 feet of the operation. Animals must not be herded away or harassed into leaving. e.Any collision with or injury to a manatee shall be reported immediately to the FWC Hotline at 1-888-404-3922. Collision and/or injury should also be reported to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in Jacksonville (1-904-731-3336) for north Florida or Vero Beach (1-772- 562-3909) for south Florida, and to FWC at lmperiledSpecies@myFWC.com f.Temporary signs concerning manatees shall be posted prior to and during all in-water project activities. All signs are to be removed by the permittee upon completion of the project. Temporary signs that have already been approved for this use by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) must be used (see MyFWC.com/manatee). One sign which reads Caution: Boaters must be posted. A second sign measuring at least 81/2" by 11" explaining the requirements for "Idle Speed/No Wake" and the shut down of in-water operations must be posted in a location prominently visible to all personnel engaged in water-related activities. Questions concerning these signs can be sent to the email address listed above. Page 240 CAUTION: MANATEE HABITAT All project vessels IDLE SPEED/ NO WAKE When a manatee is within 50 feet of work all in-water activities must SHUT DOWN Report any collision with or injury to a manatee: Wildlife Alert: 1-888-404-FWCC (3922)cell * FWC or #FWC Page 241 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE Southeast Regional Office 263 l 3th A venue South St. Petersburg, FL 33701 SEA TURTLE AND SMALL TOOTH SA WFISH CONSTRUCTION CONDITIONS The permittee shall comply with the following protected species construction conditions: a.The permittee shall instruct all personnel associated with the project of the potential presence ofthese species and the need to avoid collisions with sea turtles and smalltooth sawfish. Allconstruction personnel are responsible for observing water-related activities for the presence ofthese species.b.The pennittee shall advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties forharming, harassing, or killing sea turtles or smalltooth sawfish, which are protected under theEndangered Species Act of 1973.c.Siltation barriers shall be made of material in which a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish cannotbecome entangled, be properly secured, and be regularly monitored to avoid protected speciesentrapment. Barriers may not block sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish entry to or exit from designatedcritical habitat without prior agreement from the National Marine Fisheries Service's ProtectedResources Division, St. Petersburg, Florida.d.All vessels associated with the construction project shall operate at "no wake/idle" speeds at alltimes while in the construction area and while in water depths where the draft of the vessel providesless than a four-foot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will preferentially follow deep-waterroutes (e.g., marked channels) whenever possible.e.If a sea turtle or small tooth sawfish is seen within I 00 yards of the active dailyconstruction/dredging operation or vessel movement, all appropriate precautions shall beimplemented to ensure its protection. These precautions shall include cessation of operation of anymoving equipment closer than 50 feet of a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish. Operation of anymechanical construction equipment shall cease immediately if a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish isseen within a 50-ft radius of the equipment. Activities may not resume until the protected speciesAny collision with and/or injury to a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish shall be reported immediatelyto the National Marine Fisheries Service's Protected Resources Division (727-824-5312) and thelocal authorized sea turtle stranding/rescue organization.f.Any special construction conditions, required of your specific project, outside these generalconditions, if applicable, will be addressed in the primary consultation.Revised: March 23, 2006 O:\forms\Sea Turtle and Smalltooth Sawfish Construction Conditions.doc Page 242 Google Maps 1006 Grand Ct 50-0345492-002,003-EE � )/{I Southeast District 0 Map data ©2016 Google 200 ft .. Page 1 of l 4.'12/2016 Page 243 24-43-4 7-09-00-002-0090 ermit Numbe Q 50-0345492-002,003-EE Southeast District 1:576 C O00<4:IS C!IOSS 0017,,.., t• 01( Page 244 Edge of exlsling cooaetecap JO ltO llndl•toll. �CB.S. ,_, ... EXISTING CONDITIONS SCALE 1 :s25:U � � a-• l!R ...... ____ .., Page 245 Turbidity CIJrtalns In ,_ pilings are ii New30000fb post PROPOSED CONDITIONS SCALE: i = 25:tf Page 246 I I t New SOOOO/b (8) post bost8ft 7'•5" 17'-4" Edge of exl&ting Ex1sting seawall cap conan cap and wal to lffllain 10' 52.◄3' SITE PLAN sCALE: 118" = Nr 15' I Qenerql Ngtn; 1.For oil preatressed pilings. extend pilngs strands a min. of 1s• Into cap/cloclc slob steel or cut strands even v,/ top of pfflng• & dowel & epo>cy (2) f5 L-bors, 12• long w/ 12• bend, Into top of pUings, w/ a min. of 4• embedment. 2. Dowel ond ep>cor f5 bars or L-bors Into top and fnlnt of existing cop, stoggwed 0 24• o.c., min. 4• embedment. J. New bolt• and wrtlcd pilings ond panels lo hove a minimum 4• penetraUon Into the new cop forms. -1-. New dock pilings to be min. 10• dlo, CCA treated wood pilings. 5. Concrete plllng• to b• 12•x12• preatressed pllfngs with (4) 7/16" strands. 6. All reinforcing steel shall be grade 60, with a minimum 3• cleoronce. 7. Concrete to be min. 5000 psi O 28 daya. 8. All pfflnp to be driven 8' Into strata. If hard strata Is encountered, a 2' minimum penetration rs required. 8.AU fromlng materlals to be pressure treated, Southern Yellow Pine, Grade 2 or better, min. fb • 975 PSI or better. 9. Approved contractor to verify all dimensions. The approved contractor Is responalble for all methods. meons, sequences and procedures of work. 10. Any deviation &/or substitution from the approved plans herein shall be submitted tothe Engineer for approval prior to commencement of work.11.Elevotlona ahown ore baaed on the notlonal geodetic vertical datum of 1929. 12. Design In accordanC15 with 2014 Florido BuBdlng Code. Southeast District J: I SP Page 247 rmit Num 50-0345492-002,003-EE t"' 16' �_!.1 .�� - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - BOATLIFT DETAIL SCALE: 318" = 1'-0" 23'-7" to wetface D [I] 5' Exiating seaws5 and cap to remain J: I DTL-1 Page 248 30,000-LB ALUMINUM 8-POST YACHT LIFT C PLAN VIEW Page 249 0 IMMk I0,000 Ille I POSTS BOAT LIFT IIIAIIIPARl'S UST SECTION A PILE MOUNTING DETAIL MOUNTING Brun..-=..-..,� SECTION B Page 250 --♦'Ill.at 111' 221.,S'(0) 221.Jl'(M) IS � 11!.1 '555:Zl'Jl"W :J Existing seawall cap ) I . . LEGAL DESCRIPTI and wall to remaln ' I PMCfJ. W;._fc.1�709000020050 A PNKA 0,1.MOll�.it mwtS!lr41� RANIZ.IJEAS3; 'MJl«ADfc:aM1Y. ROIIM. IDl811t116�YQt'SOllBA$n:ll.OJll5> r--::::... PAR(<F !EC'TIQI 9, � :k�{JO"°::,,�or M#afTH UN/! OF' w, .src'IIOf, NIJ k ,ar,m,r-CF-•r£Kor srAtr.lKJ.40 A-,-A AS 1..4efV' I ,u�� �1/;, 'f:1:rr 4J £AST. 1HEM%$al"$1'«nl�.SM>NatlHUEtT.sm'XW.ADISTMICCOF'7fl..Jartn ffNCCSO(l"Orjo�Atlll1NlfXOFIUMn:ETIO�r.. &EB.1Jll£J2.JJl "·/ h/1(. � r, 1/ J� 1)(.-.IIJIIII.II( ',,e.o. / EIIQll-1H3 JI. _,._ IS1£JIJIIILl[(f£111t 111>1£tlSIIJll.ll(IS SQ"IAOMl►hl } tr li ::, � 8i 0 � �°'='ffJ.;�=�:JS��we::,.s::::k���:,:Xni{�-=='"�4;��➔'� . i =�= � AlltA =�il::7a"��.:li:;��MM�a;um: It� jUf.ff'flDc.uDO'JX �IDIS AIE$1M:/,aq i :;:-:::.,:� M� Comp,/ ,41..$'UICNOIMJ.1(011� '/IE$Q/JN£4fflJII.Y.J.111RZTOi'LOT?. QIMIOCA'l'�JES(tNlfl:Oll:lal) Ill-a f& flJ..D --o--Ealllll:CI') MAP OF BOUNDARY SURVEY """'....., ... NOA1HLOTIJN£(NSl10"'°"E) HOTES'/REWSIONS EXISTING CONDITIONS SCALE: 1 •25..tf' am���u., FOUJDCD rl IHJ ---:, ----::' 8ASE1.INE: ENG/NffRING AND =:::.1-�;;;-r; ..... na;�i::"=,n:::,,�����: ::zt:J�$1:k2 w CB-6510 (561} 417-0700 W-64Jg �.,,.,_.-.OIIQ: t0-05-Dtt 96TM1 I c.i t.> � i5 � N� (i r.:i -:z:,., i5�� s � .. tii .. 1E� � P�ig � =-�!I =-�i��I �tll � ei z� � .:d��,i 8: 1Il8 .. l]:lt,).., .. L� J�i �n" �;§ �11���r!hi � §I ., r::C EC PC Page 251 fR I � I I I I ---;--=-Turbidity curtains i ll plecee f rwhile new pilings are Installed 1J I New 400001b (8) I / post boallill : / (2) new 12"x12" additional 1 / cona-ete pilings ( / Edge of existing ' I concret� �--,--!-/-1--1 I _ __y_ +/-165' MHW TO M,H.W. (N:r:s.) �C.8.5. �111'.li · 111.J' 221,"6TD) 221.Jl'(I.I} ..,-la S55'27J1'W . . :Jd PAl1C£1. I.D. f2#J47D91XXX12()(J51 . P.B.CR. � PART<£ !Enal 9. 'tlNSIP47SW111,IWIGC4JCAST, PAUi /£AC/I caJHTY � f, IDOIGl-vndOwrlUC Z. BACFkri:la� tsA� AT.WA .l c...-s.wc �.A 4.lnt�rtlt.lr.lU"lltC#�J' MAP OF BOUNDARY SURIIFY = ,. � 20· NOr<S SOI$ PROPOSED CONDITIONS SCALE: 1 ;:,25-&' T'tl'ICAI. .slllW e -• LIi fl4D --0,--. ..... ou, CAl.O /.$N01tD PC Page 252 I I I I I I I vi I 3 I I :::E g I I ::il io I I I+ I I� 38.58' I • 38.58' ,. I I I I SITE PLAN SCALE i =15-o" WATERWAY 52.43• • I General Notes· 1. For all prestressed pilings, extend pilings strands a min. of 18" into cap/dock slab steel or cut strands even w/ top of pilings & dowel & epoxy (2) f/5 L-bars, 12" long w/ 12" bend, Into top of pilings, w/ a min. of 4" embedment. 2. Dowel and epxoy f/5 bars or L-bars into top and front of existing cap, staggered 0 24" a.c., min. 4" embedment. 3. New batter and vertical pilings and panels to have a minimum 4" penetration Into the new cap farms. 4. New dock pilings to be min. 10" dio. CCA treated wood plllngs. 5. Concrete pilings to be 12"x12" prestressed pilings with (4) 7/16" strands. 6. All reinforcing steel shall be grade 60, with a minimum 3" clearance. 7. Concrete to be min. 5000 psi C 28 days. 8. All pilings to be driven 8' Into strata. If hard strata Is encountered, o 2' minimum penetration Is required. 8. All framing materials to be pressure treated, Southern Yellow Pine, Grode 2 or better, min. lb = 975 PSI or better. 9. Approved contractor to verify all dimensions. The approved contractor ls responsible for all methods, means, sequences and procedures of work. 10. Any deviation &/or substitution from the approved plons herein shall be submitted to the Engineer for approval prior to commencement of work. 11. Elevations shown are based on the national geodetic vertical datum of 1929. 12. Design ln accordance with 2014 Florida Building Code. � � 3 J: g ti'"""·\ � � •(\ � '·tii SP Page 253 SCALE: 3/B"" 1'-0" 16' New12"x12" concrete pilings Existing seawall and cap to remain r\TI Page 254 /!Poi C,1rr-1J-Covrr·/5 ot&-r 11 F, TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH Wednesday, February 82 2017 MINUTES OF THE PLANNING BOARD REGULAR MEETING 9:30AM Members Present: Chair Louis Reidenberg; Vice Chair David Axelrod; Board Member Evelyn Weiss; Board Member Harvey Mart; Board Member Charles Shane and Board Member Warren Lewis. Memb� __ Absent: Board Member Elyse Riesa .Also Attending: Assistant Town Attorne y Brian Shutt; Deputy Town Clerk Lanelda Gaskins; Building Official Ken Bauer; Lieutenant Eric Lundberg; Mayor Bernard Featherman and members of the Public. 1.CALL TO ORDER:Chair Reidenberg called the Regular Meeting to order at 9:30 AM in the Commission Chambers. Roll call was taken by Deputy Town Clerk Lanelda Gaskins followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. Chair Reidenberg thanked Vice Chair David Axelrod for standing in for him at the last meeting. 2.ADDITIONS, DELETIONS OR ACCEPTANCE OF AGENDA:Chair Reidenberg called for a motion to accept the agenda as presented. MOTION: Member Mart moved to accept the agenda as presented. Vice Chair Axelrod seconded the motion, which passed unanimously. 3.PUBLIC COMMENTS AND REQUESTS:None. 4.PRESENTATIONS:There were no presentations. 5.APPROVAL OF MINUTES:•January 25, 2017 -Special MeetingChair Reidenberg called for a motion to approve the January 25, 2017 minutes. Page 255 Planning Board Minutes Wednesday, Febmary 8, 2017 Page2 of4 MOTION: Member Mart moved to approve the January 25, 2017 Regular Meeting Minutes as presented. The motion was seconded by Member Weiss, which passed unanimously. 6.OLD BUSINESS:There was none. 7.NEW BUSINESS:A)Application No. 39412 -1006 Grand Court LLCff ouchetteCONSIDERATION OF SITE PLAN APPROVAL FOR THE PROPOSED INSTALLATION OF A 40,000 LB., 8 POST PLATFORM BOATLIFT AT SUBJECT PROPERTY, 1006 GRAND COURT, IIlGHLAND BEACH, FLORIDA, IN THE RML (RESIDENTIAL MULTI-FAMILY LOW DENSITY) ZONING DISTRICT. APPLICANT: 1006 Grand Court LLC Chair Reidenberg read the title into the record and stated that the application should reflect the name on the Palm Beach Records property sheet which is 1006 Grand Court LLC and not Touchette .. He asked the Board were there any disclosures and/or ex parte communications and there were none. The Public Hearing was opened and all witnesses giving testimony were sworn-in. Staff Presentation: Building Official Ken Bauer presented this item. The application meets the setbacks and the requirements of the Highland Beach Code· of Ordinances. It also has the approval from the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP). Chair Reidenberg -Do you feel this application should be approved? Building Official Ken Bauer - It meets all the requirements and am recommending this application be approved. Petitioner's Presentation: David Nutter, B & M Marine Construction representing the applicant. He described the type of boatlift that will be installed. The properties on the south side and the west side are lined by trees, which would block the view of the boat from the neighbors to the south and to the north. Public Comments: Lee Morris, Grand Cay Estates Homeowner' s Association spoke on behalf of 18 homeowners. We have no issue with the boat sitting in the water, but putting a boat of that size on a boatlift becomes an aesthetic eyesore for the many members in our community. Page 256 Planning Board Minutes Wednesday, February 8, 2017 Page-3 of 4 Vice Chair David Axelrod -I don't believe that we, as a committee, can make a decision based on aesthetics. Member Shane -This Board is only empowered to be certain that the application meets all the existing codes. Aesthetics is not an issue with this Board. Lee Morris-This still has to be approved by our Architectural Control Board. Chair Reidenberg -Would the Town approval be in conflict with the community's by­laws and regulations and could it cause a problem with the Town. Town Attorney Shutt -No it should not. We enforce our codes and it is up to the entity, whether it be thedeveloper or HOA, to say they have to comply with their codes.MOTION: Member Shane moved to approve Application No. 39412. The motion was seconded by Member Lewis. ROLL CALL; Member Shane Yes Member Lewis Yes Member Weiss Yes Member Mart Yes Vice Chair Axelrod -Yes Chair Reidenberg Yes Motion carried 6 to 0. B)Item 7B was removed from the Agenda.Vice Chair Axelrod commented on the traffic at the construction sites; specifically at the site directly across from Town Hall. He asked if there was any way the traffic could be controlled. Chair Reidenberg suggested this issue be directed to the Chief of Police or the Town Commission since the Planning Board has no jurisdiction over this matter. 8.ADJOURNMENT:There being no further business, Chair Reidenberg called for a motion to adjourn the meeting at 9:52 AM. MOTION: Member Mart moved to adjourn the meeting at 9:52 AM. The motion was seconded by Vice Chair Axelrod, which passed unanimously. Page 257 Planning Board Minutes Wednesday, February 8, 2017 APPROVED: TOWN SEAL ATTEST: Date: Page 258 Page 259 H�GHLAND BEACH BUILDING DEPARTMENT 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 Ph. (561) 278-4548 DATE: September 11, 2017 TO: Planning Board MEETING DATE: October 11, 2017 at 9 :30 AM SUBJECT: 1006 Grand Court. (APPLICATION NO. 039412) Applicant Richard Touchette Property Owner Name: Address: Richard Touchette 1006 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487 PLANNING BOARD STAFF REPORT Property Characteristics Zoning District: Site Location: RMM, Residential Multi-Family Medium Density 1006 Grand Court Parcel PCN#: 24-43-47-09-00-000-0090 Request Consideration of a Site Plan approval for the construction of a new platform boatlift located at subject property, 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, Florida, in the RMM Residential Multi-Family Medium Density per Town of Highland Beach Section 30-67, Uses permitted, special exception, and prohibited uses, Table 30-4 Permitted Uses. Page 260 PLANNING BOARD 1006 Grand Court Application # 039412 September 11 , 201 7 Page 2 of 3 The table below lists the zoning district, existing land use for the subject site and surrounding area. RMM, Residential Multi-Famil RMM, Residential Multi-Famil South RMM, Residential Multi-Famil RMM, Residential Multi-Famil East RMM, Residential Multi-Famil RMM, Residential Multi-Famil West lntracoastal Intra coastal Existing Condition The subject property consists of multi-family residences. Proposed Changes The applicant is proposing the installation of a new 40,000 lb., 10 post platform boatlift. Development Standards Highland Beach Code of Ordinances, Section 30-67, Uses permitted, special exception, and prohibited uses, Table 30-4 Permitted Uses. The Town of Highland Beach Building Department has reviewed the modified, previously approved, site plan and construction drawings submitted by the applicant, (Richard Touchette), and has found that the information provided does comply with the Highland Beach Code of Ordinances for Boatlifts, Section 30-67, Uses permitted, special exception, and prohibited uses, Table 30-4 Permitted Uses. Staff recommends that the application be approved based on the above stated ordinances. Page 261 PLANNING BOARD Page 262 Application # I request a hearing regarding the terms of the Zoning Ordinances of the Town of Highland Beach. This request relates to the property and zoning requirements set forth in this application. Plt()PERTT7 INFORMATION ASSQCIATED WI1'B THIS.· .. · APPLICATION. . . ·. '.· Address: 1006 Grand Court PCN: 24-43-47-09-00-002-0090 Full Le§al Descriftion of the Promrty [as described in the deed] or reference to an attachment:9-47-4 Lot 6, Lo 7 Grand Cay E tates In N 1/2 of Govt Lot 2 Zoning District: RMM -Multi Family Medium Density I What is the location of the installation?o Intracoastal Waterwav (ICW) M Interior CanaVBasinPROPERTY:OWNER INFORMATION I Name: 1006 Grand Court LLC/Richard Touchette I Phone: 514-944-6565 l Fax: Mailing Address: 1001 Rue Lenoir Ste A501, Montreal QC H4C 276 Canada Email Address: APPLICANT INFORMATION .. ·. I Name: Richard Touchette I Phone: 514-944-6565 I Fax: Mailing Address: 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, FL 33487 Email Address: nutt3839@bellsouth.net (David Nutter @ B & M Marine Construction) ARCIDTECT/DESIGNERINFC>RMATiON Name: -· Email Address: DEVEOPMENT ORDER REQUEST Rezoning: I □ Rezoning by a Property Owner or Party Othe,r than the Town Site Plan: o Site Plan Multifamily and Non-ResidentialoSite Plan Review, Major ModificationoSite Plan Single-Family, Located on a Single Lot□Site Plan Single-Family, Located within a LargerProject Other: Special Exceptions: o Boat Basins � Boat Lifts o Change of Nonconforming UseoDwelling, Single-Family, Zero Lot LineoEssential Public Service StructuresoHouses of WorshipoOff-Premises ParkingoPerpendicular Docking of BoatsoPost OfficesoRecreation Facilities, Public□ Utility Facilities □NIA Page 263 Provide a brief description of the proiect: Request is for modification of the installation of an 400001b 8-:-post boatlift to a 40000Ib 10-post boatlift in the same location as the original lift that was approved I give permission to the members of the Planning Board and staff to inspect the property for the purpose of this application. I declare that all statements made herein are true, based upon the best available information, and I understand that willful false statements and the like are misdemeanors of the second degree under Section 837.06, Florida Statutes. Such willful false statements may jeopardize the validity of my application or any decision issued thereon. I have fully read the information outlining the Board procedures and application requirements. With this application, I am submitting the necessary supporting materials listed. Applicant's Signarup__§ 7'6-,.J,,/l,,.r... � Date: _J __ ,_3,,__/....,{ },__]_. ___ _Building Department Use: I /J. / !lo f/4 ! Date Application Received: ff' ht J 7 By: Llfrb /J lf7f i I - /Preliminary Review: _, -. Final Review: __ . Amended Site Plan: L Other: tans meet Town of Highland Beach Zoning and other governmental agencies requirements. D Plans meet Town of Highland Beach Zoning requirements, however, approvals are pending with other governmental agencies requirements. D Plans do not meet Town of Highla oning requirements. Date:. Received By: --1-,,,�=-:..�..;:::::i,..---1--------Date: q 'US'/ nDate Public Notices Mailed: _9 ___ . -l 21o _____ . '-) \ _\ ]: _____ . _______ _ Date Legal Advertisement Published: _(_D ___ \ O_\_\_l __ ]:_• _____ _ Page 264 REQUIRED ATTACH1\1ENT TO THE DEVELOPMENT ORDER APPLICATION Before any Development Order shall be issued the Board shall make written findings certifyin:g compliance with the specific rules governing individual Development Orders, and that satisfactory provisions and arrangements have been made concerning the following, where applicable: Information you provide will assist the Planning Board to determine whether your application meets the minimum criteria for obtaining a Development Order as described in Chapter 30 Zoning Code, Article 3 Development Review of the Code of Ordinances. Use additional pages if necessary. The Planning Board will not consider reference to a development orde.r a complete response to the issue. Address the issues one at a time and be as detailed as possible. Attach additional sheets if necessary. A.Building orie�tation: Buildings shall be oriented to enhance the appearance of the streetscape. 1.Building orientation shall ensure that service areas are placed out of view from public rights-of-way, parking areas, andadjacent properties. Where, because of site constraints service areas can not be so located, such areas shall be screened fromview by vegetative or structµral means. Any structural screening shall be architecturally compatible with the principalbuilding in terms of style, colors, construction materials, and finish.2.Masst bulk, and scale of all structures shall be compatible with other structures and uses both in the same zoning district andin the neighborhood. NA -installation o.f boat lift -no change to �uilding B.Refuse service areas:l.Refuse service areas shall be located in a manner that minimizes impacts to adjacent residential properties.2.Refuse service areas shall be screened from adjacent properties and rights-of-way by an enclosure that is constructed of c;lurable building materials such as concrete, stone, or brick. The enclosure shall be faced with the same style as the fa�ade of the prii:nary structure on the site. The gate. to the enclosure shall have a simi_lar appear�ce as the fa�ade of the building. The·enclosure shalt be tbe same color as the primary structure.3.Enclosures shall be large enough and located in a manner that service vehicles can access the dumpster while it is in theenclosure. NA • installation of boat lift -no change to upland areas C.Mechanical equipment operation and location:1.Mechanical eqw.pnient shaU be l<,>cated in a manner that minimizes impacts to adjacent residential properties.2.Me�hanical equipment, including equipment located on roofs shall be screened from view of adjacent residential propertiesand rights-of-way. Screening shall be of a material that is consistent with the architecture of the building.NA -installation of boat lift -no change to building accessories or equipment D.Lighting:I.Outdoor lighting shall be arranged �o that the light source is shielded from adjacent residential properties and rights-of-way.Light fixtures shall a type that directs the light downward.2.Outdoor lighting shall be arranged so that no portions of adjacent residential properties are cov�red by the light shadow.There shall be no glare or spillover effect of lighting from the property on which a development order is approved to adjacentproperties, and all lighting shall comply with the Palm Beach County Code, relating to safeguarding nesting female andbatchling marine turtles from sources of artificial light Page 265 -· -NA-installation of boat lift -no change to site lighting E.Landscaping and trees: Please refer to Chapter 28 Xeriscape-Landscape Requirements, Installation and Maintenancein the Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinances.NA -installation of boat lift -no change to landscaping F,. Signs: Please refer to Chapter 23 Signs and Advertisement in the Town of Highland Be,ach Code of Ordinances. NA -installation of boat lift-no change to signage_ .... G.Walls and Fences: Please refer to Chapter 6 Building and Structures; Article 5 Seawalls; Bulkheads; Retaining Wallsin the Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinances. NA --installation of boat lift -no change to or installation of walls or fences Additional Notes: Request is for modification of the installation of an 40000Ib 8-post boatlift to a 40000Ib 10-post boatlift in the same location as the original lift that was approved - no other ch_anges to the upland property are expected or included in this request 41 P �! �-: Page 266 e, . TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH AUTHORIZED AGENT AFFIDAVIT . �, R, q:,,.N?-,D 1>iJcB,fUt , the �lmd.Jv��➔-grant authorization to]),-._\\-JV) l()\Jif:l'lt_ . , Authorized Agent, to act in my behalf with the Town of Highland BeachBuilding Department while conducting activities related to obtaining pennits. These activities specifically includesigning aH documents requiring signature of "contractor". )) t:" � )0) :N \hr1n1. , Authorized Agent, is to be considered an agent of my business andtherefore the signature of said agent is binding and causes me to assume all responsibilities connected to orassociated with the signature as they may relate to my contrac ing business. D . -<' _. ; .,, \)u;--\'fjt_ (hll�� I N ( B �w �uJ l l4);. TIZ? . , ' �fieve tfie Town of Highland Beach of, and agree tohold the Town of Higliland Beach Building Department harmless from, any and all responsibility, claims or otheractions arising from or related to the Department's acceptance of the above agent's signature for permit-relatedactivities. I further understand that it is my sole responsibility to grant and terminate any such authorization and toensure that the D'!art. ment recei�'\ly notice of anysu��tenninat. ion. '\:p-9-R���=-_J_ ·. , �---Signature ofCoAtraGtor OL:Vt..1·e � A f('L\ C'A &u i Signature ·Agent4 .�� -- _.,,...,,..;; CL<£Y:r�,q-;J-!J l��,\"'-.N"�t\�� Co,��n�--�-t'Nc.) State Certification or Registration Number ' 1 · • County Certification Number (if applicable)***PLEASE NOTE: BOTH SIGNATURES MUST BE NOTARIZED*** Notary for Contractor's Signature: State of floc,&.c......County o�ro�&The foregoing was acknowledged before me this:t8 day of S� 7 O\.') , by '>s, \t'OCM:0 >Ni<!½ 9 ,wt.. who is personally known to me, or who producedas identification.ot���--w Notary Pu� ignatfu)e Notary for Agent's Signature: State of .c;\.t>��County o��o-.cd>The foregoing was acknowledged before me this'2.8 day of S�� 'u!>l."1 , by w0'.-U°'-O �u, \,\.Jr ,who is personally known to me, or who producedas identification.Print,TJ,e Building Departnumt, at its discretio11, may require a co11tractor or licens a btlildiiig permit notwitl1standl11g miy autl,orlzation allowilig anotl,er person to apply for or obta/11 any permit on behalf of a co11tractor, qualifier, or llcense­holder. Page 267 ,Subj-ac�: FDEP ERP Self-Certification Receipt From: no-reply@dep.state.fl.us (no-reply@dep.state.fl.us) AUG O 9 2017 To: Cc: Date: nutt3839@bellsouth.net; . •··; �:; 1i, �t;rJ'._-f:i�:i�·::>:·-:--· .· / ROBERT.B.BARRON@USACE.ARMY.MIL; ERP.SELFCERTS@dep:statetif?:_'.i�;\,�EML�J::j ·. NMFS.SER.PROGRAMMATICREVIEW@NOAA.GOV; FDEP-SP@USACE.ARMY."'J!IL·G _: .CJ 2 4 2017 Saturday; June 24, 2017 12:28 PM i ! •· ···------: Florida Department of Environmental Protection Bob Martinez Center 2600 Blair Stone Road Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2400 Receipt for Submission SELF CERTIFICATION FOR Rick Scott Governor Carlos Lopez-Cantera Lt. Governor Noah Valenstein Secretary A PROJECT AT A PRIVATE, SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE 06/24/2017 _ V 1.: ;!T!�t � �0:,. ... -,._ ,-\I· _: ' ";, H •l;, -�' . � . --�·",;. . � r, .· ,. ' , Self Certification File No.: 0355323001EE C)E . ��) � i,_, · :File Name: 1006 Grand Ct Highland Beach, FL 3348, ' -Self-Certification Modify With Boat Lift ( General) Dear David Nutter: On, 06/24/2017, you used the Florida Department of Environmental Protection's electronic Self Certification Process to certify compliance with the terms and conditions of the Federal State Programmatic General Pennit (SPGP) Self Certification Process for a project at priyate, single-family residence located at: · -.,, · LAT-Degr,ees: 2'6 Minutes: 23 Seconds: 37.4035 LONG -Degrees: .. go Minut-es: 4 Seconds: 7.0146 SITE ADDRESS: 1006 Grand Ct Highland Beach, FL 33487 COUNTY: Palm Bea,ch Page 268 For: Richard Touchette 1006 Grand Court Boca Raton, FL 33487 You have certified that the project you propose to construct at the above location meets all the conditions of the Self-Certification Process. A project that is built in confonnance to those conditions (attached for reference) will: 1.Qualify for a regulatory exemption under Section 403.813(l)(b) of the Florida Statutes (F.S.) andChapter 62-330, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.). As such, it is exempt from the need to obtain aDEP Environmental Resource Permit.;2.Qualify for Consent by Rule or Letter of Consent (as applicable) under Chapter 253, F.S. and Chapter18-21, F.A.C. (and Chapter 258, F.S. and Chapter 18-20, F.A.C., if applicable); when the project islocated on submerged lands owned by the State of Florida.;Your Self-Certification is based solely on the information you provided under this process, and applies only to the statutes and rules in effect when your certification was completed. The certification is effective only for the specific project proposed, and only if the project is constructed, operated, and maintained in conformance with all the tenns, conditions, and limitations stated in the Self-Certification Process. In addition, any substantial modifications in your plans should be submitted to the Department for review, as changes may result in a permit being required. You have acknowledged that this Self Certification will automatically expire if: 1.Construction of the project is not completed within one year from the self-certification date;2.site conditions materially change;3.the terms, conditions, and limitations of the Self Certification are not followed; or4.the governing statutes or rules are amended before construction of the project.Completion of the Self Certification constitutes your authorization for Department or Corps personnel to enter the property for purposes of inspecting for compliance. Receipt of this Self-Certification constitutes authorization to use sovereignty/state-owned submerged lands, as required by rule 18-21.005, F.A.C. The authorization must be visibly posted during all construction activities. In waters that are accessible to manatees, obtain information on your mandatory Manatee Protection sign by clicking here. FEDERAL STATE PROGRAl"IMATIC GENERAL PERJ.'\UT (SPGP) You have certified that the project you propose to construct at the above location meets all the conditions of the SPGP Self-Certification Process and will be built in conformance to those conditions (attached for reference). Your proposed activity as certified is in compliance \vith the SPGP program. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) Specific conditions apply to your project, attached. No further pennitting for this activity i:5 required by the Corps. In the event of the transfer of o'vvnership of the property by sale or by any other means. when the structures or work authorized by this SPGP Self-Certification are still in existence at the time the Page 269 Page 270 •Attachments: FDEP Terms and Conditions Johnson's Seagrass Conditions Aquatic Vegetation Guidelines Sea Turtle And Sawfish Conditions SPGP Terms and Conditions SPGP Transfer Letter --' 'liltlttt:\:: Attachments •Untitledl.2.jpeg (42.54KB)•75d8498c69518b33c02b386a7d4adb65.pdf (51.08KB)•102e 113d8fe6e69e518b35f9b3747bd.pdf (54.59KB)•JohnsonSeaGrassConditions_l_0l.pdf (131.85KB)• Aquatic VegetationGuidelines _ 1_01.pdf (80.34KB)•SeaTurtleAndSawFishConditions _ l _ 0 1.pdf ( 101.84KB)•5989d96le37dc2e8f2acdafl541 b52e.pdf (2.08KB)Page 271 Florida Department of Environmental Protection Bob Martinez Center 2600 Blair Stone Road Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2400 TERMS AND CONDITIONS Self Certification File No.: 0355323001EE Construction Conditions: Rick Scott Governor Carlos Lopez-Cantera Lt. Governor Noah Valenstein Secretary Private residential single family docks are subject to the following criteria in accordance with Section 403.813(1)(b), F.S. The dock to be constructed: 1.Has 1,000 square feet or less over water surface (includes adjacent wetlands) in accordance withChapter 62-340, F.A.C.;2.Is constructed on or held in place by pilings and is constructed so as not to involve filling or dredgingother than that necessary to install the pilings;3.Will not substantially impede the flow of water, cause water pollution, or create a navigationalhazard;.4.Is used ONLY for recreational, noncommercial activities associated with the mooring or storage of boats and boat paraphernalia;. 5.Is the sole dock on the parcel; and6.Must not be subject to any conservation easement or restrictive covenant of record prohibiting theactivity.Boat lifts are subject to the following additional conditions: 1.Is to be installed in a proposed slip or, at or adjacent to the waterward end of the dock;2.With other mooring will not result in the mooring of more than two vessels (including jet skis);3.Will not substantially impede the flow of water, cause water pollution, or create a navigationalhazard;4.Will not be located in areas prohibited for mooring by a previously issued permit or other form ofauthorization issued by a local government;Page 272 General Conditions for Sovereignty/State-Owned Submerged Lands Authorizations: Any use of sovereignty/state .. owned submerged lands is subject to the following general conditions that are binding upon the applicant and are enforceable under Chapters 253, F.S. or Chapters 258, F.S. 1.Sovereignty/state-owned submerged lands may be used only for the specified activity or use. Anyunauthorized deviation from the specified activity or use and the conditions for undertaking thatactivity or use will constitute a violation. Violation of the authorization will result in suspension orrevocation of the applicant's use of the sovereignty/state-owned submerged lands unless cured to thesatisfaction of the Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust Fund (Board).2.Authorization under Rule 18-2 l.005, F.A.C., conveys no title to sovereignty/state-owned submergedlands or water column, nor does it constitute recognition or acknowledgment of any other person'stitle to such land or water.3.Authorizations under Rule 18-21.005, F.A.C., may be modified, suspended or revoked in accordancewith its terms or the remedies provided in Sections 253.04, F.S. or Chapter 18-14, F.A.C.4.Structures or activities will be constructed and used to avoid or minimize adverse impacts toresources.5.Construction, use, or operation of the structure or activity will not adversely affect any species whichis endangered, threatened or of special concern, as listed in Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and68A-27.005, F.A.C.;6.Structures or activities will not unreasonably interfere with riparian rights. When a court ofcompetent jurisdiction determines that riparian rights have been unlawfully affected, the structure oractivity will be modified in accordance with the court's decision.7.Structures or activities will not create a navigational hazard.8.Structures will be maintained in a functional condition and will be repaired or removed if theybecome dilapidated to such an extent that they are no longer functional.9.Structures or activities will be constructed, operated, and maintained solely for water dependentpurposes.10.The applicant agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the Board and the State of Florida fromall claims, actions, lawsuits and demands in any form arising out of the authorization to usesovereignty/stateowned submerged lands or the applicant's use and construction of structures onsovereignty/state-owned submerged lands. This duty to indemnify and hold harmless will includeany and all liabilities that are associated with the structure or activity including special assessmentsor taxes that are now or in the future assessed against the structure or activity during the period of theauthorization.11.Failure by the Board to enforce any violation of the authorization or waiver by the Board of'anyprovision of the authorization will not invalidate the provision not enforced or waived, nor will thefailure or waiver prevent the Board from enforcing the waived or unenforced provision in the eventof a future violation of that provision.12.Applicant binds itself a nd its successors and assigns to abide by the provisions and conditions setforth in the authorization. If the applicant or its successors or assigns fails or refuses to comply with Page 273 ·the provisions and conditions of the authorization, the authorization may be terminated by the Boardafter written notice to the applicant or its successors or assigns. Upon receipt of such notice, theapplicant or its successors or assigns will have thirty (30) days in which to correct the violations.Failure to correct the violations within this period will result in the automatic revocation of thisauthorization.13.All costs-incurred by the Board in enforcing-the terms-and conditions of the authorization .w.ilLbe ..paid by the applicant. Any notice required by law will be made by certified mail at the address shownon page one of the authorization. The applicant will notify the Board in writing of any change ofaddress at least ten days before the change becomes effective.14.This authorization does not allow any activity prohibited in a conservation easement or restrictivecovenant of record that prohibits the activity.Manatee Conditions: The following conditions are intended to protect manatees from direct project effects; THESE CONDITIONS APPLY ONLY IN WATERS THAT ARE ACCESSIBLE TO MANATEES: 1.All personnel associated with the project will be instructed about the presence of manatees andmanatee speed zones, and the need to avoid collisions with and injury to manatees. The permitteewill advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties for harming,harassing, or killing manatees which are protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act, theEndangered Species Act, and the Florida Manatee Sanctuary Act.2.All vessels associated with the construction project will operate at 'Idle Speed/No Wake' at all timeswhile in the immediate area and while in water where the draft of the vessel provides less than afour-foot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will follow routes of deep water whenever possible.3.Siltation or turbidity barriers will be made of material in which manatees cannot become entangled,will be properly secured, and will be regularly monitored to avoid manatee entanglement orentrapment. Barriers must not impede manatee movement.4.All on-site project personnel are responsible for observing water-related activities for the presence ofmanatee(s). All in-water operations, including vessels, must be shutdown if a manatee(s) comeswithin 50 feet of the operation. Activities will not resume until the manatee(s) has moved beyond the50-foot radius of the project operation, or until 30 minutes elapses if the manatee(s) has notreappeared within 50 feet of the operation. Animals must not be herded away or harassed intoleaving.5.Any collision with or injury to a manatee will be reported immediately to the FWC Hotline at1-888-404-FWCC. Collision and/or injury should also be reported to the U.S. Fish and WildlifeService in Jacksonville (1-904-731-3336) for north Florida or Vero Beach (1-772-562-3909) forsouth Florida.►6. Temporary signs concerning manatees will be posted prior to and during all in-water projectactivities. All signs are to be removed by the permittee upon completion of the project. Awareness signs that have already been approved for this use by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC} must be used (see MyFWC.com). One sign which reads Caution: Boaters must be posted. A second sign measuring at least 8 1/2' by 11' explaining the requirements for 'Idle Page 274 Speed/No Wake' and the shut down of in-water operations must be posted in a location prominently visible to all personnel engaged in water-related activities. Self-Certification Requirements: The user agrees to the following: 1.The information provided herein is true and accurate.2. Construction of the project must be completed within one year from the self-certification date. If theproject cannot be completed within that time frame, or the project is to be modified, the Departmentmust be contacted for authorization requirements.3. Any substantial modifications in the plans for this project must be submitted to the Department forreview, as changes may result in a permit being required.4.This self-certification will automatically expire if site conditions materially change; if the terms,conditions, and limitations of the self-certification are not followed; or if the governing statutes orrules are amended before the project is completed.5.Department personnel will be allowed to enter the property for purposes of inspecting the project forcompliance with the terms and conditions of this self-certification.Page 275 Florida Department of Environmental Protection Bob Martinez Center 2600 Blair Stone Road Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2400 Rick Scott Governor Carlos Lopez-Cantera Lt Governor Noah Valenstein Secretary CONDITION FOR THE DEPART1\.1ENT OF THE ARMY SELF-CERTIFIED STATE PROGRAl\fMATIC GENERAL PERl\fiT FOR A PROJECT AT A PRIVATE, SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE Self Certification File No.: 035532300 lEEGeneral Conditions: 1.The time limit for completing the work authorized on July 26, 2021.2.You must maintain the activity authorized by this permit in good condition and in conformance withthe terms and conditions of this permit. You are not relieved of this requirement if you abandon thepermitted activity, although you may make a good faith transfer to a third party in compliance withGeneral Condition 4 below. Should you wish to cease to maintain the authorized activity or shouldyou desire to abandon it without a good faith transfer, you must obtain a modification of this pennitfrom this office, which may require restoration of the area.3.If you discover any previously unknown historic or archeological remains while accomplishing theactivity authorized by this permit, you must immediately notify this office of what you have found.We will initiate the Federal and State coordination required to determine if the remains warrant arecovery effort or if the site is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places.4.If you sell the property associated with this permit, you must obtain the signature of the new owneron the enclosed form and forward a copy of the permit to this office to validate the transfer of thisauthorization.5.If a conditioned water quality certification has been issued for your project, you must comply withthe conditions specified in the certification as special conditions to this permit.6.You must allow representatives from this office to inspect the authorized activity at any time deemednecessary to ensure that it is being or has been accomplished in accordance with the terms andconditions of your permit.Further Information: l . Limits of this authorization:a.This permit does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, State, or local authorizationsrequired by law.b.This permit does not grant any property rights or exclusive privileges.c.This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others.d.This permit does not authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal projects.2.Limits of Federal Liability. In issuing this permit, the Federal Government does not assume anyliability for the following:a.Damages to the pennitted project or uses thereof as a result of other permitted or unpermittedactivities or from natural causes.b.Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of current or future activities Page 276 undertaken by or on behalf of the United States in the public interest. c.Damages to persons, property, or to other permitted or unpermitted activities or structures causedby the activity authorized by this permit.d.Design or Construction deficiencies associated with the permitted work.e.Damage claims associated with any future modification, suspension, or revocation of this permit.3.Reliance on Applicant's Data: The determination of this office that issuance of this permit is notcontrary to the public interest was made in reliance on the information you provided.4.Reevaluation of Permit Decision: This office may reevaluate its decisio·n on this permit at any timethe circumstances warrant. Circumstances that could require a reevaluation include, but are notlimited to, the following:a.You fail to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit.b.The information provided by you in support of your permit application proves to have been false,incomplete, or inaccurate (see 3 above).c.Significant new information surfaces which this office did not consider in reaching the originalpublic interest decision.5.Such a reevaluation may result in a determination that it is appropriate to use the suspension,modification, and revocation procedures contained in 33 CFR 325.7 or enforcement procedures suchas those contained in 33 C� 326.4 and 326.5. The referenced enforcement procedures provide forthe issuance of an administrative order requiring you comply with the terms and conditions of yourpermit and for the initiation of legal action where appropriate. You will be required to pay for anycorrective measures ordered by this office, and if you fail to comply with such directive, this officemay in certain situations (such as those specified in 33 CER 209.170) accomplish the correctivemeasures by contract or otherwise and bill you for the cost.6.When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time the property istransferred, the terms and conditions of this permit will continue to be binding on the new owner( s)of the property. To validate the transfer of this permit and the associated liabilities associated withcompliance with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign and date the enclosed form.7.The Permittee understands and agrees that, if future operations by the United States require theremoval, relocation, or other alteration, of the structures or work herein authorized, or if, in theopinion of the Secretary of the Army or his authorized representative, said structure or work shallcause unreasonable obstruction to the free navigation of the navigable waters, the Permittee will berequired, upon due notice from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, to remove, relocate, or alter thestructural work or obstructions caused thereby, without expense to the United States. No claim shallbe made against the United States on account of any such removal, relocation or alteration.Manatee Conditions: 1.All personnel associated with the project will be instructed about the presence of manatees andmanatee speed zones, and the need to avoid collisions with and injury to manatees. The pennitteewill advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties for harming,harassing, or killing manatees which are protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act, theEndangered Species Act, and the Florida Manatee Sanctuary Act.2.All vessels associated with the construction project will operate at '"Idle Speed/No Wake" at all timeswhile in the immediate area and while in water where the draft of the vessel provides less than afourfoot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will follow routes of deep water whenever possible.3.Siltation or turbidity barriers will be made ofmaterial in which manatees cannot become entangled,will be properly secured, and will be regularly monitored to avoid manatee entanglement orentrapment. Barriers must not impede manatee movement.4.All on-site project personnel are responsible for observing water-related activities for the presence ofmanatee(s). All in-water operations, including vessels, must be shutdown if a manatee(s) comeswithin 50 feet of the operation. Activities will not resume until the manatee(s) has moved beyond the50-foot radius of the project operation, or until 30 minutes elapses if the manatee(s) has not Page 277 ·reappeared within 50 feet of the operation. Animals must not be herded away or harassed intoleaving.5.Any collision with or injury to a manatee will be reported immediately to the FWC Hotline at1-888-404-FWCC. Collision and/or injury should also be reported to the U.S. Fish and WildlifeService in J acksonviUe ( 1-904-731-3336) for north Florida or Vero Beach ( 1-772-562-3909) forsouth Florida.6.Temporary signs concerning manatees will be posted prior to and during all in-water projectactivities. All signs are to be removed by the pennittee upon completion of the project. Awarenesssigns that have already been approved for this use by the Florida Fish and Wildlife ConservationCommission (FWC) must be used (see MyFWC.com). One sign which reads Caution: Boaters mustbe posted. A second sign measuring at least 8 ½" by 11,, explaining the requirements for "IdleSpeed/No Wake" and the shut down of in-water operations must be posted in a location prominentlyvisible to all personnel engaged in water-related activities.Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Conditions: 1.Avoidance. The piling-supported structure will be aligned so as to minimize the size of the footprintover SA V beds.2.The height of piling-supported stru�ture will be a minimum of 5 feet above .MHW/OHW asmeasured from the top surface of the decking.3.The width of the piling-supported structure is limited to a maximum of 4 feet. A turnaround area isallowed for piling-supported structures greater than 200 feet in length. The turnaround is limited to asection of the piling-supported structure no more than 10 feet in length and no more than 6 feet inwidth. The turnaround will be located at the midpoint of the piling-supported structure.4.Over-SAY bed portions of the piling-supported structure will be oriented in a north-south orientationto the max.imum extent that is practicable.5.Terminal Platfoans:a.If possible, terminal platforms will be placed in deep water, waterward of SA V beds or in an areadevoid of SA V beds.b.If a terminal platform is placed over SA V areas and constructed of grated decking, the total size ofthe platform will be limited to 160 square feet. The grated deck material will conform to thespecifications stipulated below. The configuration of the platform will be a maximum of 8 feet by 20feet. A minimum of 5 feet by 20 feet will conform to the 5-foot height requirement; a 3 feet by 20feet section may be placed 3 feet above MHW to facilitate boat access. The long axis of the platformshould be aligned in a north-south direction to the maximum extent that is practicable.c.If the terminal platform is placed over SA V areas and constructed of planks, the total size of theplatform will be limited to 120 square feet. The configuration of the platform will be a maximum of6 feet by 20 feet of which a minimum 4-foot wide by 20-foot long section will conform to the 5-footheight requirement. A section may be placed 3 feet above MHW to facilitate boat access. The 3 feetabove MHW section will be cantilevered. The long axis of the platform should be aligned in anorthsouth direction to the maximum extent that is practicable. If the 3 feet above lVIHW section isconstructed with grating material, it may be 3 feet wide.6.Pilings will be installed in a manner which will not result in the formation of sedimentary depositsC�donuts" or ahalos") around the newly installed pilings. Pile driving is the preferred method of installation, but jetting with a low pressure pump may be used. 7.The spacing of pilings through SAY beds will be a minimum of 10 feet on center.8.The gaps bet\veen deckboards will be a minimum of 1/2 inch ..Marsh and l\Iangroves Conditions: l.Marsh:a.The piling-supported structure will be aligned so as to have the smallest over-marsh footprint as Page 278 practicable. b.The over-marsh portion of the piling-supported stmcture will be elevated to at least 4 feet abovethe marsh floor.c.The width.of the piling-supported structure is limited to a maximum of 4 feet. Any exceptions tothe width must be accompanied by an equal increase in height requirement.2.Mangroves:a.The width of the piling-supported structure is limited to a maximum of 4 feet.b. Mangrove clearing is restricted to the width of the piling-supported structure.c.The location and alignment of the piling-supported structure should be through the narrowest areaof the mangrove fringe.Sea Turtle·and Smalltooth Sawfish Construction Conditions: The permittee will comply with the following protected species construction conditions: 1.The permittee will instruct all personnel associated with the project of the potential presence of thesespecies and the need to avoid collisions with sea turtles and smalltooth sawfish. All constructionpersonnel are r esponsible for observing water-related activities for the presence of these species.2.The permittee will advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties forharming, harassing, or killing sea turtles or smalltooth sawfish, which are protected under theEndangered Species Act of 1973.3.Siltation barriers will be made of material in which a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish cannot becomeentangled, be properly secured, and be regularly monitored to avoid protected species entrapment.Barriers may n ot block sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish entry to or exit from designated criticalhabitat without prior agreement from the National Marine Fisheries Service's Protected ResourcesDivision, St. Petersburg, Florida.4.All vessels associated with the construction project will operate at '"no wake/idle" speeds at all timeswhile in the construction area and while in water depths where the draft of the vessel provides lessthan a four-foot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will preferentially follow deep-water routes(e.g., marked channels) whenever possible.5. If a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish is seen within 100 yards of the active daily construction/dredgingoperation or vessel movement, all appropriate precautions will be implemented to ensure itsprotection. These precautions will include cessation of operation of any moving equipment closerthan 50 feet of a sea turtle or small tooth sawfish. Operation of any mechanical constructionequipment will cease immediately if a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish is seen within a 50-ft radius ofthe equipment. Activities may not. resume until the protected species has departed the project area ofits own volition.6.Any collision with and/or injury to a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish will be reported immediately tothe National Marine Fisheries Service's Protected Resources Division (727-824-5312) and the localauthorized sea turtle stranding/rescue organization.7.Any special construction conditions, required of your specific project, outside these generalconditions, if applicable, will be addressed in the primary consultation.8.Any collision(s) with and/or injuries to any whale, or sturgeon occurring during the construction of aproject, shall be reported immediately to NMFS's Protected Resources Division (PRD) at(727-824-5312).9.Reports to NMFS's Protected Resources Division (PRD) may be made by email totakereport.nmfsser@noaa.gov.10.Sea turtle and marine mammal stranding/rescue organizations' contact information is available byregion at http://www.runfs.noaa.gov/pr/health/networks.htm.l l. Smalltooth sawfish encounters shall be reported tohttp://www.flmnh. ufl .edu/fish/sharks/sawfish/ sawfishencounters.html. 12.All work must occur during daylight hours.Special Conditions: Page 279 l.For concrete piles installed by impact hammer:a.The piles will be less than or equal to than 24 inches in_diameter; andb.Not more than 10 piles will be installed per day if in open water; or,c.Not more than 5 piles will be installed per day in a confined space. A confined space is defined asany area that has a solid object (e.g., shoreline, seawall, jetty) or structure within 150 feet of the pileinstallation site that would effectively serve as a barrier or otherwise prevent animals from movingpast it to exit the area. This does not include objects such as docks or other pile-supported structuresthat would not stop animal movement or significantly reflect noise.2.Metal piles will NOT be installed by impact hammer.3.The Permittee is responsible for obtaining any 'talce' permits required under the U.S. Fish andWildlife Service's regulations governing compliance with the Migratory Bird Treaty Act or the Baldand Golden Eagle Protection Act. The Permittee should contact the appropriate local office of theU.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to determine if such 'talce' permits are required for a particularactivity.4.The Permittee is responsible for compliance with 50 CPR 224.103 prohibiting approach within 500yards of a right whale, with limited exceptions.5.Special Conditions Related to All Reviews and Authorizations are available at:htt_p://www.saj.usace.army.mil/Missions/Regulatory/Source-Book/ and must be followed.Page 280 Dock Construction Guidelines in Florida for Docks or Other Minor Structures Constructed in or over Submerged Aquatic Vegetation (SA V), Marsh or Mangrove Habitat U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/National Marine Fisheries Service August2001 Submerged Aquatic Vegetation: I.Avoidance. The pier shall be aligned so as to minimize the size of the footprint over SA V beds. 2.The height of pier shall be a minimum of 5 feet above .MHW /OHW as measured from the top surface of the decking. 3.The width of the pier is limited to a maximum of 4 feet. A turnaround area is allowed for piers greater than 200 feet in length. The turnaround is limited to a section of the pier no more than 10 feet in length and no more than 6 feet in width. The turnaround shall be located at the midpoint of the pier. 4.Over-SA V bed portions of the pier shall be oriented in a north-south orientation to the maximum extent that is practicable. 5.a. If possible, terminal platforms shall be placed in deep water, waterward of SA V beds or in an area devoid of SA V beds. b.If a terminal platform is placed over SA V areas and constructed of grated decking, the total size of the platform shall be limited to 160 square feet. The grated deck material shall conform to the specifications stipulated below. The configuration of the platform shall be a maximum of 8 feet by 20 feet. A minimum of 5 feet by 20 feet shall conform to the 5-foot height requirement; a 3 feet by 20 feet section may be placed 3 feet above MHW to facilitate boat access. The long axis of the platfonn should be aligned in a north-south direction to the maximum extent that is practicable. c.If the terminal platform is placed over SA V areas and constructed of planks, the total size of the platform shall be limited to 120 square feet. The configuration of the platform shall be a maximum of 6 f�et by 20 feet of which a minimum 4-foot wide by 20-foot long section shall conform to the 5-foot height requirement. A section may be placed 3 feet above MHW to facilitate boat access. The 3 feet above MHW section shall be cantilevered. The long axis of the platform should be aligned in a north-south direction to the maximum extent that is practicable. If the 3feet above l\t1HW section is constructed with grating material, it may be 3 feet wide. 6.One uncovered boat lift area is allowed. A narrow catwalk (2 feet wide if planks are used, 3 feet wide if grating is used) may be added to facilitate boat maintenance along the outboard side of the boat lift and a 4-foot wide walkway may be added along the stern end of the boat lift, provided ,all such walkways are elevated 5 feet above �lHW. The catwalk shall be cantilevered from the outboard mooring pilings (spaced no closer than 10 feet apart). 7.Pilings shall be installed in a manner which will not result in the formation of sedimentary deposits("donuts" or "halos") around the newly installed pilings. Pil� driving is the preferred method of installation, but jetting with a low pressure pump may be used. 8.The spacing of pilings through SA V beds shall be a minimum of 10 feet on center. 9.The gaps bernreen deckboards shall be a minimum of½ inch. Grid Specifications and Suppliers Section modifo:d in October .2002 to add an additional vendor of mat�rials. F-ebruary 2003 -Vendor name changed t'rom ChemGr:ite to FiberGnte Page 281 Marsh: 1.The structure shall be aligned so as to have the smallest over-marsh footprint as practicable. 2.The over-marsh portion of the dock shall be elevated to at least 4 feet above the marsh floor. 3.The width of the dock is limited to a maximum of 4 feet. Any exceptions to the width must be accompanied by an equal increase in height requirement. Mangroves. I.The width of the dock is limited to a maximum of 4 feet. 2.Mangrove clearing is restricted to the width of the pier. 3.The location and alignment of the pier should be through the narrowest area of the mangrove fringe. Grid Specifications and Suppliers The following information does not constitute a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers endorsement or advertisement for any particular provider and is provided only as an example for those interested in obtaining these materials for dock construction. A type of fiberglass grate panel is manufactured by SeaSafe (Lafayette, LA; phone: l-800-326-8842) and FiberGrate (l-800-527-4043). Plastic grate panels are also available from Southern Pine Lumber Company (Stuart, FL; phone: 772-692-2300). Panels are available in a variety of sizes and thicknesses. For safety, the grate should contain an anti-slip texture which is integrally molded into the top surface. The manufacturer or local distributor should be consulted to ensure that the load-bearing capacity of the selected product is sufficient to support the intended purpose. Contact the manufacturer(s) for product specifications and a list of regional distributors. Gr.d Specifications and Suppliers Section modified in October 2C02 to add an additional vendor of materials. February !G03 -Vendor name changed from ChemGrate to FiberGrate Page 282 la. The construction site is within the known range of Johnson's seagrass occurrence (Sebastian Inlet to central Biscayne Bay in the lagoonal systems on the east coast of Florida). lb. The construction site is not within the known range of Johnson's seagrass occurrence but submerged aquatic vegetation (SA V) is present at the site. Use The construction site is not within the range of Johnson's seagrass and is not present site: 2a. Seagrass survey for Johnson's seagrass is perfonned at the proposed site during the April 1 - August growing season. 2 b. No survey for Johnson's seagrass is perfonned at the proposed site during the growing season, or a survey is performed at the proposed site but outside of the growing season. 3a. Johnson's seagrass is present at the proposed construction site. Johnson's seagrass is not present the proposed construction site. 4a. The construction is in an area designated by the National Marine Fisheries Service -Protected Resources Division as for Johnson's seagrass. Use 4b. The construction is not in an area designated by NMFS"'.PRD as critical habitat for Johnson's seagrass. Use 5a. The construction is in an area designated by NivfFS-PRD as critical habitat for Johnson's seagrass. Use 5b. The construction is in area designated by NMFS-PRD as critical habitat for Johnson's seagrass. Use Page 283 1-inclt spacing sliall be mailitained between all wooden deckboards used waterward of tl,e MLW/itte. 6a. The construction is in an area designated by M.1FS-PRD as critical habitat for Johnson's seagrass. Use "Dock Constmction Guidelines in Florida for Docks or Other Minor Stmctures Constn,cted in or over Submerged Aquatic Vegetation, Marsh or Mangrove Habitat" -U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/National i\!larine Fisheries Service, August 2001, except that a millimum I-inch spacing slta/l he maintained between all wooden deckhoards used waterward of tlie MLW line. 6b. The construction is not in an area designated by �[FS as critical habitat for Johnson's seagrass. Go to 7 7a. SA V other than Johnson's seagrass is present at the site. Use "Dock Constmction Guidelines in Florida for Docks or Other 1\,linor Structures Constntcted in or over Submerged Aquatic Vegetation, Marsh or Mangrove Habitat" -U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/National Marine Fisheries Service, August 2001. 7b. No SA V present. No construction conditions for SAV are necessary. Notes: t.This key is meant to complement but not supersede the "Dock Construction Guidelines in Florida for Docks orOther Minor Structures Constn,cted in or over Submerged Aquatic Vegetation, iWarsh or Alangrove Habitat -U.S.Army Corps of Engineers/National Alarine Fisheries Service, August 200 /. Docks incorporating light-transmitting materials shall not exceed the dimensions recommended in the Guidelines. 2· Federal Register 65 FR 17786, April 5, 2000, Designation of critical habitat for Johnson's seagrass. 3· Light-transmitting materials are made of various materials shaped in the fonn of grids, grates, lattices, etc., to allowthe passage of light through the open spaces. All light-transmitting materials used for dock construction in the known range of Johnson's seagrass shall have a minimum of forty-three (43) percent open space. This kev was modified in October 200:? to change the percent light transmittance requirement of the grids from 46 to .ii as stipulated in �ote #3 . Page 284 UNITED ST ATES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration NATIONAL MARl�'"E FISHERIES SERVICE Southeast Regional Office 263 13th Avenue South St. Petersburg, FL 33701 SEA TURTLE AND SlVIALLTOOTH SAWFISH CONSTRUCTION CONDITIONS The permittee shall comply with the following protected species construction conditions: a.The permittee shall instruct all personnel associated with the project of the potential presence ofthese species and the need to avoid collisions with sea turtles and smalltooth sawfish. Allconstruction personnel are responsible for observing water-related activities for the presence ofthese species.b.The pennittee shall advise all construction personnel that there are civil and criminal penalties forharming, harassing, or killing sea turtles or smalltooth sawfish, which are protected under theEndangered Species Act of 1973.c.Siltation barriers shall be made of material in which a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish cannotbecome entangled, be properly secured, and be regularly monitored to avoid protected speciesentrapment. Barriers may not block sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish entry to or exit fromdesignated critical habitat without prior agreement from the National Marine Fisheries Service'sProtected Resources Division, St. Petersburg, Florida.d.All vessels associated with the construction project shall operate at '"no wake/idle" speeds at alltimes while in the construction area and while in water depths where the draft of the vesselprovides less than a four-foot clearance from the bottom. All vessels will preferentially followdeep-water routes (e.g., marked channels) whenever possible.e.If a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish is seen within 100 yards of the active dailyconstruction/dredging operation or vessel movement, all appropriate precautions shall beimplemented to ensure its protection. These precautions shall include cessation of operation ofany moving equipment closer than SO feet of a sea turtle or small tooth sawfish. Operation of anymechanical construction equipment shall cease immediately if a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish isseen within a 50-ft radius of the equipment. Activities may not resume until the protected specieshas departed the project area of its own volition.f.Any collision with and/or injury to a sea turtle or smalltooth sawfish shall be reportedimmediately to the National Marine Fisheries Service's Protected Resources Division (727-824-5312) and the local authorized sea turtle stranding/rescue organization.g.Any special construction conditions, required of your specific project, outside these generalconditions, if applicable, will be addressed in the primary consultation.Revised: March 23, 2006 O:\fonns\Sea Turtle and Smalltooth Sa"vfish Construction Conditions.doc Page 285 Additions to the "Sea Turtle and Smalltooth Sawfish Construction Conditions" for SPGP V a.Any collision(s) with an/or injuries to any whale, or sturgeon occurring during the construction of a project, shall be reported immediately to NMFS's Protected Resources Division (PRD) at (727-824-5312). b.Reports to NMFS's Protected Resources Division (PRO) may be made by email to takereport.nmfsser@noaa.gov. c.Sea turtle and marine mammal stranding/rescue organizations' contact information is available by region at http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/health/networks.htm. d.Smalltooth sawfish encounters shall be re ported to http://www.flmnh.ufl.edu/fish/sharks/sawfish/sawfishencounters.html. e.All work must occur during daylight hours. Page 286 Page 287 1t� ·;��:��.--�=-� .. \1 '·· '·.· .• , � ...., . ..,,, concrete cap -· ,. !f_; '._l.-' I AUG 2 9 2017 400001 post b.o ' : .:..:.. \� I. -., l • ,- 1 .., I '.-]·r ---� ···- ·--� . ------ I I --. . -. IL +I @new 12" x 12" additional I concrete pilings :::: \ O p o ST s;; 110'-2" 1-=-•II! :It . . JI! 17'-4" + 10' "52.43'+ � [A (-71 \?RO V €. �) • � () (>L,\ C.�T lo\v ' >I� I _t 3� • I Irs•· -I f2 • -I � Page 288 ,'.I ,(11 'A ri r. I I i I I I I I I I I 1 :6C>lc, G � r-\ "-l I), CCU r<-T 1 • I : •. ,. \\';!/\F. -\ AUG 2 9 20\7 I r�. c-,;).c i� \ _ '. l \; _ D \· \'.-�-. '.-,�r l•!; i i -; -�\ ...., Q) � C N't-I� co 3:N I ·- � (0 � ew 40000lt(tl_Q. . post boatlift I I I Existing dock and ... Jlf .. t-t-il It---.-, -pilings to remain Existing seawall cap and wall to remain �dge of existing concrete cap ------ 10' 10' 10' 1"3'-4" 1-- --1-= -1---1----1 44'-4" , �,�� I f\ (> .PL\ C;.� T \0\v Tc> � €- t..o C \.<:\ T E- T \-\ E. .SA f\'\€-\ o f-> 0S.S V{AI ERVvAf - I I �. T-!\f.'t-'1 UY� all mett 10.Any de,the Eng 11.Elevatio112.Design ui t-= � ;: i.o <.0 ..,... Page 289 Date: September 26, 2017 CERTIFICATE OF MAILING This is to certify that on September 26, 2017 the Town of Highland Beach mailed a copy of the attached Notice of Public Hearing for the property located at 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach, Florida, to the attached list. This mailing consisted of 56 notices sent certified and return receipt requested. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and seal this 26th day of e tember , 2017 erisha Cuebas, , eputy Town Town of Highland Beach ************************************************************************ STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH Before me this 26th . day of September personally appeared Terisha Cuebas, Deputy Town Clerk for the Town of Highland Beach, who is known to be the person described and who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged to and before me that she executed said instrument for the purposes therein expressed. Notary Seal: ,._)i·; .. :�."��� ROSALIE DEMARTINO i �/&_:� MY COMMISSION # FF216560 i •::r;;,·�� EXPIRES April 04. 2019 ! ,-.,.;:: •���•.: · :.::floodaNo.arySorwk:o.c..rr Page 290 TOWN OF IDGHLAND BEACH NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING PLANNING BOARD YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that the Planning Board of the Town of Highland Beach will conduct a Public Hearing on Wednesday, October 11, 2017 at 9:30 AM in the Commission Chambers at Town Hall, 3614 South Ocean Boulevard, Highland Beach, Florida to consider the following application: APPLICATION #039412-CONSIDERATION OF A SITE PLAN APPROVAL FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW PLATFORM BOATLIFT LOCATED AT SUBJECT PROPERTY, 1006 GRAND COURT, HIGHLAND BEACH, FLORIDA, IN THE RMM (RESIDENTIAL MUL TI-FAMILY MEDIUM DENSITY). Application is available for inspection in the Town Clerk's Office at Town Hall, Monday through Friday during normal business hours of 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Any person that decides to appeal any decision made by the Town Commission with respect to any matter considered at this meeting, such person will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. The Town of Highland Beach does not provide such a record. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons who need special accommodation to attend or participate in this meeting should contact the Town Clerk's Office at (561)-278-4548 at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. If you are hearing or speech impaired, please contact the Florida Relay Service at 1- 800-955-8770 or 1-800-955-8771. Terisha Cuebas Deputy Town Clerk Per Town of Highland Beach Code of Ordinance, Ordinance No. 13-002 0, written notice shall be sent by certified mail with a return receipt requested on Tuesday, September 26, 2017, to property owners located within 300 feet of the affected property, excluding property owned by the applicant. If a condominium with an association is to be included, written notice may be provided only to the association president and the condominium's resident or property manager. Page 291 Planning Board Regular Minutes Wednesday, October 11, 2017 Public Comments: There were no public comments. Chair Reidenberg closed the public hearing at 9:48 AM. Page 5 of 10 MOTION: Member Mart moved to approve Application No. 17-0564 at 3912 South Ocean Blvd. The motion was seconded by Vice.Chair Axelrod. ROLL CALL: Member Mart Yes Vice Chair Axelrod -Yes Member Kravit Yes Member Weiss Yes Member Shane Yes Chair Reidenberg Yes Motion carried 6 to 0. C)Application No. 039412 ;...1006 Grand Court CONSIDERATION OF A SITE PLAN APPROVAL FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW PLATFORM BOATLIFT LOCATED AT SUBJECT PROPERTY, 1006 GRAND COURT, HIGHLAND BEACH, FLORIDA, IN THE RMM RESIDENTIAL MULTI-FAMILY MEDIUM DENSITY PER TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEAC H SECTION 30-67, USES PERMITTED, SPECIAL EXCEPTION, AND PROHIBITED USES, TABLE 30- 4 PERMITTED USES. APPLICANT: Richard Touchette Chair Reidenberg read the title into the record. He asked if the Board members had any ex-parte communications to disclose. Hearing none, the public hearing was opened at 9:49 AM. Petitioner's Presentation: David Nutter, B & M Marine provided comments with regard to the new updates of the lift. Mr. Nutter advised an 8-post boat lift was previously approved and the only change is that two additional moorings will be incorporated to make. it a 10- post boat lift. Chair Reidenberg questioned how much weight the new lift could hold. Mr. Touchette, the applicant, advised the boat was 30,000 lbs but that the lift would support a gross of 40,000 lbs. Member Shane called for a correction to the record with regard to the Staff Report that was submitted by the building departm�nt. Town Attorney Shutt advised that the zoning is correct and clarified that the residence is a single-family residence and not a multi family residence as stated in the Staff Report. Page 292 Planning Board Regular Minutes Wednesday, October 11, 2017 Page 6 oflO Discussion ensued with regard to an addendum being submitted by the Building Official. Town Attorney Shutt advised an addendum would not be necessary so long as the record is clear. Staff Presentation: Member Shane questioned the plans with regard to the existing docks and pilings that remain. Town Attorney Shutt advised that there is only one dock and Building Official Perez confirmed there is only one dock. Public Comments: There were no public comments. MOTION: Vice Chair Axelrod moved to approve Application No. 039412 at 1006 Grand Court. The motion was seconded by Member Weiss. ROLL CALL: Vice Chair Axelrod -Yes Member Weiss Yes Member Kravit Yes Member Shane Yes Member Mart Yes Chair Reidenberg Yes Motion carried 6 to 0. C)Presentation Regarding Lifting DevicesJoe GiHo, Sea Tech Construction provided comments with regard to the currentlifts that are being used in the industry.Deputy Town Clerk Cuebas handed out boat lift information, attached as Exhibit"A'', provided by Mr. Gilio to the board members.Mr. Gilio provided testimony with regard to the below surrounding municipalitiesand their code requirements for marine lifting devices.Delray Beach Boca Raton Lighthouse Point Pompano Beach Fort Lauderdale Chair Reidenberg questioned Mr. Gilio as to whether he would recommend Highland Beach update their code. Mr. Gilio believes the code should be updated to keep up with the times. Page 293 Page 294 Page 295 Page 296 Page 297 Page 298 Page 299 Page 300 Page 301 Page 302 Page 303 Page 304 Page 305 Page 306 Page 307 Page 308 Page 309 Page 310 Page 311 PUBLIC COMMENT (19-0001) Kathleen Kennedy 12.10.2019 Page 130Page 312 From:Marshall Labadie To:Ingrid Allen; Jason Manko Subject:FW: 1006 Grand Ct Date:Tuesday, December 10, 2019 8:48:05 AM Sincerely, Marshall Labadie Town Manager Town of Highland Beach 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 (561)278-4548 mlabadie@highlandbeach.us PLEASE NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the Town of Highland Beach officials and employees regarding public business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may be subject to public disclosure. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by phone or in writing. The views expressed in this message may not necessarily reflect those of the Town ofHighland Beach. From: Barry Donaldson <bdonaldson@highlandbeach.us>  Sent: Tuesday, December 10, 2019 8:38 AM To: Kathleen Kennedy <kkboca@gmail.com> Cc: Marshall Labadie <mlabadie@highlandbeach.us> Subject: RE: 1006 Grand Ct Kathleen, Your problem reinforces the decision of the Town to bring code enforcement back as a direct, and not out-sourced, service for the citizens of Highland Beach. While we are beginning to see the positive impact of that move, some issues still linger that were not properly handled under the prior contractual arrangement for services. Like others, I was shocked at what appears to be a flagrant violation of the permit process that resulted in the incorrect work advancing until a stop work order was issued.  We now need to redress the issue, correct the violation and take steps to prevent anything like this from happening again. I am confident the Town Manager will pursue a satisfactory resolution and involve the Town Commission should we need to address any policy issues that led to this problem. Barry Barry Donaldson Commissioner Page 131Page 313 Town of Highland Beach 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 (561) 859-2686 bdonaldson@highlandbeach.us PUBLIC RECORDS NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from local officials, employees, or the general public regarding city business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure.   From: Kathleen Kennedy <kkboca@gmail.com>  Sent: Monday, December 9, 2019 6:02 PM To: Rhoda Zelniker <rzelniker@highlandbeach.us>; Peggy Gossett-Seidman <pseidman@highlandbeach.us>; Marshall Labadie <mlabadie@highlandbeach.us>; Greg Babij <gbabij@highlandbeach.us>; Barry Donaldson <bdonaldson@highlandbeach.us>; Evalyn David <edavid@highlandbeach.us> Subject: 1006 Grand Ct   Greetings,   It was a pleasure meeting you all at your town meeting. I reside at 1005 Grand Ct. in Boca Highland. I have been to the city's building department several times for over a year, inquiring about my neighbor’s construction of a boat lift. The last information from city officials was that this was never permitted to be so large and the permit is expired. I would like to see a copy of the approved permit. I called the State and they confirmed that the contractor B&M construction falsely certified that this project met SPGP guidelines.   The permit issued does not meet code requirements and/or represent the structure that is under construction. The SPGP self-certification permit expired 7-25-2016 or 7-25-2017. The photo attached, (A), is current and was taken in late 2019, which reflects an abandoned construction project that has not progressed in over a year. The EPA guidelines clearly state: "This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others." The pilings are over 20' high, the entire structure appears to be closer to 12' X 35'. Do you have a minimum set back requirement and/or height requirement for pilings that pertain to neighboring property lines? Do you have requirements for expired permits? Do you have enforcement policies for structures that in violation of your municipal code that protect city ordinances, property values and vested interests of Highland Beach residences?   The 10 massive pilings are abutting and possibly encroaching onto my property. The basin is now restricted to less than 9' clearance. It has restricted my ability to have any boat larger than 20' and navigating that size boat is extremely unsafe. If you are able to navigate through the new pilings the wind tunnel created here is problematic for even small boats. I recently lost a buyer because of this restricted access. The waterway is now virtually unusable for the 5 homes to the south east, and the boat slips across from me are severely impacted. I have attached an image of this from the property appraiser's website, (B).   Below are references of codes I have researched and believe to be in violation, which I request further investigation. I apologize in advance for the lengthy email, however, I moved into the Page 132Page 314 city of Highland Beach believing I and my property would be protected in the best interest to preserve the integrity and value of all properties within. My parents and I have happily owned homes, (3813 South Ocean BLVD.), for over 30 years and have always been proud to be part of this community. I thank you for your timely attention to this matter.     Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations (g) (2) (2) Boat basins. Boat basins may be permitted, as provided herein: a. Boat basins in all zoning districts on lots of one acre or more may be permitted as an accessory use. b. Boat basins in all zoning districts on lots of less than one acre shall be a special exception, subject to the standards listed below: 1. The edge of any improvements associated with a boat basin shall be located at least twenty-five (25) feet from side property lines. 2. The total length of improvements associated with a boat basin shall not exceed one-third (33.3%) of the length of the property line in which the basin is located. 3. Not more than twenty-five (25) percent of any boat moored in a boat basin may extend waterward of property line in which the basin is located. 4. The town, at the expense of the applicant, may utilize appropriate marine, engineering, construction, and related professionals to review all aspects of such application. Such professionals shall be utilized to ensure compliance with the requirements herein, to ensure a proposed basin will not be a hazard to navigation, and to ensure a proposed boat basin will not pose a potential hazard, via erosion or other action, to the stability of neighboring properties. Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations (g) (4) (g) Accessory marine facilities: (4) Boats and setbacks. When moored, any portion of a boat shall not extend beyond any property line, as extended waterward. Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations. (h)(1) c Page 133Page 315 (h) Dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, and moorings: (1) Installation. In order to be installed, dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, and moorings shall comply with all standards listed below: a. The installation shall be subject to approval by the planning board at an advertised public hearing. b. The mooring facilities will be located in a canal or waterway at least eighty (80) feet in width. c. The mooring facilities will not create a hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the public reasonable visual access to public waterways. Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations (h) (4)& (5) (h) Dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, and moorings: (4) Adjacent property. Installation of the mooring facilities shall not cause a hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the adjacent property owners or public reasonable visual access to the public waterway. (5) Navigation. Installation of such mooring facilities shall not infringe upon standard navigational practices that are or may be used by abutting property owners.   (2) Public notice. In addition to the requirements of section 30-46, written notice must be provided by certified mail, return receipt requested, to owners of property abutting the canal and located within three hundred (300) feet, as measured from both property lines along the canal bank, of the property in question. In addition to the notice required above, if the mooring facilities identified in (h)(1) above are to be installed/constructed in the Bel Lido Isle subdivision, notice, by first class mail, shall be provided to the owners of property located in the Bel Lido Isle subdivision, where such property is located outside the 300 feet notice area but where the property line is within one thousand (1,000) feet of the property line of the property on which such installation/construction is proposed. I was never given notice of this lift, my neighbors did not receive any notice either. This structure has caused me to lose the ability to use the dockage allotted to this property to its fullest potential. Not to mention, a loss of property value to be in excess of 1 million dollars. I am requesting city involvement to enforce their codes that protect residences, waterway navigation and property values. I have been informed the file has been passed on to someone else, and it will be a while. How long will your review take? Do you intend to enforce your codes?    Furthermore, 1006 Grand Ct. has completely blocked my view of the waterway with an Page 134Page 316 overgrown ficus tree. Ficus hedges and Areca Palms are all untrimmed and not maintained. A large ficus tree is planted less than 5' from the property line, which is against city code. This tree is diseased, It has been treated and when the leaves fall, my grass dies. It encroaches into my yard, at times overhangs on my roof, and has caused damage to my pavers and irrigation. I'm sure that it will continue to cause damage to my foundation and plumbing if it hasn't already. Several references from the municipal code regarding landscaping are in violation:   Sec. 28-5. - Landscape design standards. Chapter 28, Landscape Requirements: Land values: Maintain and increase the value of land by requiring landscaping to be incorporated into development, thus becoming by itself a valuable capital asset. (g) Removal of nuisance species: Eradicate or control certain exotic plant species which have become nuisances because of their tendency to damage public and private works, to have a negative effect upon public health, or to disrupt or destroy native ecosystem 28-5 (4)(d)(2) Use of site-specific planting materials: Trees and other vegetation that are prohibited from use in meeting the landscape requirements of this chapter are so indicated in the Xeriscape Plant Guide and Pruning Manual maintained by the town. Trees and other vegetation shall be planted in soil and climatic conditions which are appropriate for their growth habits as set out in the Xeriscape Plant Guide and Pruning Manual maintained by the town. Plants used in the landscape design pursuant to this chapter shall to the greatest extent be: (2) Have noninvasive growth habits. I respectfully ask for your attention to and enforcement of the code violations mentioned above. Residents of Highland Beach have an expectation of standards to be upheld within the community. These standards heavily depend on the community itself to protect the value and prestigious Highland Beach brand. Respectfully, Kathleen Kennedy 561-702-7313 1005 Grand Court Highland Beach, FL 33487   Think Green: Please do not print this email unless absolutely necessary The information contained in this message may be privileged and confidential and  protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or  an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient,  you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copy of this  Page 135Page 317 communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,  please notify us immediately by replying to the message and deleting it from your  computer.   Page 136Page 318 PUBLIC COMMENT (19-0001) Marc Siegel 06.28.2020 Page 137Page 319 1 Public Comments To:Marc Siegel Subject:RE: Application No. 19_0001 Application No. 39412 From: Marc Siegel <mnsiegel@hotmail.com>   Sent: Sunday, June 28, 2020 5:20 PM  To: Public Comments <publiccomments@highlandbeach.us>  Subject: RE: Application No. 19_0001 Application No. 39412    Please include my comments as part of the public record regarding the  application and amendment for Richard Touchette for his boat lift at  1006 Grand Court.    As a resident of Braemar Isle in the Boca Highland Beach Club complex I  wish to express my displeasure in the granting and request for  amendment of the entire installation of the boat lift at 1006 Grand Court.  As a property owner there for close to 14 years, I purchased my condo  overlooking the north marina because of its beauty and tranquil setting.  With the install of (10) 15‐foot marine poles/posts that were installed  previously, this has changed the entire view and tranquility that was once  there. The appearance now is one of a commercial boatyard rather than  a "cove or beauty, tranquility and peacefulness". It is as bad as the  overpowering and obtrusiveness of the construction of the Toscana  complex in the town. Gone is the sense of being an old‐fashioned ,laid  back coastal town to the start of a city like Delray Beach and Boca Raton.    The area in question consists of several private homes and the Braemar  Isle building. Yes, there are boat slips there with beautiful boats  occupying them but nothing like the proposed and previously installed  boat lift/poles. The lift is obviously designed to support an extremely  large vessel above the waterline. This boat will be multi‐ton and multi‐ Page 138Page 320 2 foot in length This will raise the vessel several feet up in the air above the  high tide line and cause an unsightly view for multimillion‐dollar homes  and the Braemar Isle building residents looking out upon the project. At  low tide ,the "ship" will look even worse. Several adjacent homes are  affected as well because this install is already restricting smooth flow into  the intracoastal with their pleasure boats.  The area of the marina is rather small and movement within the marina is  difficult at best with everything that is in place there. The previously  installed poles/posts protrude into the waterway blocking the smooth  navigation and movement of all boats. This structure is completely  overpowering for the size of the body of water in that area. A boat for  this intended size lift is overpowering and intrudes into adjacent property  water space and their property values will be greatly diminished as such.  Would I purchase a home or condo apartment in Braemar Isle that faces  this monstrosity?? Certainly not.  I am hoping that the members of the Planning Board of Highland Beach  decide and refuse this proposed amendment as well as the initial  application for install of this massive boat lift and take all comments into  sincere consideration. This install is to satisfy one at the very expense of  many, many residents and neighbors of 1006 Grand Court in the Boca  Higland community.  Thank you for your consideration and forethought.  Sincerely,  Marc N. Siegel  Braemar Isle  Boca Highland Beach Club  Page 139Page 321 PUBLIC COMMENT (19-0001) Marc Siegel 06.30.2020 Page 140Page 322 1 Public Comments To:Marc N Siegel Subject:RE: Public comments for application NO. 19-0001 1006 Grand Court From: Marc N Siegel <mnsiegel@gmail.com>   Sent: Tuesday, June 30, 2020 7:55 AM  To: Public Comments <publiccomments@highlandbeach.us>  Subject: Public comments for application NO. 19‐0001 1006 Grand Court    https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/1006‐Grand‐Ct‐Highland‐Beach‐FL‐ 33487/46798023_zpid/#      Mr. TOUCHETTE IS IN THE PROCESS OF SELLING HIS HOME.His residence  is listed on Zillow. The link is listed above.  It’s been on the market for 130  days. Why is this install and amendment to change be approved and even  allowed?    Hoping that the Planning Board does not approve the request for  amendment and demands removal of the installed eyesore he previously  put in place.   Positive for one results in so many negatives for many.   Please excuse brevity and grammar    Marian Siegel  Boca Highland Beach Club  Braemar Isle.   Page 141Page 323 File Attachments for Item: B. DEVELOPMENT ORDER APPLICATION NO. 20-0004 (DAVID & DANIELLE SCHNEID) APPLICATION BY SEATECH CONSTRUCTION FOR A SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPROVAL TO REMOVE A 160 SQUARE FOOT EXISTING DOCK, INSTALL A 820 SQUARE FOOT MARGINAL DOCK, INSTALL A SEAWALL CAP ALONG AN EXISTING 200 LINEAR FOOT SEA WALL, AND INST ALL TWO (2) SEAWALL RETURNS FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4410 TRANQUILITY DRIVE. Page 142Page 324 PUBLIC COMMENT #4 (19-0001) Phyllis Gendal 07.6.2020 Page 325 Page 326 Page 327 PUBLIC COMMENT #05 (19-0001) Connie & Anthony Strianese 07.6.2020 Page 328 1 Public Comments To:Public Comments Subject:RE: Application No. 19-0001 By Richard Touchette Requesting an Amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat IiftTo (Application No. 39412) From: Public Comments   Sent: Monday, July 6, 2020 12:26 PM  To: Connie Strianese <libqual@verizon.net>  Subject: RE: Application No. 19‐0001 By Richard Touchette Requesting an  Amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat IiftTo (Application  No. 39412)  Good day Connie Strianese, Thank you for expressing interest in public comment, during the Virtual Planning Board meeting scheduled for Thursday, July 9, 2020 at 9:30 A.M. Your comment will be read into record during the meeting under Item 9, New Business, public comments (APP. No. 19-0001 - Richard Touchette). Stay Safe. Best regards, Beverly A. Wright, Deputy Town Clerk Town of Highland Beach  3614 S. Ocean Boulevard  Highland Beach, Florida 33487  Tel: (561) 278‐4548  Fax: (561) 265‐3582  Email: bwright@highlandbeach.us  www.highlandbeach.us  Page 329 2 PUBLIC RECORDS NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from local officials, employees, or the general public regarding city business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. From: Connie Strianese <libqual@verizon.net>   Sent: Friday, July 3, 2020 1:31 PM  To: Public Comments <publiccomments@highlandbeach.us>  Subject: Application No. 19‐0001 By Richard Touchette Requesting an Amendment  to a previously approved ten post platform boat IiftTo (Application No. 39412)    To Whom It May Concern, My name is Connie Strianese. I reside at 4744 South Ocean Boulevard TH- 2, Boca Highland Beach Club and Marina. I am writing this letter in response to Public Notice Application No. 19-0001. Mr. Touchette was granted permission to put posts that measure four feet on his dock. He purposely did not abide by the town code and constructed 12 foot posts. It is disturbing that he feels he is special and does not have to abide by the Town ordinances. It is equally disturbing that his posts are an eyesore to the neighboring area. The town ordinance has been put in place for a reason. People specifically buy property on the water to dock their boats and to enjoy the beautiful view. Residents have paid more money for their waterfront property for the view. If residents construct eyesores along our waterway, we will lose our beautiful view that we enjoy and our property values will surely drop. The Highland Beach "Nuisance Code" considers anything that can cause a substantial deterioration in the value of the property in the neighborhood. Mr. Touchette is setting a precedent for the rest of the neighbors. If he can get away with this so could everyone else. I respectfully request that the Highland Beach Town Board do the right thing and have Mr. Touchette remove his posts immediately. Connie and Anthony Strianese 4744 South Ocean Boulevard Page 330 3 TH-2 Highland Beach Page 331 PUBLIC COMMENT #6 (19-0001) Kathy & James Gurrieri 07.6.2020 Page 332 1 Public Comments To:Public Comments Subject:RE: Application No.19-0001 From: Public Comments   Sent: Monday, July 6, 2020 12:29 PM  To: Kgurrieri81 <kgurrieri81@aol.com>  Subject: RE: Application No.19‐0001  Good day Kathy and James Gurrieri, Thank you for expressing interest in public comment, during the Virtual Planning Board meeting scheduled for Thursday, July 9, 2020 at 9:30 A.M. Your comment will be read into record during the meeting under Item 9, New Business, public comments (APP. No. 19-0001 - Richard Touchette). Stay Safe. Best regards, Beverly A. Wright, Deputy Town Clerk Town of Highland Beach  3614 S. Ocean Boulevard  Highland Beach, Florida 33487  Tel: (561) 278‐4548  Fax: (561) 265‐3582  Email: bwright@highlandbeach.us  Page 333 2 www.highlandbeach.us    PUBLIC RECORDS NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from local officials, employees, or the general public regarding city business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. From: Kgurrieri81 <kgurrieri81@aol.com>   Sent: Friday, July 3, 2020 9:41 PM  To: Public Comments <publiccomments@highlandbeach.us>  Subject: Application No.19‐0001    To the Town of Highland Beach Building Department, I am responding to the letter we received regarding an application by Mr. R. Touchette requesting an amendment to increase the height of a boat lift. We absolutely oppose this increase in height. Our water views are very important to us and to have them obstructed with these high boat lifts would be extremely upsetting. It would also affect the value of our property. Please do the right thing by our community and do NOT grant Mr. Touchette an amendment. Our appreciation in advance. Thank you Kathy and James Gurrieri 4740 So. Ocean Blvd Highland Beach Apt 1112 Page 334 PUBLIC COMMENT #7 (19-0001) Paul Resnick 07.6.2020 Page 335 Page 336 ADDENDUMS TO ITEM 9A (19-0001) RICHARD TOUCHETTE) PUBLIC COMMENTS Date: 07.08.2020 Page 337 PUBLIC COMMENT #8 (19-0001) Kathleen Kennedy 07.07.2020 Page 338 1 Beverly Wright From:Beverly Wright Sent:Wednesday, July 8, 2020 9:50 AM To:Ingrid Allen; 'Len Rubin'; Brian DeMoss (golfdemoss@aol.com); David Axelrod (DZAXELROD@gmail.com); Eric Goldenberg (gldnbrg@gmail.com); Harry Adwar; Ilyne Mendelson (msirm1@gmail.com); John Boden; roger3265@aol.com Subject:Planning Board Meeting Additional Public Comments Item 9A Attachments:19-0001 PC (Read into Record) K. Kennedy Email 07.07.2020 (1006 Boat Lift).pdf; 19-0001 PC (Read into Records) Ltr from K. Kennedy 07.07.2020.pdf Good morning all, Attached are additional documents received for Public Comments for PB Mtg 07.09.2020, Agenda Item 9A (19-0001 Touchette). Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please call me. Thank you! Best regards, Beverly A. Wright, Deputy Town Clerk PUBLIC RECORDS NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from local officials, employees, or the general public regarding city business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. Page 339 1 Beverly Wright From:Kathleen Kennedy <kkboca@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, July 7, 2020 2:38 PM To:Marshall Labadie; Cc: Marc N Siegel; Paul_Resnick@msn.com; Harry Adwar (Hadwar@msn.com); Fred M. Rosen (fredrosen@icloud.com); Ingrid Allen; Terisha Cuebas; Barry Donaldson; Evalyn David; Greg Babij; Peggy Gossett-Seidman; Rhoda Zelniker; Douglas Hillman; Louis Mazzella; Public Comments; jboden@elderissues.com; John Shoemaker; Lanelda Gaskins; hbpublicrecords; Robert Pershes; Beverly Wright; Ganelle Thompson Subject:1006 Boat lift Attachments:aerial of dock.JPG; EPA Approval.pdf; Original letter to city.eml; EPA SPGF sef-cert.pdf; EPA SPGF sef- cert.pdf July 7, 2020  To: Town of Highland Beach         3614 South Ocean Blvd         Highland Beach Florida 33487  From: Kathleen Kennedy              1005 Grand Court              Highland Beach, Florida  OPPOSITION TO APPLICATION NO. 19‐0001 By RICHARD TOUCHETTE REQUESTING AN  AMENDMENT TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED TEN POST PLATFORM BOAT LIFT (APPLICATION  NO. 39412) IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE HEIGHT OF THE BOAT LIFT FOR THE PROPERTY  LOCATED AT 1006 GRAND COURT I live at 1005 Grand Court, Highland Beach and I oppose Application No. 19‐0001 and construction of the  proposed boat lift. My property is adjacent to the property seeking the expanded boat lift and I am negatively  effected by the proposed structure.  I reside in a single‐family home in Grand Cay Estates at 1005 Grand Court,  inside the town of Boca Highland. I moved into my home in May 2017.  Sometime in October of 2017 notice  was sent out for a public hearing as to the boat dock/lift but never sent me or to any of the newer residents in  this neighborhood   Page 340 2 Mr. Touchette, the owner of 1006 Grand Ct. originally applied to have a boat lift placed in the basin, the  adjacent side from its current location. Mr. Touchette moved location to run along the front(canal side) of the  property, which restricts access to the docks and residents beyond its location, and which completely blocks  my view of the Intercoastal (please see attached map). This location change disregards the rights of residents  of the community.       Since Mr. Touchette’s initial attempt for permission to build the boat lift in 2017, it appears there is a failure to  adequately adhere to process, and apparent violations of Highland Beach codes, and Florida EPA (FEPA)  Guidelines.  In addition, I had put my home up for sale several months ago; however, directly because of this  ongoing issue, I have lost three sales.      Below, I have bullet pointed issues regarding apparent and clear disregard for procedures, as well as sections  of the Town’s Code of Ordinances and FEPA guidelines that I believe have been violated. During a meeting at  the city several months ago all the commissioners and town planners were completely shocked and appalled  at this situation and have gone on record. Documents pertaining to this case can be accessed at (Meeting  Archives related to case):   https://mmportal6.teammunicode.com/   and (documents related to the meeting on 7/9/20):  https://meetings.municode.com/adaHtmlDocument/index?cc=HIGHLANDFL&me=0f947fcd141b4f2db99476ac 485bf43b&ip=True,  (all of which are incorporated herein by reference).         Current Structure Issues:     1. The city hired ATM Engineering (see attachment 3 on city website). Note: Section 30‐68 where they state  the facility extends into southern property boundary. I believe that is my boundary. I have asked for a new  survey to be included in the report but have not received one.  2. This neighbor has shown a disregard for other property owners by partially blocking my view of the  intracoastal/waterway with an invasive and destructive Ficus tree and overgrown vegetation. This is against  city code.     3. FEPA Guidelines state that only one dock is permitted on a parcel; this would be a second dock on Mr.  Touchette’s property.     Page 341 3 4. FEPA approval is confusing, particularly dates and deadlines and it appears the application may be  untimely. Initial permit was issued in 2017. Guidelines state that the work needs to be complete in 1 year, the  initial permit was 3 years ago. A recent letter (attached as conditions for self cert.) indicates another  expiration to 2021; however, it is unclear both how and why a new date was given      5. FEPA and City Statutes state that any lift to be built must not create a navigational hazard; this lift clearly  does as it extends into the navigation area severely limiting passage area.     6. FEPA permit granted based on a single‐family residence. However zoning maps state it should fall under  RMM zoning. The City has enforced RMM zoning in any improvements.     7. City procedures were not followed on at least two separate occasions. First occasion, initial notice was  sent in September 2017 using an old mailing list. I reviewed and confirmed with the City that the list used was  severely outdated. I did not receive any notice of public hearing. Second occasion, Mr. Toucette, appears to  have modified the construction significantly by adding an additional 2 pilings without notice.     8. ATM’s report states that the existing basin does not meet current code, and then implies this application  does not need to follow other codes and rules. If so, then there are no development guidelines and Mr.  Touchette would be able to build anything anywhere. This would not appear to be correct.     9. The SPGF Guidelines (see attached) were not followed and B&M Marine Construction incorrectly states  (see attached) they had met regulations on a self‐certification process.     10. Rather than rectify the situation, the City has not only allowed the building of this navigational hazard to  continue but appears to have permitted additional violations throughout this process.        Code Violations:      A. Sec. 30‐68(h)(4) & (5) of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states … (4) Adjacent property.  Installation of the mooring facilities shall not cause hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or  property, or deny the adjacent property owners or public reasonable visual access to the public  Page 342 4 waterway.   … (5) Navigation. Installation of such mooring facilities shall not infringe upon standard  navigational practices that are or may be used by abutting property owners.      B. Sec. 30‐68(h)(1)c of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states: The mooring facilities will not create a  hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the public reasonable visual  access to public waterways. There are 3 homes and multiple docks beyond this structure which this directly  affects.      C. Sec. 30‐68(g)(2)b1 of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states: The edge of any improvements  associated with boat basin shall be located at least twenty‐five (25) feet from the side property lines. His  structure either infringes on my property line or abuts and I have not provided any consent.       D. Sec. 30‐68(g)(2)b4 of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states … compliance with the requirements  herein, to ensure a proposed basin will not be a hazard to navigation… This structure causes very dangerous  navigation hazards for me and my neighbors due to the now existing very narrow waterway.      For the reasons stated herein the Application No. 19‐0001 should be denied and construction of any additional  dock be denied or at minimum the matter be sent back for appropriate review.      Due to the Covid 19 restrictions I have submitted this Objection and supporting documents by email prior to  July  8 at 9:30AM and will be arranging for recording of the proceeding to be held on Thursday July 9,2020 at  9:30 AM by a reporting service.     Respectfully,  Kathleen Kennedy              Think Green: Please do not print this email unless absolutely necessary   The information contained in this message may be privileged and confidential and   protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or   an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient,   you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copy of this   Page 343 5 communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,   please notify us immediately by replying to the message and deleting it from your   computer.          Virus-free. www.avast.com   Page 344 Page 345 Page 346 Page 347 Page 348 Page 349 Page 350 Page 351 Page 352 Page 353 Page 354 Page 355 Page 356 Page 357 Page 358 Page 359 Page 360 Page 361 1 Beverly Wright From:Kathleen Kennedy <kkboca@gmail.com> Sent:Friday, April 3, 2020 12:19 PM To:: Marshall Labadie; Cc: Marc N Siegel; Paul_Resnick@msn.com; Harry Adwar (Hadwar@msn.com); Fred M. Rosen (fredrosen@icloud.com); Ingrid Allen; Terisha Cuebas; Barry Donaldson; Evalyn David; Greg Babij; Peggy Gossett-Seidman; Rhoda Zelniker; Jshoemaker@highlandbeach.us; dhillman@highlandbeach.us; Louis Mazzella Subject:1006 Grand Ct Attachments:dock pilings.JPG Good afternoon,    I want to welcome the new Mayor, Doug Hillman and the new counsel member; John Shoemaker.  I'm looking forward  to working with you to find a fair resolution to the ongoing problem at 1006 Grand Ct.  My name is Kathleen Kennedy. I reside at 1005 Grand Ct. in Boca Highland. I live next door to the 10 massive pilings at  1006 Grand Ct.    On December 9th, 5 MONTHS AGO I wrote the city asking for help in enforcing a clear violation of city and state code.  This letter is included in the bottom of this email. I have been seeking help from the building department for over 1 year.    I have now lost 3 sales on my property because no‐one is interested in purchasing my property with the canal blocked. I  cannot afford to sit any longer while the city authorities change positions and cower down to the attorney that this  problem neighbor has hired. I do not like litigation, and I'm trying hard to NOT go that direction but need some help  from you please.    The picture of the pilings is attached. I measured less the 9' clearance with the boat docked in its deeded slip across the  basin.     I was promised a marine experts involvement. I was told by city officials that the pilings were going to be removed. After  the neighbor hired an attorney the city has drastically changed their position. Now with the virus we have more excuses  and no action being taken.     I am happy to have anyone come to my residence to observe this first hand. I will maintain distance from any who wish  to see the mess next door to me. Please call first 561 702‐7313.    Stay well and safe.    Respectfully,    Kathleen Kennedy        Letter from December:    It was a pleasure meeting you all at your town meeting. I reside at 1005 Grand Ct. in Boca Highland. I have  been to the city's building department several times for over a year, inquiring about my neighbor’s  construction of a boat lift. The last information from city officials was that this was never permitted to be so  Page 362 2 large and the permit is expired. I would like to see a copy of the approved permit. I called the State and they  confirmed that the contractor B&M construction falsely certified that this project met SPGP guidelines.      The permit issued does not meet code requirements and/or represent the structure that is under  construction. The SPGP self‐certification permit expired 7‐25‐2016 or 7‐25‐2017. The photo attached, (A), is  current and was taken in late 2019, which reflects an abandoned construction project that has not progressed  in over a year. The EPA guidelines clearly state: "This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or  rights of others." The pilings are over 20' high, the entire structure appears to be closer to 12' X 35'. Do you  have a minimum set back requirement and/or height requirement for pilings that pertain to neighboring  property lines? Do you have requirements for expired permits? Do you have enforcement policies for  structures that in violation of your municipal code that protect city ordinances, property values and vested  interests of Highland Beach residences?     The 10 massive pilings are abutting and possibly encroaching onto my property. The basin is now restricted to  less than 9' clearance. It has restricted my ability to have any boat larger than 20' and navigating that size boat  is extremely unsafe. If you are able to navigate through the new pilings the wind tunnel created here is  problematic for even small boats. I recently lost a buyer because of this restricted access. The waterway is  now virtually unusable for the 5 homes to the south east, and the boat slips across from me are severely  impacted. I have attached an image of this from the property appraiser's website, (B).     Below are references of codes I have researched and believe to be in violation, which I request further  investigation. I apologize in advance for the lengthy email, however, I moved into the city of Highland Beach  believing I and my property would be protected in the best interest to preserve the integrity and value of all  properties within. My parents and I have happily owned homes, (3813 South Ocean BLVD.), for over 30 years  and have always been proud to be part of this community. I thank you for your timely attention to this  matter.        Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations (g) (2)  (2) Boat basins. Boat basins may be permitted, as provided herein: a. Boat basins in all zoning districts on lots of one acre or more may be permitted as an accessory use. b. Boat basins in all zoning districts on lots of less than one acre shall be a special exception, subject to the standards listed below: 1. The edge of any improvements associated with a boat basin shall be located at least twenty-five (25) feet from side property lines. 2. The total length of improvements associated with a boat basin shall not exceed one-third (33.3%) of the length of the property line in which the basin is located. 3. Not more than twenty-five (25) percent of any boat moored in a boat basin may extend waterward of property line in which the basin is located. 4. Page 363 3 The town, at the expense of the applicant, may utilize appropriate marine, engineering, construction, and related professionals to review all aspects of such application. Such professionals shall be utilized to ensure compliance with the requirements herein, to ensure a proposed basin will not be a hazard to navigation, and to ensure a proposed boat basin will not pose a potential hazard, via erosion or other action, to the stability of neighboring properties. Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations (g) (4)  (g)  Accessory marine facilities:  (4)  Boats and setbacks. When moored, any portion of a boat shall not extend beyond any property line, as extended waterward.  Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations. (h)(1) c  (h)  Dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, and moorings:  (1)  Installation. In order to be installed, dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, and moorings shall comply with all standards listed below:  a.  The installation shall be subject to approval by the planning board at an advertised public hearing.  b.  The mooring facilities will be located in a canal or waterway at least eighty (80) feet in width.  c.  The mooring facilities will not create a hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the public reasonable visual access to public waterways.  Highland Beach code: Sec. 30-68. - Supplemental district regulations (h) (4)&(5)  (h)  Dolphins, freestanding pilings, boat lifts, and moorings:  (4)  Adjacent property. Installation of the mooring facilities shall not cause a hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the adjacent property owners or public reasonable visual access to the public waterway.  (5)  Navigation. Installation of such mooring facilities shall not infringe upon standard navigational practices that are or may be used by abutting property owners.     (2)  Public notice. In addition to the requirements of section 30-46, written notice must be provided by certified mail, return receipt requested, to owners of property abutting the canal and located within three hundred (300) feet, as measured from both property lines along the canal bank, of the property in question. In addition to the notice required above, if the mooring facilities identified in (h)(1) above are to be installed/constructed in the Bel Lido Isle subdivision, notice, by first class mail, shall be provided to the owners of property located in the Bel Lido Isle subdivision, where such property is located outside the 300 feet notice area but where the property line is within one thousand (1,000) feet of the property line of the property on which such installation/construction is proposed.  Page 364 4 I was never given notice of this lift, my neighbors did not receive any notice either. This structure has caused  me to lose the ability to use the dockage allotted to this property to its fullest potential. Not to mention, a loss  of property value to be in excess of 1 million dollars. I am requesting city involvement to enforce their codes  that protect residences, waterway navigation and property values. I have been informed the file has been  passed on to someone else, and it will be a while. How long will your review take? Do you intend to enforce  your codes?      Furthermore, 1006 Grand Ct. has completely blocked my view of the waterway with an overgrown ficus tree.  Ficus hedges and Areca Palms are all untrimmed and not maintained. A large ficus tree is planted less than 5'  from the property line, which is against city code. This tree is diseased, It has been treated and when the  leaves fall, my grass dies. It encroaches into my yard, at times overhangs on my roof, and has caused damage  to my pavers and irrigation. I'm sure that it will continue to cause damage to my foundation and plumbing if it  hasn't already. Several references from the municipal code regarding landscaping are in violation:     Sec. 28-5. - Landscape design standards. Chapter 28, Landscape Requirements:  Land values: Maintain and increase the value of land by requiring landscaping to be incorporated into development, thus becoming by itself a valuable capital asset.  (g)  Removal of nuisance species: Eradicate or control certain exotic plant species which have become nuisances because of their tendency to damage public and private works, to have a negative effect upon public health, or to disrupt or destroy native ecosystem  28-5 (4)(d)(2) Use of site-specific planting materials: Trees and other vegetation that are prohibited from use in meeting the landscape requirements of this chapter are so indicated in the Xeriscape Plant Guide and Pruning Manual maintained by the town. Trees and other vegetation shall be planted in soil and climatic conditions which are appropriate for their growth habits as set out in the Xeriscape Plant Guide and Pruning Manual maintained by the town. Plants used in the landscape design pursuant to this chapter shall to the greatest extent be: (2) Have noninvasive growth habits. I respectfully ask for your attention to and enforcement of the code violations mentioned above. Residents of Highland Beach have an expectation of standards to be upheld within the community. These standards heavily depend on the community itself to protect the value and prestigious Highland Beach brand.       Respectfully,    Kathleen Kennedy   Properties by Kennedy   561.702‐7313   kkboca@gmail.com   www.KennedyHomes.com    The linked image cannot be displayed. The file may have been moved, renamed, or deleted. Verify that the link points to the correct file and location.      Think Green: Please do not print this email unless absolutely necessary   Page 365 5 The information contained in this message may be privileged and confidential and   protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or   an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient,   you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copy of this   communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,   please notify us immediately by replying to the message and deleting it from your   computer.      Page 366 Page 367 Page 368 Page 369 Page 370 Page 371 Page 372 Page 373 Page 374 Page 375 Page 376 PUBLIC COMMENT #9 (19-0001) Kathleen Kennedy 07.07.2020 Page 377 Page 378 Page 379 Page 380 PUBLIC COMMENT #10 (19-0001) Kathleen Kennedy 07.07.2020 Page 381 1 Public Comments From:Kathleen Kennedy <kkboca@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, July 7, 2020 4:31 PM To:Marshall Labadie <mlabadie@highlandbeach.us>,, Cc: Marc N Siegel <mnsiegel@gmail.com>,, Paul_Resnick@msn.com,, Harry Adwar (Hadwar@msn.com) <Hadwar@msn.com>,, Fred M. Rosen (fredrosen@icloud.com); Ingrid Allen; Terisha Cuebas; Evalyn David; Greg Babij; Peggy Gossett- Seidman; Rhoda Zelniker; Douglas Hillman; Louis Mazzella; Public Comments; jboden@elderissues.com; John Shoemaker; Lanelda Gaskins; hbpublicrecords; Robert Pershes; Beverly Wright; Ganelle Thompson Subject:signed letter Attachments:signed letter to city 7.7.2020.pdf Please see the attached signed letter for your records.     Thanks for your time, stay well.      Respectfully,    Kathleen Kennedy       The linked image cannot be displayed. The file may have been moved, renamed, or deleted. Verify that the link points to the correct file and location.    Think Green: Please do not print this email unless absolutely necessary   The information contained in this message may be privileged and confidential and   protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or   an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient,   you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copy of this   communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,   please notify us immediately by replying to the message and deleting it from your   computer.          Virus-free. www.avast.com   Page 382 Page 383 Page 384 Page 385 PUBLIC COMMENT #11 (19-0001) Keith Newfield 07.08.2020 Page 386 1 Beverly Wright From:Beverly Wright Sent:Wednesday, July 8, 2020 12:19 PM To:Ingrid Allen; 'Len Rubin'; 'Brian DeMoss (golfdemoss@aol.com)'; 'David Axelrod (DZAXELROD@gmail.com)'; 'Eric Goldenberg (gldnbrg@gmail.com)'; 'Harry Adwar'; 'Ilyne Mendelson (msirm1@gmail.com)'; 'John Boden'; 'roger3265@aol.com' Subject:Planning Board Meeting Final Public Comments Item 9A Attachments:19-0001 PC (Read into Record) K. Newfield Email 07.08.2020 - Copy.pdf Good day all, As of 9:30 this am, Public Comments were closed. Attached is the final public comment for the 07.09.2020 PB meeting regarding Agenda Item 9A (19-0001 Touchette). Just FYI, the Town Clerk’s Office did not receive public comments for any other items on the agenda. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please call me. Thank you! Best regards,     Beverly A. Wright, Deputy Town Clerk   PUBLIC RECORDS NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from local officials, employees, or the general public regarding city business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. Page 387 1 Public Comments From:K Newfield <knewfield63@aol.com> Sent:Wednesday, July 8, 2020 8:28 AM To:Public Comments Subject:Comments to Application No. 19-0001 Re:Ten post platform boat lift The town of Highland Beach should not allow the proposed boat lift at 1006 Grand Court. The pilings that they have put in place are much higher than all the other pilings in highland beach and has an upper boarder of 2 x 4s. The hole structure is unsightly and needs to be reduced. All the other pilings in the canal are of uniform height, color and construction, giving the community a pleasant and upscale appearance. Also the corresponding lift that will be put in, will bring the bottom of the vessel above eye level and create an eye sore similar to being in a commercial boat yard.1006 Grand Court should adhere to the standards of the neighborhood in which they are in and not create a bad precedent for future lift projects. Thank you Keith Newfield Highland Beach resident Page 388 ADDENDUMS TO ITEM 9A (19-0001) RICHARD TOUCHETTE) PUBLIC COMMENTS Date: 07.09.2020 Page 389 PUBLIC COMMENT #12 (19-0001) Steven Pastor 07.9.2020 Page 390 1 Beverly Wright From:steven pastor <stevenpastor@msn.com> Sent:Thursday, July 9, 2020 12:27 AM To:dzaxelrod@gmail.com; gldnbrg@gmail.com; msirm1@gmail.com; hadwar@msn.com; golfdemoss@aol.com; roger3265@aol.com; jboden@elderissues.com; Beverly Wright; Lanelda Gaskins; Ingrid Allen; Len Rubin Subject:Application No. 19-0001 Good Evening Members of the Planning Board and Town Staff,     My name is Steven Pastor and my family and I are full‐time residents at 1004 Grand  Court.  Unfortunately, we did not receive notice of the July 9th Planning Board meeting via US  mail. I was informed of such meeting thru a neighbor earlier today causing me to inadvertently  miss the pre‐registration cut off for public comments as well as not affording me time to  consult with legal counsel. Therefore, I am emailing all of you in hopes that my opinions will be  heard.    I am strongly opposed to Application No. 19‐0001 regarding increasing the height of the dock  and 40,000lb boatlift at 1006 Grand Court.      My young children along with my wife and myself have truly enjoyed wonderful views down  the canal to the main waterway while sitting on our dock and back patio since purchasing our  home.  It actually was one of the many reasons we bought our home.  Since the installation of  the 10 extremely tall wood piles at 1006 Grand Court, the views from both floors of our home,  our dock and patio have been compromised by this large structure. I can only expect that once  a 40,000lb lift is installed and a boat that requires that strengthen of a lift is placed on such lift,  we will lose our waterway views.  Increasing the height of this visually obstructive dock will  only worsen the current situation.  This not only disappoints my family but will negatively  decrease the value of our home.    On a final note, in the time since this large structure has been erected, several of our friends  with 50+ft vessels have had challenges navigating around the piles at 1006 Grand Court.  From  their description, the waterway has been significantly narrowed and a challenge with the  current to get to our dock comfortably.        Thank you for your careful consideration,    Steven Pastor          Page 391 2              although you missed the pre‐registration cut‐off time for the July 9th Planning Board meeting, you are more than  welcome to send an email voicing your concerns related to Application No. 20‐0004 (1006 Grand Ct.)  Below are the  board members and town staff contact information.      Page 392 1 Beverly Wright From:steven pastor <stevenpastor@msn.com> Sent:Thursday, July 9, 2020 12:40 AM To:Lanelda Gaskins Cc:Marshall Labadie; Ingrid Allen; Beverly Wright; Len Rubin Subject:Re: July 9th Planning Board Meeting Lanelda,    I wanted to thank you for taking the time to speak with me earlier today.  I greatly appreciate your  explanations and as well as recommendations which I have followed.  I truly found speaking with both you and  Ingrid to be a pleasure.  This has been my first interaction with the City after having lived in Highland Beach for  more than 10 years.  I'm glad that we residents have such helpful and nice people working in our town.    Thank you again,    Steven Pastor  1004 Grand Court          From: Lanelda Gaskins <lgaskins@highlandbeach.us>  Sent: Wednesday, July 8, 2020 4:44 PM  To: stevenpastor@msn.com <stevenpastor@msn.com>  Cc: Marshall Labadie <mlabadie@highlandbeach.us>; Ingrid Allen <iallen@highlandbeach.us>; Beverly Wright  <bwright@highlandbeach.us>; Len Rubin <len@lgrubinpa.com>  Subject: July 9th Planning Board Meeting      Good afternoon Steven,     It was a pleasure speaking with you today.   Per our conversation, the Clerk’s Office has verified that your address (1004  Grand Court) was included in the mailing that was sent out via U.S. first class regular postage on June 24, 2020.  See  attachments.     As mentioned during our conversation, although you missed the pre‐registration cut‐off time for the July 9th Planning  Board meeting, you are more than welcome to send an email voicing your concerns related to Application No. 20‐0004  (1006 Grand Ct.)  Below are the board members and town staff contact information.          David Axelrod, Chairperson dzaxelrod@gmail.com   Eric Goldenberg gldnbrg@gmail.com  Ilyne Mendelson msirm1@gmail.com   Harry Adwar hadwar@msn.com   Brian DeMoss golfdemoss@aol.com  Roger Brown roger3265@aol.com  John Boden jboden@elderissues.com  Page 393 2 Beverly Wright bwright@highlandbeach.us  Lanelda Gaskins lgaskins@highlandbeach.us  Ingrid Allen iallen@highlandbeach.us  Leonard Rubin len@lgrubinpa.com     Please note, the Planning Board meeting will be livestreamed tomorrow, July 9th at 9:30 AM.  To access the meeting  agenda or view live streaming on the Town’s website click the following links:      Meeting agenda https://mmportal6.teammunicode.com/     Live streaming (https://highlandbeach.us/highland‐beach‐television‐2     Should you need further assistance, please feel free to contact me.                           Best Regards,  Lanelda Gaskins, MMC, FCRM  Town Clerk / Custodian of Public Records     Town of Highland Beach  3614 S. Ocean Boulevard  Highland Beach FL 33487  (561) 278‐4548 Office  (561) 265‐3582 Fax  www.highlandbeach.us     PLEASE NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the Town of Highland Beach officials and  employees regarding public business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e‐mail communications may be  subject to public disclosure. Under Florida law, e‐mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e‐mail address released in response to  a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by phone or in writing. The views expressed in this  message may not necessarily reflect those of the Town of Highland Beach.     Page 394 PUBLIC COMMENT #13 (19-0001) Lauren Galvane 07.6.2020 Page 395 1 Beverly Wright From:Lauren Galvani <lauren@snyderlawpa.com> Sent:Thursday, July 9, 2020 11:43 AM To:Ingrid Allen Cc:Beverly Wright Subject:Touchette - 1006 Grand Court Application for Boat Lift (Application 19-0001) My clients own and reside at the home located at 1009 Grand Court, as well as additional docks in the marina. My client  strongly objects to the Touchette boat lift.      The current structure violations are as follows:     1. Sec. 30‐68(h)(1)b of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states the mooring facilities shall be located in a  canal or waterway at least 80 feet in width. Please measure current waterway with existing docks across the  canal.      2. Sec. 30‐68(h)(4) & (5) of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states … (4) Adjacent property. Installation of  the mooring facilities shall not cause hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or  deny the adjacent property owners or public reasonable visual access to the public waterway.   … (5)  Navigation. Installation of such mooring facilities shall not infringe upon standard navigational practices that  are or may be used by abutting property owners.  3. Sec. 30‐68(h)(1)c of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states The mooring facilities will not create a  hazardous interference with navigation, endanger life or property, or deny the public reasonable visual access  to public waterways. There are 3 homes and multiple docks beyond this structure which this directly affects.      4. Sec. 30‐68(g)(2)b1 of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states The edge of any improvements associated  with boat basin shall be located at least twenty‐five (25) feet from the side property lines. His structure either  infringes on my property line or abuts.       5. Sec. 30‐68(g)(2)b4 of the Town’s Code of Ordinances, which states … compliance with the requirements herein,  to ensure a proposed basin will not be a hazard to navigation… This structure results in very dangerous  navigation hazards for myself and neighbors beyond its point due to the now very narrow waterway.      6. Sec. 30‐46, which states public notice is mandatory. The original approvals did not meet this requirement, as no  one in the community was notified. The additional 2 pilings further infringed on waterways without any notice  to community that uses the waterways.      This structure and its placement is the result of Lee Morris, the President of the HOA for Grand Cay, demanding the  structure be moved out of his sight line so that it improves the value of his property (which he has had on the  market for years). It is entirely inappropriate for its location and the placement of the boat lift is unacceptable  because it obstructs boat traffic. My clients have additional docks and this construction causes the docks 4‐7 to be  much more difficult to access. My clients were denied the right to put a lift in slip number 20 and consequently have  to navigate past this construction.     I understand that the vote on Mr. Touchette’s has now been delayed by 1 month to get comments from his  neighbors. I expect that he reach out to  Louis Mazzella for comment and input on the boat lift.         Lauren A. Galvani J.D., LL.M, Attorney   Page 396 2 Licensed in Florida, New York, New Jersey  Massachusetts and Washington D.C.     SNYDER & SNYDER, P.A.  2701 N.W. 2nd Avenue, Ste. 214, Boca Raton, Florida 33431  O 954‐475‐1139 ext 213  |  F 954‐475‐2634  New York Office 212‐300‐9363  lauren@snyderlawpa.com  |  www.snyderlawpa.com                Davie   |   Miami   |   Boca Raton     The information contained in this email message is legally privileged and confidential information intended only for the use of the individual or  entity named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copy  of this email is strictly prohibited.  If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify us by replying to the email and delete the  original message. Thank you.     Page 397 Page 398 Page 399 Page 400 Page 401 Page 402 Page 403 Page 404 Page 405 Page 406 Page 407 Page 408 Page 409 Page 410 Page 411 Page 412 Page 413 Page 414 Page 415 Page 416 Page 417 Page 418 Page 419 Page 420 Page 421 Page 422 Page 423 Page 424 Page 425 PUBLIC NOTICE APPLICATION NO. 20-0014 500 Ft Public Notification Boundary October 28, 2020 Dear Property Owner: This is to notify you that the PLANNING BOARD of the Town of Highland Beach will conduct a public meeting on Thursday, November 12, 2020 at 9:30 AM in the Commission Chambers at Town Hall, 3614 South Ocean Boulevard, Highland Beach, Florida to consider the following application: APPLICATION NO 20-0014 – REQUESTING AN AMENDMENT TO A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED TEN POST PLATFORM BOAT LIFT (APPLICATION NO. 39412) IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE HEIGHT OF THE BOAT LIFT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1006 GRAND COURT. APPLICANT: RICHARD TOUCHETTE The attached Notice of Public Meeting Protocol document, is an informational guide to provide you with assistance in attending, participating or viewing the meeting. The application is also available for inspection in the Town Clerk’s Office at Town Hall, Monday through Friday during normal business hours of 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Any person that decides to appeal any decision made by the Town Commission with respect to any matter considered at this meeting, such person will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. The Town of Highland Beach does not provide such a record. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons who need special accommodation to attend or participate in this meeting should contact the Town Clerk’s Office at (561) 278-4548 at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. If you are hearing or speech impaired, please contact the Florida Relay Service at 1-800-955-8770 or 1-800-955-8771. For additional information, please contact the Town Planner at (561) 278-4540. TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH, BUILDING DEPARTMENT Attachment Page 426 ADDENDUMS TO ITEM 9B (20-0014) RICHARD TOUCHETTE PUBLIC COMMENTS PB MEETING Date: 11.12.2020 PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Connie Strianese 11.04.2020 1 Public Comments From:Connie Strianese <libqual@verizon.net> Sent:Wednesday, November 4, 2020 12:53 PM To:Public Comments Subject:Re: Application No. 19-0001 By Richard Touchette Requesting an Amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat IiftTo (Application No. 39412) Dear Deputy Wright, I am writing this letter to just reinforce my previous opinion which was sent in the past about Mr. Touchette's application. We still feel strongly that the height which he is requesting to keep his poles at will be an eyesore. We are opposed to any height other than which the ordinance allows. Regards, Connie and Anthony Strianese Boca Highland Beach Club and Marina TH-2 Highland Beach, Fl 33487 516-551-0086 -----Original Message----- From: Connie Strianese <libqual@verizon.net> To: geriverola@gmail.com <geriverola@gmail.com> Sent: Mon, Jul 6, 2020 12:30 pm Subject: Fwd: Application No. 19-0001 By Richard Touchette Requesting an Amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat IiftTo (Application No. 39412) -----Original Message----- From: Public Comments <publiccomments@highlandbeach.us> To: Connie Strianese <libqual@verizon.net> Sent: Mon, Jul 6, 2020 12:25 pm Subject: RE: Application No. 19-0001 By Richard Touchette Requesting an Amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat IiftTo (Application No. 39412) Good day Connie Strianese, Thank you for expressing interest in public comment, during the Virtual Planning Board meeting scheduled for Thursday, July 9, 2020 at 9:30 A.M. Your comment will be read into record during the meeting under Item 9, New Business, public comments (APP. No. 19-0001 - Richard Touchette). Stay Safe. Best regards, Beverly A. Wright, Deputy Town Clerk 2 The linked image cannot be displayed. The file may have been moved, renamed, or deleted. Verify that the link points to the correct file and location.Town of Highland Beach 3614 S. Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, Florida 33487 Tel: (561) 278‐4548 Fax: (561) 265‐3582 Email: bwright@highlandbeach.us www.highlandbeach.us PUBLIC RECORDS NOTE: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from local officials, employees, or the general public regarding city business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e‐mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. From: Connie Strianese <libqual@verizon.net> Sent: Friday, July 3, 2020 1:31 PM To: Public Comments <publiccomments@highlandbeach.us> Subject: Application No. 19-0001 By Richard Touchette Requesting an Amendment to a previously approved ten post platform boat IiftTo (Application No. 39412) To Whom It May Concern, My name is Connie Strianese. I reside at 4744 South Ocean Boulevard TH-2, Boca Highland Beach Club and Marina. I am writing this letter in response to Public Notice Application No. 19-0001. Mr. Touchette was granted permission to put posts that measure four feet on his dock. He purposely did not abide by the town code and constructed 12 foot posts. It is disturbing that he feels he is special and does not have to abide by the Town ordinances. It is equally disturbing that his posts are an eyesore to the neighboring area. The town ordinance has been put in place for a reason. People specifically buy property on the water to dock their boats and to enjoy the beautiful view. Residents have paid more money for their waterfront property for the view. If residents construct eyesores along our waterway, we will lose our beautiful view that we enjoy and our property values will surely drop. The Highland Beach "Nuisance Code" considers anything that can cause a substantial deterioration in the value of the property in the neighborhood. Mr. Touchette is setting a precedent for the rest of the neighbors. If he can get away with this so could everyone else. I respectfully request that the Highland Beach Town Board do the right thing and have Mr. Touchette remove his posts immediately. Connie and Anthony Strianese 4744 South Ocean Boulevard TH-2 Highland Beach PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Geri Verola 11.05.2020 1 Public Comments From:geri verola <geriverola@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, November 5, 2020 6:12 AM To:Public Comments Cc:Bob Verola Subject:Application No 19-0001 by Richard Touchette I wrote this letter in July and still feel the same way. How many times is he going to appeal or alter this request. Please deny this request as you previously did Thank you . Read below. As an owner of a residence in Boca Highlands, and a boat owner in the marina, I strongly oppose of the proposed amendment as well as the site of the 10 posts that were previously approved. Residents of the Boca Highlands community take pride in their properties and the views that surround the area within the marina and the canals behind their properties. Those 10 huge posts are such an eye saw and obstruct the views of the properties across from them and adjacent to Mr Touchette’s property. Not only is it an ugly site, it will also bring the property values down for the nearby residents . When a property is valued, the view is a big factor. We don’t want to set a precedent in our community for other boat owners to request similar amendments. It seems to me that Mr Touchette got approval for 4 ft posts but decided to install 12 ft posts and ask for forgiveness. I ask that the Planning Board deny this request so Highland Beach can maintain its reputation as a beautifully maintained community and adhere to our codes to keep it that way. Thank you for your attention on this matter. Geri Verola Sent from my iPhone PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Tamara Faintuch 11.06.2020 1 Public Comments From:Tamara Faintuch <tsfxxoo@icloud.com> Sent:Friday, November 6, 2020 11:33 AM To:Public Comments Subject:1006 grand court #20-0014 To whom it may concern, Along term residents at 1011 Grand Court (20 yrs),we strongly oppose any modifications or changes to the code for increasing the height of the structure I cannot understand how the structure could have been approved in the scale and location. To add height to accommodate steel beams and necessary pulleys and machining to support a large boat seems way beyond code and any aesthetics for the marina The current location creates a navigational hazard and the expanding template of the lift structure is wholly disproportionate to the marina and ultimately to surrounding property values PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Jack Faintuch 11.06.2020 1 Public Comments From:Town of Highland Beach via Highland Beach Florida <publiccomments@highlandbeach.us> Sent:Friday, November 6, 2020 11:43 AM To:Public Comments Subject:Highland Beach Public Comment Submission Submitted on Friday, November 6, 2020 ‐ 11:43am  Submitted by anonymous user: 76.109.129.124  Submitted values are:  Contact Information   Name jack faintuch   Email Address   Telephone   Meeting Date Thu, 11/12/2020   Meeting Type Planning Board   Public Comments   Strongly opposed to any amendment. structure is way out of scale, navigational hazard and the antithesis of aesthetics  of the marina. placing steel, pulleys and mechanical drives on top of this unacceptable lift structure should not be  allowed. it directly affects its neighbors and every one else in the marina. nowhere is there ans obtrusive lift like that  which encroaches on the water ,safe navigation and access and it should not be in this marina which would further  diminish the aesthetics and property values  The results of this submission may be viewed at:  https://highlandbeach‐fl.municodemeetings.com/node/2411/submission/251  PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Kathleen Kennedy 11.11.2020 Public Comments From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Dear neighbors, Kathleen Kennedy < kkboca@gmail.com > Wednesday, November 11, 2020 1 :40 PM wsklar@cfjblaw.com <wsklar@cfjblaw.com > 11 gayle.grimes@gmail.com; lvm33496 @gmail.com < lvm33496@gmail.com > 11 tsfxxoo@aol.com; cast1e33487@yahoo.com <castle33487@yahoo.com > 11 wildgifts@hotmail.com; Jrkuzio@aol.com <jrkuzio@aol.com>11 tomkuzio@gmail.com; onegrandplace@gmail.com < onegrandplace@gmail.com > 11 bweprin@aol.com; roccodaidone@aol.com < roccodaidone@aol.com > 11 Bonnie Boroian < bonnie@blissfullybetter.com> 11 Bonnie Boroian (bonnie@boromail.com); pat@boromail.com < pat@boromail.com > 11 robynsilver@gmail.com; kkboca@gmail.com < kkboca@gmail.com > 11 Jeannette Schmitz Ucfschmitz@aol.com); Louis Mazzella; Lee Morris; Lauren@snyderlawpa.com; Paul Resnick; Harry Adwar (Hadwar@msn.com) <Hadwar@msn.com>11 Fred M. Rosen (fredrosen@icloud.com); Ingrid Allen; Terisha Cuebas; Barry Donaldson; Evalyn David; Greg Babij; Peggy Gossett-Seidman; Rhoda Zelniker; Douglas Hillman; DebraMFL; Michael Silver; kkboca@gmail.com <kkboca@gmail.com>, Michael Weiner < mweiner@ssclawfirm.com > 11 Rebecca Zissel < rzissel@ssclawfirm.com, Jeff Miller <jmiller@divorceyes.com >, Jason.Spanier@floridadep.gov>, Pempek, Jonathan C CIV (US); Jennifer Boussy Carroll; Michael Simon; Jannette Lyon; David Axelrod, Chairperson; Eric Goldenberg; Brian DeMoss; llyne Mendelson; John Boden; Harry Adwar (Hadwar@msn.com); rbrown@acslabtest.com; John Shoemaker; Marshall Labadie; Lanelda Gaskins; Beverly Wright; Public Comments; Len Rubin; Jenkins, Mike; hbpublicrecords; Ganelle Thompson; Kathleen Kennedy; bee: William Sklar; lvm33496 @gmail.com; Stephen & Barbara Williams; Janet Kuzio; Ken Pierce; roccodaidone@aol.com; bonnie@blissfullybetter.com; Patrick & Bonnie Boroian; steven pastor; Roger Brown; Marc N Siegel; Frank Mendez; lwalter@ssclawfirm.com; mweiner@ssclawfirm.com; rzissel@ssclawfirm.com; Neighbor Jeffrey and Lisa Miller; Spanier, Jason; Mullins, Robert; Robert Pershes; Andrea O'Rourke; Jefferyfl@gmail.com; Michael Catino; glsassistant@simonsigalos.com; prima723 Superstructure/Boat lift November city lett er.pdf Hope everyone is well. I wanted to update you on tomorrow's city meeting, Thursday November 12th at 9:30. Please see the attached Public Notice Application 20-0014. 1006 Grand Ct. is not complying with the city's order. They have submitted a revised application for building a massive boatlift. Over 3 years ago our late Mayor Feldman ordered a Cease And Desist on this project but still it continues. I have outlined in previous emails the numerous violations and navigational hazards this project creates. It devalues neighboring properties. It completely obstructs access to the basin: it protrudes out 17" into the waterway. There is less than 10' clearance for a boat to navigate into its slip. Views of the water from several neighboring properties are completely blocked .. Allowing this to proceed sets a precedent for all further development. It violates state regulations. The permits that allowed this are expired, and false information was used to allow issuance of permits to begin with. I have outlined all of this in prior emails. I appreciate your prompt attention in this. Please let the city know you do not agree with this Superstructure before tomorrow morning's meeting. Our Highland Beach Waterways need to be protected. I appreciate your time and consideration. 1 PUBLIC COMMENT (20-0014) Robyn Silver 11.11.2020 Public Comments From: Sent: To: Subject: Dear Lanelda Gaskins, Robyn Silver < robynbsilver@gmail.com > Wednesday, November 11, 2020 3:07 PM Public Comments; Michael Silver Richard Touchette Public Meeting The purpose of this email is to both pre-register for the meeting being held tomorrow, November 12, at 9:30 am in regards to the boat lift at 1006 Grand Court, as well as to voice our concern in regards to the structure itself. We, Michael and Robyn Silver, are the residents at 1001 Grand Court. We understand that the issue at hand is the height of the structure (which we are opposed to, as every other property in the community maintains dock pilings that are approximately four feet high and we feel that height should be consistent throughout the community) but our greater concern is the width of the structure. Our understanding is that the structure protrudes approximately 17 feet into the waterway and leaves a narrow passageway for us to travel from our property through the canal. After the last televised meeting we were under the impression that the city of Highland Beach was going to evaluate the structure's width in regards to navigation rules for safety. We believe that the width of the structure interferes with our ability to safely travel through the canal to the intracoastal waterway. We are boaters. We bought our home at 1001 Grand Court over two years ago because we wanted to enjoy our boating lifestyle. We do not begrudge any of our neighbors in wanting the same. However, individual boat lifts must fit within the confinements of the space available in the waterway. The resident at 1006 Grand Court should be allowed a boat lift, but the current position and size of the boat lift should not be allowed to interfere or impede other residents from safely accessing the waterway. Thank you for your time and attention. Please forward us information in regards to zoom access to the meeting. Sincerely, Robyn & Michael Silver 1 fib-oo Fifa M t3cTr rQ Center-Fifh FloorDORSTHYJACKS 301 North Olive Avenue wCFA,AAS West Palm Beach,FL 33401 �� wy Palm Beach Count Property Appraiser tel 561.355.3230 Y p Y Pp fax 561.355.3963 Pbcgev.orgf papa ORDER#: �cl, 1 DATE RECEIVED: (�r ' REQUEST FOR DATA RUN OR PROPERTY INFORMATION NAME OF COMPANY AND/OR INDIVIDUAL: Ele Zachariades, Dunay Miskel and Backman (PLEASE PRINT) ADDRESS: 14 SE 4th Street, Suite 36, Boca Raton, FL 33432 7HIGH[Abjj�(PLEASE PRINT) TELEPHONE NUMBER(S): 561-405-3300 E-MAIL ADDRESS: ele@dmbblaw.com RADIUS- OPTIONAL-WHERE NEEDED,(INDICATE NUMBER OF FEET FROM STARTING POINT): 500 3 2020 PROPERTY CONTROL NUMBERS(PCN-S) - FOR VARIANCES: P C H ART KENT PUBLIC RECORDS-DESCRIPTION OF RUN OR AREA REQUESTED: 1006 Grand Court, Highland Beach 24-43-47-09-00-002-0090 INDICATE AMOUNT 1 OWNERS LIST NEEDED: VARIANCE REQUEST 1 RADIUS MAP SETS CD FORMAT (CSV) 2 LABEL SETS EXCEL FORMAT I,THE UNDERSIGNED,WISH TO ORDER THE ABOVE DESCRIBED DATA RUN; (ORDER WILL BE PROCESSED ONLY AS MARKED OR AS INDICATED ABOVE). I UNDERSTAND THAT I WILL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY CHARGES INCURRED FROM PROCESSING THIS ORDER OUR OFFICE MAY CALL YOU TO REQUEST PAYMENT IN ADVANCE OR NON-REFUNDABLE DEPOSIT BEFORE THE WORK IS PROCESSED. OFFICE USE ONLY CONTACT: PUBLIC SERVICE DEPARTMENT-VARIANCES PHONE: PROPERTY APPRAISER PUBLIC RECORDS 561.355.2881 FAX:561.355.1528 EMAIL: pa-pubsvc@pbcgov.org Kelly 9uinn., (PRIN CONT CT AME) X SIGNAT••RE ~` �S' 1016120 DataRunikeq.Revised 06/05/2019 (DATE) WEST COUNTY NORTH COUNTY MID-WESTERN COMMUNITIES SOUTH COUNTY SERVICE CENTER SERVICE CENTER SERVICE:CENTER SERVICE CENTER 2976 State Roar(15 3188 PGA Blvd.,Suite 230T 200 Civic Center Way,Suite 200 14925 Cumberland Drive Belle Glade,FL 33430 Palm Beach Gardens,FL 33410 Royal Palm Beach,FL 33411 Delray Beach,FL 33446 tel 561.996.4890 tel 561.624.6521 tel 561.784.1220 tel 561.276.1250 fax 561.996.1661 fax 561.624.6565 fax.561.784.1241 fax 561.276.1278 Page 1 of 4 -( /' �� �c� OtCL'�c ' f kit, 10/6/2020 Property Appraiser GIS - PCN listing Buffer: S 24434709000020090 Buffer:500 24434704000060250 24434704010001145 24434709000020100 24434709030010102 24434709030011505 24434704000060251 24434704010001146 24434709000020110 24434709030010111 24434709030011506 24434704010001021 24434704010001147 24434709000020120 24434709030010112 24434709030011601 24434704010001034 24434704010001148 24434709000020130 24434709030010121 24434709030011602 24434704010001041 24434704010001151 24434709000020140 24434709030010122 24434709030011603 24434704010001042 24434704010001152 24434709000020150 24434709030010141 24434709030011604 24434704010001043 24434704010001153 24434709000020160 24434709030010142 24434709030011605 24434704010001044 24434704010001154 24434709000020170 24434709030010151 24434709030011606 24434704010001045 24434704010001167 24434709000020180 24434709030010152 24434709030011701 24434704010001051 24434704010001168 24434709000020190 24434709030010161 24434709030011702 24434704010001052 24434704010001173 24434709000020200 24434709030010162 24434709030011703 24434704010001053 24434704010001174 24434709000020210 24434709030010171 24434709030011705 24434704010001054 24434704010001175 24434709000020220 24434709030010172 24434709030011706 24434704010001061 24434704010001176 24434709000020230 24434709030011001 24434709030012010 24434704010001062 24434704010001181 24434709000020240 24434709030011002 24434709030012020 24434704010001063 24434704010001182 24434709000020250 24434709030011003 24434709030012030 24434704010001064 24434704010001201 24434709000020260 24434709030011004 24434709030012040 24434704010001071 24434704010001202 24434709000020270 24434709030011005 24434709030012050 24434704010001072 24434704010001203 24434709000020280 24434709030011006 24434709030012060 24434704010001073 24434704030000161 24434709000020290 24434709030011010 24434709030013010 24434704010001074 24434704030000181 24434709000020300 24434709030011020 24434709030013020 24434704010001081 24434704030000182 24434709000020310 24434709030011050 24434709030013030 24434704010001082 24434704030000183 24434709000020320 24434709030011101 24434709030013040 24434704010001083 24434704410000010 24434709000020330 24434709030011102 24434709030013050 24434704010001084 24434704410000020 24434709000020340 24434709030011103 24434709030013060 24434704010001085 24434704410000030 24434709030010011 24434709030011104 24434709030014010 24434704010001091 24434704460000010 24434709030010021 24434709030011105 24434709030014020 24434704010001092 24434704460000020 24434709030010022 24434709030011106 24434709030014030 24434704010001093 24434704460000030 24434709030010031 24434709030011201 24434709030014040 24434704010001094 24434709000010030 24434709030010032 24434709030011202 24434709030014050 24434704010001101 24434709000010040 24434709030010041 24434709030011203 24434709030014060 24434704010001102 24434709000010060 24434709030010042 24434709030011204 24434709030015010 24434704010001103 24434709000010070 24434709030010051 24434709030011205 24434709030015020 24434704010001104 24434709000010100 24434709030010052 24434709030011206 24434709030015030 24434704010001124 24434709000010210 24434709030010061 24434709030011401 24434709030015040 24434704010001125 24434709000020010 24434709030010062 24434709030011402 24434709030015050 24434704010001126 24434709000020020 24434709030010071 24434709030011403 24434709030015060 24434704010001127 24434709000020030 24434709030010072 24434709030011404 24434709030016010 24434704010001128 24434709000020040 24434709030010081 24434709030011406 24434709030016020 24434704010001131 24434709000020050 24434709030010082 24434709030011501 24434709030016030 24434704010001132 24434709000020060 24434709030010091 24434709030011502 24434709030016040 24434704010001133 24434709000020070 24434709030010092 24434709030011503 24434709030016050 24434704010001134 24434709000020080 24434709030010101 24434709030011504 24434709030016060 Page 2 of 4 10/6/2020 Property Appraiser GIS - PCN listing 24434709030017010 24434709060000202 24434709070000050 24434709080000410 24434709080000711 24434709030017020 24434709060000203 24434709070000060 24434709080000411 24434709080000712 24434709030017030 24434709060000204 24434709070000070 24434709080000412 24434709080000714 24434709030017040 24434709060000301 24434709070000080 24434709080000414 24434709080000715 24434709030017050 24434709060000302 24434709070000090 24434709080000415 24434709080000716 24434709030017060 24434709060000303 24434709070000100 24434709080000416 24434709080000801 24434709030018010 24434709060000304 24434709070000110 24434709080000501 24434709080000802 24434709030018020 24434709060000401 24434709070000120 24434709080000502 24434709080000803 24434709030018030 24434709060000402 24434709080000101 24434709080000503 24434709080000804 24434709030018040 24434709060000403 24434709080000102 24434709080000504 24434709080000805 24434709030018050 24434709060000404 24434709080000103 24434709080000505 24434709080000806 24434709030018060 24434709060000501 24434709080000104 24434709080000506 24434709080000807 24434709030019010 24434709060000502 24434709080000105 24434709080000507 24434709080000808 24434709030019020 24434709060000503 24434709080000116 24434709080000508 24434709080000810 24434709030019030 24434709060000504 24434709080000201 24434709080000509 24434709080000811 24434709030019040 24434709060000601 24434709080000202 24434709080000510 24434709080000812 24434709030019050 24434709060000602 24434709080000203 24434709080000511 24434709080000814 24434709030019060 24434709060000603 24434709080000204 24434709080000512 24434709080000815 24434709040000021 24434709060000604 24434709080000205 24434709080000514 24434709080000816 24434709040000024 24434709060000701 24434709080000206 24434709080000515 24434709080000901 24434709040000031 24434709060000702 24434709080000207 24434709080000516 24434709080000902 24434709040000032 24434709060000703 24434709080000208 24434709080000601 24434709080000903 24434709040000033 24434709060000704 24434709080000212 24434709080000602 24434709080000904 24434709040000034 24434709060000801 24434709080000215 24434709080000603 24434709080000905 24434709040000041 24434709060000802 24434709080000216 24434709080000604 24434709080000906 24434709040000042 24434709060000803 24434709080000301 24434709080000605 24434709080000907 24434709040000043 24434709060000804 24434709080000302 24434709080000606 24434709080000908 24434709040000044 24434709060000901 24434709080000303 24434709080000607 24434709080000909 24434709040000051 24434709060000902 24434709080000304 24434709080000608 24434709080000910 24434709040000052 24434709060000903 24434709080000305 24434709080000609 24434709080000911 24434709040000053 24434709060000904 24434709080000306 24434709080000610 24434709080000912 24434709040000054 24434709060001001 24434709080000308 24434709080000611 24434709080000914 24434709040000061 24434709060001002 24434709080000309 24434709080000612 24434709080000915 24434709040000062 24434709060001003 24434709080000312 24434709080000614 24434709080000916 24434709040000063 24434709060001004 24434709080000314 24434709080000615 24434709080001001 24434709040000064 24434709060001101 24434709080000315 24434709080000616 24434709080001002 24434709040000071 24434709060001102 24434709080000316 24434709080000701 24434709080001003 24434709040000072 24434709060001103 24434709080000401 24434709080000702 24434709080001004 24434709040000073 24434709060001104 24434709080000402 24434709080000703 24434709080001005 24434709040000074 24434709060001201 24434709080000403 24434709080000704 24434709080001006 24434709040000081 24434709060001203 24434709080000404 24434709080000705 24434709080001007 24434709040000082 24434709060001204 24434709080000405 24434709080000706 24434709080001008 24434709040000083 24434709070000010 24434709080000406 24434709080000707 24434709080001009 24434709040000084 24434709070000020 24434709080000407 24434709080000708 24434709080001010 24434709060000101 24434709070000030 24434709080000408 24434709080000709 24434709080001011 24434709060000201 24434709070000040 24434709080000409 24434709080000710 24434709080001012 Page 3 of 4 10/6/2020 Property Appraiser GIS - PCN listing 24434709080001014 24434709080001415 24434709080001716 24434709080001015 24434709080001416 24434709080031090 24434709080001016 24434709080001501 24434709080031100 24434709080001101 24434709080001502 24434709080031110 24434709080001102 24434709080001503 24434709080031120 24434709080001103 24434709080001504 24434709080031140 24434709080001104 24434709080001505 24434709080031150 24434709080001105 24434709080001506 24434709080032090 24434709080001106 24434709080001507 24434709080032100 24434709080001107 24434709080001508 24434709080032110 24434709080001108 24434709080001509 24434709080032120 24434709080001109 24434709080001510 24434709080032140 24434709080001110 24434709080001511 24434709080032150 24434709080001111 24434709080001512 24434709080001112 24434709080001514 24434709080001114 24434709080001515 24434709080001115 24434709080001516 24434709080001116 24434709080001601 24434709080001201 24434709080001602 24434709080001202 24434709080001603 24434709080001203 24434709080001604 24434709080001204 24434709080001605 24434709080001205 24434709080001606 24434709080001206 24434709080001607 24434709080001207 24434709080001608 24434709080001208 24434709080001609 24434709080001209 24434709080001610 24434709080001210 24434709080001611 24434709080001211 24434709080001612 24434709080001212 24434709080001614 24434709080001214 24434709080001615 24434709080001215 24434709080001616 24434709080001216 24434709080001701 24434709080001401 24434709080001702 24434709080001402 24434709080001703 24434709080001403 24434709080001704 24434709080001404 24434709080001705 24434709080001405 24434709080001706 24434709080001406 24434709080001707 24434709080001407 24434709080001708 24434709080001408 24434709080001709 24434709080001409 24434709080001710 24434709080001410 24434709080001711 24434709080001411 24434709080001712 24434709080001412 24434709080001714 24434709080001414 24434709080001715 Paqe 4 of 4 10/6/2020 Property Appraiser GIS - PCN listing 10 COVE TWHS °P44325 co o 0 0 CONDO 0090 0100 0909 0 CONDO CONDO o PMZ23946P179 0334 x31 OR3439P1349 31 00 36 03 45 0080 $ 0070 7 OCEAN C) CONDO P06060.0000CCN a` OR4289:t m 00000000 0231.. 0232 ir1 22 a 1 T, O r' 0 3637 Or ���� r � OR2354P0901 03 N STEPI BEACH 00 N cn N— Md- 34 � SHAMROCK 1 <- �- �� N ceo 0010002a 03 4 CONDO SIDE Ca o o �� '�o rT 0231 2 CONDO oo r-T- 00 1 2 3 ',: OR6537Pq 0181 0183 C ) 02 23 233 22 OR3268P600 Q" ca LT 16 3 37 001-0000 QQQQ 37 22,,46 P1767 46P1989 ..�__ ' �- 2 � -- 0 4 Russell Dr Rtf�..DR1VE-._- _.d _ ____� 10 10, .03 03 01 51051 10541062 10611064 10731074 1082 1083 1093 2110411011105 " aid 30 30- 01 o 1 103310 10 p42 1051��'T�� i ti r`,, 1082 10&4 ? 1094 M o 0 0 1106 B O CA COVE 1025 5 02 41 7 0000 0 0 0 0 00�� 0��`btk d9�,1094�r `—�� 1106 VILLAS CONDO M 0 r r r�- s- t-- c-T-r 1024102t� o 0�` 70 Qd" 10521053 1063OR2609P 17041072 1081 N,085 01091 0971092 1103 ^ J30 OR3627PO647 30 10231023 10431044 1085 1092 02330233 LTS RETAI 1022 1 022 1021 102 320232.._ INT IN OR2 5P1234 PROOF OF PUBLICATION RE:HIGHLAND BEACH ORD#187 ABND FLORIDA AVE COMMON 1153 ) J�7 01 2310231 AREA 1201 1 1 7 , 117 71167 7 77�7s 7Tl��6 71147 1132 1125 112 ' 006 51 1182 1168 7� s 7 1148 , T 77J, , , 1124 24 S EA FROLIC 1128 7'�7 7 7.>77 > > 7 1151 `�.7 77 7070 ��`�6' c�j�g 24 0 1202 02 j .��g ,>>6,6�76, 11521145 st 0 g 0 1 1151 c4 1131 c�133 11341127 0250006-0250 CONDO 1203 1203 8 �j 731174 1176 OR3876P1370 1131 01 0250 '58 OR27987P997 5 01 1128 9473PO422 OR10181 P859 os 08 04 04 LT 17 002-0010 OR8198P871 0010 0150 LT 18 2-12 0120 0010002-0150 0120 0040 a 15 LT 19 CARRON PARKER LT 16 P11020020 002-0040 LT 11 2-27 2-29 LT 8 0� 0160002-016016 160002'06160 HOUSE HIGHLAND 0040 0020 011OLT 12 0270 0290 002-0180 LT 15 LT 14 2-11 2-19 0270 0290 01800180 1 LT 20 COND EAST 002-0100 0190 0170002-0170 CONDO 002-0020 0100 0110 0190 LT 6 17 0020 0100 OR9382 002-0090 2-32 OR36848PO271 OR3487P1732 OR9135 P900 GRAND CAY ESTS 0090 0090 32o .. P289 UNREC LT 5 ., �- _ _..::.. __ ...._... .. 04 002-0260 20 09 18 0070 002-0050 0050 LT 4 0040 0260 0260 2-2�Q O� 0050 002-0130 001-0040 001-0040 08 0310 T 0200 2-70 17 0 O 1110,14 0040 o13oQ 130 LT 3 0040 0040 0310 OC3 2 0-3S N c0 C,,in N 9 002-0280. C3 0O o N CV o 0030 © a �2j-3�o-2 iP 0250 0280 O2s0 LT 2'. -.. tS1 10 001-0010 2-80230 2�s 0220 0140002-0140 0210 0010 0010 0340 OR10186 P1240 0140 06 06 0210 0240 002-0240 LT 1 2-330330 001-0030 0240 0330 0030 0030 001-0080 BRAEMAR ISLE 08 0070 001-0070 0080 0080 CONDO 07 EVANTON 07 0070 SAYE CONDO OR3644P1761 OR3694PO690 MILANI PARK EAST 07 0050 MILANI PARK 001-0050 03 WEST 0050 0060 001-0060 0060 03 MARINA > os 001-0100 m 0100 0100 � 0200 v -. 420. 001-0180 DALTON - �„° 0180 0'80 0120 PLACE - 001-0120 0170- 0160 0120 of CONDO 001-0170 1-16 1-15 001-0110 -,� 03 0170 ABERDEEN 0160 0150 0110 ARMS 001-019b0150 0110 n CONDO © . OR2951P0217 0100 001-0100 0010100 -_ 0100 OR1929PO630 0100 01 03 1 09 02 02 ADMIRALS WALK m TOWER A CU CONDO O z OR23648P0595 Dorothy Jacks, CFA Location: Downtown Service Center Palm Beach County 0 55 110 220 330 440 Key Property Appraiser Feet Map Scale Selected Parcels 100 300 500 Notes: Others 200 400 Produced on:10!612020 Pe klk� 24434704000060250 500 24434704010001052 500 24434704010001074 500 BOCA COVE PROP HOMEOWNER ASSN HARWOOD KAREN A& LLERAS TODD 902 CLINT MOORE RD STE 110 1032 RUSSELL DR 1108 RUSSELL DR BOCA RATON FL 33487 2846 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4230 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 24434704000060251 500 24434704010001053 500 24434704010001081 500 BOCA COVE PROPERTY HOMEOWNERS DEANGELIS ROSE DIDONATO JOHN& 902 CLINT MOORE RD STE 110 1034 RUSSELL DR 1110 RUSSELL DR BOCA RATON FL 33487 2846 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4230 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 24434704010001021 500 24434704010001054 500 24434704010001082 500 BOCA COVE PROP HMOWNERS ASSN INC SNELL MICHAEL& ECHEVERRIA DOROTHY J 902 CLINT MOORE RD# 110 1036 RUSSELL DR 1112 RUSSELL DR BOCA RATON FL 33487 2846 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4230 HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 4222 24434704010001034 500 24434704010001061 500 24434704010001083 500 GALVIN WILLIAM C& COHEN BARRY M& ASCIONE GERARD G& PO BOX 414 1042 RUSSELL DR 1114 RUSSELL DR CANTON MA 02021 0414 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4230 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4222 24434704010001041 500 24434704010001062 500 24434704010001084 500 LUPO MICHAEL JOSEPH SHREM RAFAEL S& BETON CONRAD A&CHERYL L TRUST 1020 RUSSELL DR 1038 RUSSELL DR 1116 RUSSELL DR# 71 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4230 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4230 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 24434704010001042 500 24434704010001063 500 24434704010001085 500 RADWAN MARIANNE N GELSO PATRICK SCILLA VINCENT JR 1026 RUSSELL DR 1040 RUSSELL DR 1118 RUSSELL DR HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4230 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4230 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4222 24434704010001043 500 24434704010001064 500 24434704010001091 500 MILLER MICHAEL H & LITTLE WINSTON W KATZ RONALD M& 5927 CHEROKEE DR PO BOX 1501 1122 RUSSELL DR FAIRWAY KS 66205 3317 RICHLAND WA 99352 1501 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4222 24434704010001044 500 24434704010001071 500 24434704010001092 500 MAYO JAIME WANKLYN JULIA& RADDI FRANKLIN D& 1024 RUSSELL DR# #53 709 SE 9TH ST 1120 RUSSELL DR HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4230 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 5127 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4222 24434704010001045 500 24434704010001072 500 24434704010001093 500 GARDNER EDMOND PAUL BUCHSBAUM DAVID A LEE SIMON& 1028 RUSSELL DR 1104 RUSSELL DR 1124 RUSSELL DR HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4230 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4222 24434704010001051 500 24434704010001073 500 24434704010001094 500 BURNLEY DEVON& EISENBAND NEIL B GAVLICK MICHAEL& 509 OWL HILL RD 1106 RUSSELL DR 1126 RUSSELL DR LITITZ PA 17543 8557 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 1 ® l' (ID C:� 24434704010001101 500 24434704010001132 500 24434704010001154 500 STENQUIST WILLIAM G COTTLE DAVID POSNER RONALD C& 1134 RUSSELL DR 1915 TOWNE CENTRE BLVD UNIT 907 1049 BOCA COVE LN HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4222 ANNAPOLIS MD 21401 3588 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4244 24434704010001102 500 24434704010001133 500 24434704010001167 500 FETCHO TRUDY& PENN BARBARA JANER WEISS HARRY 1128 RUSSELL DR 1127 BOCA COVE LN 1039 BOCA COVE LN BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4246 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4242 24434704010001103 500 24434704010001134 500 24434704010001168 500 ROBINSON SAMUEL T& GRECO THOMAS& FOECKING LELAND R& 1130 RUSSELL DR#78 1129 BOCA COVE LN # 2 1041 BOCA COVE LN BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4246 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4242 24434704010001104 500 24434704010001145 500 24434704010001173 500 BRZEZICKI ANTHONY J& PIAZZA CHRISTOPHER D& GELSO PATRICK& 1132 RUSSELL DR 1667 CENTRAL ST 1031 BOCA COVE LN BOCA RATON FL 33487 4222 STOUGHTON MA 02072 1609 BOCA RATON FL 33487 4242 24434704010001124 500 24434704010001146 500 24434704010001174 500 MALLOY JOHN PATRICK IV& FLEMING WILLIAM J& BROWN ERIC J& 1137 BOCA COVE LN 1053 BOCA COVE LN 1033 BOCA COVE LN BOCA RATON FL 33487 4246 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4244 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4242 24434704010001125 500 24434704010001147 500 24434704010001175 500 WALSDORF RISSA CHIGER RHONDA& PETRILLO PASQUALE& 2 LAUREL CT 17 FIFESHIRE ROAD 1035 BOCA COVE LN HUNTINGTON NY 11743 9730 TORONTO ONTARIO BOCA RATON FL 33487 4242 M2L 2G4 CANADA 24434704010001126 500 24434704010001148 500 24434704010001176 500 BUCHMAN JEFFREY& TOEWS TIMOTHY B& ARMSTRONG DAVID J & 1133 BOCA COVE LN 1057 BOCA COVE LN 1816 SE 1ST ST HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4246 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4244 DEERFIELD BEACH FL 33441 4528 24434704010001127 500 24434704010001151 500 24434704010001181 500 CARLSON ANIA D THAW MITCHELL RIESA MARTIN W& 1135 BOCA COVE LN 1043 BOCA COVE LN 1027 BOCA COVE LN BOCA RATON FL 33487 4246 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4244 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4242 24434704010001128 500 24434704010001152 500 24434704010001182 500 BOCA COVE PROPERTY HMOWNERS STEIN ROBERT N FOECKING LELAND R& 902 CLINT MOORE RD STE 110 1045 BOCA COVE LN 1041 BOCA COVE LN BOCA RATON FL 33487 2846 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4244 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4242 24434704010001131 500 24434704010001153 500 24434704010001201 500 FREUND THOMAS& TRINKOFSKY ROBERT S& LOGAN LOIS 1123 BOCA COVE LN 1047 BOCA COVE LN 1025 BOCA COVE LN BOCA RATON FL 33487 4246 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4244 HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 4242 24434704010001202 500 24434704460000020 500 24434709000020030 500 AKBASLI RITA KLAYMAN DAVID& PIERCE KENNETH& 1023 BOCA COVE LN PO BOX 332 1016 GRAND BAY CT HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4242 SHARON MA 02067 0332 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 24434704010001203 500 24434704460000030 500 24434709000020040 500 HYMAN JA'EL FISH BARRY& PIERCE KENNETH& 1021 BOCA COVE LN 40 PINE ST 1016 GRAND CT HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4242 NEEDHAM MA 02492 1019 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 24434704030000161 500 24434709000010030 500 24434709000020050 500 HIGHLAND HOUSE HIGHLAND BEACH HOLDINGS LP KENNEDY KATHLEEN 1111 RUSSELL DR APT A 4612 S OCEAN BLVD 1005 GRAND CT HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4278 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5330 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 24434704030000181 500 24434709000010040 500 24434709000020060 500 BOAN GREGORY M& TROIANO FRANK P& LIMEROSE REVOCABLE TRUST 1101 RUSSELL DR 4611 S OCEAN BLVD 931 HYACINTH DR BOCA RATON FL 33487 4221 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5300 DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 4808 24434704030000182 500 24434709000010060 500 24434709000020070 500 TRIVENTO LOUIS P& PALM BEACH COUNTY PIERCE KENNETH& 1103 RUSSELL DR 2633 VISTA PKWY 1016 GRAND BAY CT HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 4221 WEST PALM BEACH FL 33411 5613 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 24434704030000183 500 24434709000010070 500 24434709000020080 500 TRIVENTO LOUIS& BOCA HIGHLAND CENTER INC PIERCE KENNETH& 1105 RUSSELL DR 4801 S OCEAN BLVD 1016 GRAND BAY CT BOCA RATON FL 33487 4221 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5305 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 24434704410000010 500 24434709000010100 500 24434709000020100 500 GOLDBERG DAVID C& BOCA HIGHLAND CENTER INC KUZIO JANET& 1023 RUSSELL DR UNIT 1 4801 S OCEAN BLVD 1014 GRAND CT HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 4299 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5305 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 24434704410000020 500 24434709000010210 500 24434709000020110 500 GOLDBERG DAVID& �� ` HIGHLAND BEACH HOLDINGS LP STRANDBERG GREGG S& 1023 RUSSELL D..>'-f 4612 S OCEAN BLVD 1012 GRAND CT BOCA RAT9N--'FL 33487 4299 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5330 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 24434704410000030 500 24434709000020010 500 24434709000020120 500 GOLDBERG FAMILY TRUST& REDPATH INVESTMENT CORP HAMUY NISSAN& 1023 RUSSELL DR APT 1_ - 2000 N DIXIE HWY STE 201 1017 GRAND CT BOCA RATON FL-33487 4299 BOCA RATON FL 33431 8000 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 24434704460000010 500 24434709000020020 500 24434709000020130 500 1019A LLC WILLIAMS STEPHEN& PASTOR STEVEN M& 272 WALNUT ST 1015 GRAND CT 1004 GRAND CT NUTLEY NJ 07110 1822 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 4-1 24434709000020140 500 24434709000020240 500 24434709000020340 500 SKLAR WILLIAM P& SILVER MICHAEL J& MAZZELLA ANNE J TRUST 1002 GRAND CT 1001 GRAND CT 1855 DR ANDRES WAY STE 2 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 DELRAY BEACH FL 33445 4658 24434709000020150 500 24434709000020250 500 24434709030010011 500 WEPRIN WILLIAM S MILLER JEFFREY& APPLEYARD DONNA TRUST& 1018 GRAND CT 415 PALM DR 303 HURLEY AVE BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 ISLAMORADA FL 33036 4211 KINGSTON NY 12401 2416 24434709000020160 500 24434709000020260 500 24434709030010021 500 DAIDONE JOHN E& GORDON HOMES INC STERN RICHARD B H & 265 LARGER CROSS RD 275 SE SPANISH TRL 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 2A BEDMINSTER NJ 07921 2721 BOCA RATON FL 33432 6232 BOCA-BATON FL 33487 5302 24434709000020170 500 24434709000020270 500 24434709030010022 500 BOROIAN PATRICK J MFG REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LLC SUAU PHILLIP R& 1020 GRAND CT 11988 STATE ROUTE 45 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 2B HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 LISBON OH 44432 9615 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5302 24434709000020180 500 24434709000020280 500 24434709030010031 500 MORRIS LELAND M& LUKENDA RICHARD J CAMARENA CARMEN PARAMO& 1008 GRAND CT 1003 GRAND CT 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 3A BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5302 24434709000020190 500 24434709000020290 500 24434709030010032 500 FAINTUCH JACK SOL MAZZELLA LOUIS V& TORRES PRISCILA 1011 GRAND CT 1009 GRAND CT 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 3B BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 5302 24434709000020200 500 24434709000020300 500 24434709030010041 500 MAZZELLA ANNE J TRUST BOAT SLIP 13 OF GRAND CAY ESTATES LLC SYLVESTER MARTIN& 401 E LINTON BLVD APT 417 1020 GRAND CT 110 W 86TH ST DELRAY BEACH FL 33483 5025 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 NEW YORK NY 10024 4049 24434709000020210 500 24434709000020310 500 24434709030010042 500 WEPRIN WILLIAM S& FAINTUCH JACK S& AUBE TRUST& 1018 GRAND CT 1011 GRAND CT 1130 MATTAWA BLVD STE 1002 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 LAVAL QC H7P OH6 CANADA 24434709000020220 500 24434709000020320 500 24434709030010051 500 BOROIAN PATRICK J& GORDON HOMES INC THIERMAN TOBY TR 1020 GRAND CT 1014 GRAND CT 4748 S OCEAN BLVD #801 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5306 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 24434709000020230 500 24434709000020330 500 24434709030010052 500 PIERCE KENNETH&.: BOCA HIGHLAND CENTER INC GRISALES HUGO& 1016 GRAND-CT 4801 S OCEAN BLVD 4748 S OCEAN BLVD #5B BO�APATON FL 33487 5306 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5305 .HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5302 t 24434709030010061 500 24434709030010111 500 24434709030010171 500 HRC 55 INVESTMENTS LLC PAPPAS DEAN& SIMON ROBERT& 55 NE 5TH AVE# 501 357 JUNIPER DR 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT PH-A BOCA RATON FL 33432 4093 UPPER BROOKVILLE NY 11771 4608 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5367 24434709030010062 500 24434709030010112 500 24434709030010172 500 PAKLER MITCHELL P& LEWIS WARREN& �lm PARKAS JUDITH M& 537 N NEVILLE ST APT 2E 4748 S OCEAN.BLVD APT 11B 290 W END AVE APT 9D PITTSBURGH PA 15213 2768 HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 5302 NEW YORK NY 10023 8106 24434709030010071 500 24434709030010121 500 24434709030011001 500 MH&OL LLC JAHRR LLC NICOLIA ROBERTO L SR 55 NE 5TH AVE# 5 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 12A 100 THOMPSON AVE BOCA RATON FL 33432 4000 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5328 BABYLON NY 11702 3405 24434709030010072 500 24434709030010122 500 24434709030011002 500 LEVENTHAL RICHARD G SCHOTT LEILA DUBE NELSON '`" 1806 PORT KIMBERLY PL 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 12B 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1002 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660 6620 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5303 HIGHLAND FL 33487 5316 24434709030010081 500 24434709030010141 500 24434709030011003 500 GOENS MARILYN J& FELDMAN STEMPEL RAZELLE.S BRENNER LEONARD A& 4748 S OCEAN-BLVD UNIT 8A 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 14A 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1003 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5302 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5328 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5316 24434709030010082 500 24434709030010142 500 24434709030011004 500 RONDINELLA JOHN A TRUST TARCOTTE GILLES& DAVIS WILLIAM& 4750 S OCEAN BLVD PH 5 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 14B 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1004 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5312 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5303 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5316 24434709030010091 500 24434709030010151 500 24434709030011005 500 GROPPER DANIEL M& ENGEL LON C& NEWFIELD KEITH B 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 9A 4748 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 15A 4748 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1005 BOCA RATON-FL 33487 5302 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5328 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5316 i 24434709030010092 500 24434709030010152 500 24434709030011006 500 REAME RONALD GOLDMAN JEROME& HECHT NAOMI 4748 S OCEAN BLVD#9B 225 CENTRAL PARK W APT 1105 16416 CHERRY WAY BOCA RATON FL 33487 5302 NEW YORK NY 10024 6047 DELRAY BEACH FL 33484 6607 24434709030010101 500 24434709030010161 500 24434709030011010 500 GRUHIN SUSAN B& GROSSMAN STANLEY& DALTON PLACE CONDO ASSN INC 6 MASTERS CT 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT LPH-A 4748 S OCEAN BLVD POTOMAC MD 20854 3841 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5344 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5367 11 24434709030010102 500 24434709030010162 500 24434709030011020 500 THALER BRUCE J& PERLSTEIN MORTON& ROMANYK DEBORAH J 116 UNION AVE 4748 S OCEAN BLVD PH LPHB 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 102 ALTOONA PA 16602 3246 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5344 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5303 =7 24434709030011050 500 24434709030011204 500 24434709030011503 500 DALTON PLACE COND ASSN INC MARGUERITE JOANNA METNICK LARRY& 4748 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 105 PO BOX 272 1827 MCCRAREN RD BOCA RATON FL 33487 5303 FRANKLIN MA 02038 0272 HIGHLAND PARK IL 60035 2226 24434709030011101 500 24434709030011205 500 24434709030011504 500 SYLVIA S HAMBURGER TRUST HAIN ANNALISA BEDRIN PAUL E& 27440 LAKEHILLS DR 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1205 81 WINDSOR LN FRANKLIN MI 48025 1098 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5316 RAMSEY NJ 07446 2401 24434709030011102 500 24434709030011206 500 24434709030011505 500 MAYS TIMOTHY& GALTON KIM A LONGO MARIA& 3 HEARTHSTONE DR 201 COMMONS PARK S UNIT 2205 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1505 HUNTINGTON STATION NY 11746 5004 STAMFORD CT 06902 7073 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5313 24434709030011103 500 24434709030011401 500 24434709030011506 500 JACOBS CELIA R SBARSKY ARTHUR A GOSSELIN MARIO 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1103 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1401 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1506 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5316 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5341 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5313 24434709030011104 500 24434709030011402 500 24434709030011601 500 LEVY ALBERT KORUS PAUL& LEVINE ROBERT E 25 SUTTON PL S 4748 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1402 4748 S OCEAN BLVD PH LPH1 NEW YORK NY 10022 2409 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5341 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5303 24434709030011105 500 24434709030011403 500 24434709030011602 500 AKSELRAD CLAIRE A G WEINBERGER EVA BLASE FANNIE F TRUST 29 HILLCREST RD 4748 S OCEAN BLVD# 1403 8074 N MILWAUKEE AVE CALDWELL NJ 07006 7739 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5341 NILES IL 60714 2802 24434709030011106 500 24434709030011404 500 24434709030011603 500 DI RE VICTOR& YERMAN ROBERT J& PALASKE DANIEL E 141 DARTERS LN 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1404 4748 S OCEAN BLVD PH LPH3 MANHASSET NY 11030 4024 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5341 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5303 24434709030011201 500 24434709030011406 500 24434709030011604 500 EVENTOFF LUCILLE TRUST& CANTER ROBERT LPH4 INC 1235 NORTH LOOP W STE 205 4748 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1406 901 PONCE DE LEON BLVD # 501 HOUSTON TX 77008 4701 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5341 MIAMI FL 33134 3060 24434709030011202 500 24434709030011501 500 24434709030011605 500 WOLF JOHN& CORBETT GARY A& KARLIN LOUISE& 11 LYONS RD 4748 S OCEAN BLVD# 1501 1228 SPRING LAKE DR ARMONK NY 10504 2225 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5313 ORLANDO FL 32804 7132 24434709030011203 500 24434709030011502 500 24434709030011606 500 DIRE GUIDO& HOROWITZ WALLACE& MUTAFYAN AYSEN APAYDIN& ' 8 REDMOND LN 4748 S OCEAN BLVD# 1502 4748 S OCEAN BLVD PH'LPH6 OYSTER BAY NY 11771 3109 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5313 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5303 -x 24434709030011701 500 24434709030012060 500 24434709030014040 500 MORRISON DAVID H& KOHEN SHELDON COHEN FAMILY REALTY TRUST 8642 HENDRIE BLVD 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 206 35 DENLOW BLVD HUNTINGTN WDS MI 48070 1620 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5368 TORONTO ONTARIO M3B 1P6 CANADA 24434709030011702 500 24434709030013010 500 24434709030014050 500 FRANK PAULA M YUIL JENNIFER DER AVEDISIAN THELM B REVOCABLE TRUST 4748 S OCEAN BLVD# PH 4 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 301 22 ADAMS AVE HIGHLAND.BEACH FL 33487 5303 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5368 WATERTOWN MA 02472 1391 24434709030011703 500 24434709030013020 500 24434709030014060 500 LAVIGNE FRANCOIS& STRUMWASSER ELAINE HILLMAN DOUGLAS C& 25 AINSLIE AVENUE 2255 GLADES RD STE 321A 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 406 MONTREAL QC BOCA RATON FL 33431 7383 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5368 H2V 2Y2 CANADA 24434709030011705 500 24434709030013030 500 24434709030015010 500 LAVIGNE YVAN& MANSOUR JOSEPH A JR TRUST& MAZZA MARCELLO S 4748 S OCEAN BLVD PH 5 6 BELLMAR RD 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 501 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5303 COVENTRY RI 02816 8292 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5368 24434709030011706 500 24434709030013040 500 24434709030015020 500 FRANKEL RICHARD G& BRAUNSTEIN JONI B COHEN BARBARA L 4748 S OCEAN BLVD PH 6 21113 NE 38TH AVE 120140 BOTELER STREET BOCA RATON FL 33487 5303 AVENTURA FL 33180 4021 OTTAWA ON K1N 9C8 K1N 9C8 CANADA 24434709030012010 500 24434709030013050 500 24434709030015030 500 DI SANTO JASPER& GREENE JOHN D& FELDMAN LINDA G 4748 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 201 4748 S OCEAN BLVD#305 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 503 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5303 BOCA-RATON FL 33487 5368 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5368 /J 24434709030012020 500 24434709030013060 500 24434709030015040 500 TYROLER RICHARD& WOOD KENNETH G FRANKEL SYLVIA TRUST 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 202 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 306 1 STRAWBERRY HILL CT APT 5H HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5344 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5368 STAMFORD CT 06902 2529 24434709030012030 500 24434709030014010 500 24434709030015050 500 9202 9495 QUEBEC INC SWIFT MARY ANN& QUEZADA JULIA M 2950 LOSCH BLVD 4748 S OCEAN BLVD #401 4748 S OCEAN BLVD# 505 SAINT HUBERT QC HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5368 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5368 J3Y 3V8 CANADA 24434709030012040 500 24434709030014020 500 24434709030015060 500 DIBLASI JOSEPH& BOUCHER PAUL TRUST& MIRSHOKRAIE MEHRNOOSH& 29 RIVERFIELD DR 32 RUE DU GRAND DUC 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 506 WESTON CT 06883 2947 VERDUN QUEBEC BOCA RATON FL 33487 5368 H3E 1V3 CANADA 24434709030012050 500 24434709030014030 500 24434709030016010 500 REMA 2017 TRUST COSTA SAM MONTEMARANO ANGELO& 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 205 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 403 103 CHRISTIAN HILL RD BOCA RATON FL 33487 5368 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5368 DOVER PLAINS NY 12522 5038 110 24434709030016020 500 24434709030017060 500 24434709030019040 500 GUGENHEIM ADRIANNA SANCHEZ MARIO J& KANEFIELD ISABEL 4748 S OCEAN,BLVD UNIT 602 4900 N OCEAN BLVD# 1714 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 904 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5315 FORT LAUDERDALE FL 33308 2939 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 r' 24434709030016030 500 24434709030018010 500 24434709030019050 500 MARCOVICH SHLOMO P THIERMAN TOBY MALDONADO RAFAEL& 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 603 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 801 3 CEDARWOOD RD HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 HIGHLA D BEACH FL 33487 5315 WHITE PLAINS NY 10605 5308 24434709030016040 500 24434709030018020 500 24434709030019060 500 SELNICK SCOTT& SCHOTT ROSLYN SCHULMAN IRA& 11874 FARSIDE RD 40 WHITBAY DR 4748 S OCEAN BLVD# 906 ELLICOTT CITY MD 21042 1526 WEST ORANGE NJ 07052 6603 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5315 24434709030016050 500 24434709030018030 500 24434709040000021 500 KRAMAN DAVID J& EARNEST THOMAS E& REASON MARGARET J TRUST 510 CLOTHIER RD 6235 KERRICK DR 3789 INDIAN TRL WYNNEWOOD PA 19096 2213 LA PLATA MD 20646 3326 ORCHARD LAKE MI 48324 1626 24434709030016060 500 24434709030018040 500 24434709040000024 500 MAYER SANDRA G COHEN MATTATIA DEMIRJIAN MARY J REVOCABLE TRUST 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 606 4748 S OCEAN BLVD#804 20 LAKE POINTE BOCA RATON FL 33487 5315 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 DECATUR IL 62521 5500 24434709030017010 500 24434709030018050 500 24434709040000031 500 BIRNBAUM MELVIN& DODKOWITZ BRUCE&SHARON J JAHRE ANNE M 4748 S OCEAN BLVD# 701 46 LARCH DR 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 3A BOCA RATON FL 33487 5315 NEW HYDE PARK NY 11040 2343 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5339 24434709030017020 : 500 24434709030018060 500 24434709040000032 500 BAYON KARIN ,~ PILLENIERE ALAIN& DAMICO BARBARA A TRUST 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 702 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 806 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 3B HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5365 24434709030017030 500 24434709030019010 500 24434709040000033 500 DASHEFSKY CLAIRE STEIN T PETER& COHEN GERALD 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 703 89 MATLACK DR 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 3C HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 VOORHEES NJ 08043 4773 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5339 24434709030017040 500 24434709030019020 500 24434709040000034 500 BAKER BARRY& ZUNICK SCOTT LERNER JUDITH L 31 OKANAGAN DR 7 SEAPORT DR APT 224 4605 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 3D OTTAWA ONTARIO QUINCY MA 02171 1577 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5365 K2H 7E9 CANADA 24434709030017050 500 24434709030019030 500 24434709040000041 500 MANN RICHARD H LABEMA CORP PERER ALAN H& 4748 S OCEAN BLVD APT 705 ELGIN COURT, ELGIN AVE 1515 BEECHWOOD BLVD HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5315 PO BOX 448 GRAND CAYMAN PITTSBURGH PA 15217 1431 KY1-1106 CAYMAN ISLANDS r 24434709040000042 500 24434709040000064 500 24434709060000201 500 HARRIS FAMILY 2002 TRUST SOOJIAN WAYNE& URQUIDI MARIA P 15 AZALEA RD 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 6D 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 201 WALTHAM MA 02452 4701 HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 5366 BOLA RAtON FL 33487 5389 24434709040000043 500 24434709040000071 500 24434709060000202 500 SETTLER EUGENE B& HIGHLAND BEACH TRUST COLUCCI PETER S& 4605 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 4C 17 NORTH ST 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 202 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5339 MANCHESTER NH 03104 3016 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5389 24434709040000044 500 24434709040000072 500 24434709060000203 500 KOPPEN HENRI T& FERRARA LORI A WEISMAN ILYA&FAINA TRUST 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 4D 4605 S OCEAN BLVD#7B 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 203 HIGHLAND-BEACH FL 33487 5365 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5366 BOCA_RATON FL 33487 5389 24434709040000051 500 24434709040000073 500 24434709060000204 500 YOWELL GORDON& PRINS EDMOND L& BRAVE BRADLEY M 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 5A 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 7C 220 W 98TH ST APT 11B HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5339 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5340 NEW YORK NY 10025 5677 24434709040000052 500 24434709040000074 500 24434709060000301 500 KRANE STUART G CARR ALAN MORRIS ALLEN D& 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 5B 4605 S OCEAN BLVD 15470 VANTAGE PT BOCA RATON FL 33487 5365 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5323 REDDING CA 96001 8710 24434709040000053 500 24434709040000081 500 24434709060000302 500 JACKSON MARY L EST SANDLER ADAM LONGO FRANK A& 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 5C 101 MADELINE RD 2874 LEE PL HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5340 MANCHESTER NH 03104 2017 BELLMORE NY 11710 5030 24434709040000054 500 24434709040000082 500 24434709060000303 500 JINX BEACH TRUST PEER TONYA J GREENBERG RIMA 86 FOREST HEIGHTS BLVD 4605 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 8B 4600 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 303 TORONTO HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5366 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5389 ON M2L 2K8 CANADA 24434709040000061 500 24434709040000083 500 24434709060000304 500 INGLIMA ROBERT J & GILROY BRIAN TRUST LABARRE PATRICK& 4605 S OCEAN BLVD#6A 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 8C 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 304 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5340 HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 5340 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5389 24434709040000062 500 24434709040000084 500 24434709060000401 500 KIRSH MICHAEL BROWN BARBARA S& TALBERT EDITH H& 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 6B 4605 S OCEAN BLVD APT 8D 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 401 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5366 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5366 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5389 24434709040000063 500 24434709060000101 500 24434709060000402 500 BERKELEY ESTER S �.• "' 622 BOCA DEVELOPMENT LLC WEINBERG JUNE G TRUST 4605 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 6C 8 BARSTOW RD APT 2A 33 WADE ST HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5340 GREAT NECK NY 11021 3542 BRIGHTON MA 02135 5702 �r r � /0 24434709060000403 500 24434709060000701 500 24434709060000903 500 LAKIS JOANN M TRUST DERRICO SANDRA L PILOSSOPH SUSAN 7 OTTAWA TRL 2 SHERRY LEE LN 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 903 GALESBURG IL 61401 5546 PEABODY MA 01960 1441 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5390 24434709060000404 500 24434709060000702 500 24434709060000904 500 SCHMID CLAUDE ZEIFF MEREDITH S SPARKS HAROLD L 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 404 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 702 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 904 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5389 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5342 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5390 24434709060000501 500 24434709060000703 500 24434709060001001 500 FINKEL SANDE PAPAGIANNIS GEORGIOS& BINSTEIN BEVERLY TR 14 WINTHROP RD 315 PARKWOOD CIR 9655 WOODS DR UNIT 1902 PLAINVIEW NY 11803 1123 DORVAL QUEBEC SKOKIE IL 60077 4435 H9S 3A4 CANADA 24434709060000502 500 24434709060000704 500 24434709060001002 500 JAGERNAUTH MADAN M& DAVIS LEWIS D& BAKELMAN JACK S 4600 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 502 30340 KINCARDINE 4600 S OCEAN.BLVD APT 1002 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5389 FRANKLIN MI 48025 1419 HIGH LAN d-BEACH FL 33487 5390 24434709060000503 500 24434709060000801 500 24434709060001003 500 WARHEIT LYNNE S& CINELLI MARIO SEIGEL ERIC& 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 503 43- 1450 OCONNER DR BLDG 2 STE 300 47 WILMINGTON DR BOCA RATON FL 33487 5389 TORONTO ON MELVILLE NY 11747 4032 M4B 2T8 CANADA 24434709060000504 500 24434709060000802 500 24434709060001004 500 BALLEN HELENE MOORE WILLIAM L& VALLERAND HELEN G 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 504 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 802 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1004 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5389 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5390 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5390 24434709060000601 500 24434709060000803 500 24434709060001101 500 RUGE JOHN R TR BUDZITOWSKI VINCENT& SPITALE CONO& 3700 N LAKE SHORE DR 12 TIFFANY LN#A 18 ELDER CR RR#1 CHICAGO IL 60613 4243 SMITHTOWN NY 11787 4706 JERSEYVILLE ON LOR 1RO CANADA 24434709060000602 500 24434709060000804 f 500 24434709060001102 500 BUHAY BOZZONE KELLI M BOYER ROSLAIDE M GRILLI ROCCO& 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 602 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 804 111 MAPLE DR HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5342 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5363 STONEY CREEK ON L8G 4T2 CANADA 24434709060000603 500 24434709060000901 500 24434709060001103 500 NUWESRA LEE& STELLA JOHN& SUSAN COLE TRUST FBO ROBERT COLE 16 WESTMINSTER DR 2271 HALYARD DR 4600 S OCEAN BLVD CROTON ON HUDSON NY 10520 1008 MERRICK NY 11566 5526 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5320 24434709060000604 500 24434709060000902 500 24434709060001104 500 BOUSFIELD PATRICIA J& LEOGRANDE DONALD TRUST MINTON LINDA SAXL 4600 S OCEAN BLVD APT 604 80 WINDSOR AVE 60 E END AVE APT 31B HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5342 MINEOLA NY 11501 1922 NEW YORK NY 10028 7946 24434709060001201 500 24434709070000080 500 24434709080000116 � 500 ROSE GARY J STAMPP TIM& BRAMI RHONDA 4600 S OCEAN BLVD"APT 1201 4746 S OCEAN BLVD APT 8 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 116 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5320 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5388 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5345 24434709060001203 500 24434709070000090 500 24434709080000201 500 TELVI MURRAY& EPLAN STEVEN& GRADY JOHN W 2017 FMLY TRUST 4600 S OCEAN BLVD,# PH3 4746 S OCEAN BLVD APT TH-09 10 KUDYBA CT BOCA RATON FL 33487 5390 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5388 ENGLISHTOWN NJ 07726 8832 24434709060001204 500 24434709070000100 500 24434709080000202 500 PRAVDA DAVID A& TRACHTER ARLENE& GILL DONALD V 25 ROCKLEDGE AVE APT 1113 4746 S OCEAN BLVD APT 10 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 202 WHITE PLAINS NY 10601 1218 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5388 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5346 24434709070000010 500 24434709070000110 500 24434709080000203 500 SCHNELL GAYLE L DE MARCO DONNA GIAMMARELLA VITO& 121 HAROLD RD 4746 S OCEAN BLVD APT 7 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 203 WOODMERE NY 11598 1434 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5388 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5346 24434709070000020 500 24434709070000120 500 24434709080000204 500 CHIMIENTI NICHOLAS GRIESI RODRIGO& COTLER JENNIFER A 1510 SAINT PETERS AVE 4746 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 12 300 E 59TH ST BRONX NY 10461 3119 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5388 NEW YORK NY 10022 2061 24434709070000030 500 24434709080000101 500 24434709080000205 500 LUKENDA RICHARD JOSEPH KELVIN GEORGE V& BUDNEY HOLLY& 1003 GRAND CT 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 101 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 205 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5306 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5345 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5346 24434709070000040 500 24434709080000102 500 24434709080000206 500 VEROLA ROBERT& BOCA USA LLP URQUIDI MARILENA 8 WINCHESTER DR 756 SPADINA RD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 206 GLEN HEAD NY 11545 3203 TORONTO ONT HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5346 M5P 2X4 CANADA 24434709070000050 500 24434709080000103 500 24434709080000207 500 WINNERMAN SANFORD FISCHER MARTIN A& DILLON KEITH F& 4746 S OCEAN BLVD APT 5 254 E 68TH ST APT 28A 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 207 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5387 NEW YORK NY 10065 6017 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5346 24434709070000060 500 24434709080000104 500 24434709080000208 500 BRUNNER RONALD F& STETTNER JAMES W& HARRIS JUDY 4746 S OCEAN BLVD#6 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 104 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 208 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5387 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5345 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5347 24434709070000070 500 24434709080000105 500 24434709080000212 500 BARRA RICHARD K& PATEL RAJESHWAR N& ROMANO KENNETH T& 4746 S OCEAN BLVD APT 7 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 105 12619 COPPER MOUNTAIN PASS BOCA RATON FL 33487 5388 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5345 BOYNTON BEACH FL 33473 3605 24434709080000215 500 24434709080000312 500 24434709080000407 500 CAPRICE ROBERT C& BGE PROPERTIES LLC FELLIN CINDY PO BOX 2489 104 EMERSON RD 3959 SALLY LN VENTNOR CITY NJ 08406 0489 LONGMEADOW MA 01106 1814 OCEANSIDE NY 11572 5934 24434709080000216 500 24434709080000314 500 24434709080000408 500 MAC VEZZI CORP BIEBER EVELYN TRUST FELDMAN HELENE L TRUST& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 216 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 314 6414 MONTESITO ST BOCA RATON FL 33487 5347 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5349 BOCA RATON FL 33496 3200 24434709080000301500 24434709080000315 500 24434709080000409 500 MACCHIA ARLENE TRUST '" GUBBI SMITHA A& CHESTER RHODA 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 301 40 VAIL LN 4740 S OCEAN BLVD_,P-T 409 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5347 WATCHUNG NJ 07069 6150 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5351 24434709080000302 500 24434709080000316 500 24434709080000410 500 ROIDIS KATHY CAPLAN PAUL S TRUST LEVIN ALYSE 130 FAIRGLEN AVE 401 E 84TH ST#23A 130 EVERIT AVE SCARBOROUGH ON NEW YORK NY 10028 6271 HEWLETT NY 11557 2201 M1W 1A7 CANADA 24434709080000303 500 24434709080000401 500 24434709080000411 500 ROTH WILLIAM& FINKELSTEIN ALAN& BARON PERRY V ,.," 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 303 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 401 4740 S OCEAN BLVD-~APT.411 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5348 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5333 HIGH UAND'BEACH FL 33487 5351 24434709080000304 500 24434709080000402 500 24434709080000412 500 SIEGEL MARC N& SAPOZHNIK MIKHAIL& CINI JOHN& 932 ALTESSA BLVD 234 LAMONT BLVD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 412 MELVILLE NY 11747 5205 WINNIPEG MB HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5352 R3P OE9 CANADA 24434709080000305 500 24434709080000403 500 24434709080000414 500 SCHAFFER GERALD N& BEERE JAMI SCOTT LAWRENCE M & 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 305 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 403 12900 HALL RD STE 350 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5348 HIGHLAND-BEACH FL 33487 5350 STERLING HEIGHTS MI 48313 1174 24434709080000306 500 24434709080000404 500 24434709080000415 500 KRONENBERG ROBERT& BIBEN GAIL W GLUCK AUDREY E 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 306 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 404 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 415 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5348 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5350 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5352 24434709080000308 500 24434709080000405 500 24434709080000416 500 MILLER IRA& RECKARD DAVID C& WEISMAN JEROME E& 3411 BELTAGH AVE 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 405 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT'416 WANTAGH NY 11793 2557 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5350 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5352 24434709080000309 500 24434709080000406 500 24434709080000501 500 WOLFSON BRAEMER ISLE LLC KANDLER EDWARD& LAWSON MARIA C REVOCABLE TRUST 131 PARKWAY DR N 4740 S OCEAN BLVD#406 260 18TH ST APT 3 COMMACK NY 11725 4908 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5350 BROOKLYN NY 11215 5476 -mom (I jjv ) 3 I jfi7 ..._ 24434709080000502 500 24434709080000512 500 24434709080000607 500 MONKE ROGER K LIPUMA JOHN A& BLAU ROBERT& 1236 E EMPIRE ST STE 3 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 512 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 607 BLOOMINGTON IL 61701 3378 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5369 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5370 24434709080000503 500 24434709080000514 500 24434709080000608 500 NOBEL MURIEL R HEROUX LOUISE& CAMPBELL ZOEANN � :$~ 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 503 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 514 4740 S OCEAN BLVD AFT-608' HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5352 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5369 BOCA RAT0N-FL'33487 5370 24434709080000504 500 24434709080000515 500 24434709080000609 500 GRAHAM KALMAINE BENJAMIN DEBORAH GABRIEL MICHAEL& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 504 377 OAK ST 9801 SHORE RD APT 5A HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5352 GARDEN CITY NY 11530 6553 BROOKLYN NY 11209 7633 24434709080000505 500 24434709080000516 500 24434709080000610 500 VOGEL DOUGLAS A& FELDMAN JAFFA LEVIN ISADORA 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 505 1 OAKMONT CT 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 610 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5352 LIVINGSTON NJ 07039 8238 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5371 24434709080000506 500 24434709080000601 500 24434709080000611 500 STEIN REBECCA S BLOTNER PHYLLIS S AGRANATI SHLOMO& 49 WOODCHESTER DR 4740 S OCEAN BLVD-APT 601 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 611 CHESTNUT HILL MA 02467 1032 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5369 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5371 24434709080000507 500 24434709080000602 500 24434709080000612 500 DIMINO VINCENT J LIVING TRUST KLOTSAS ERACLES NAIMAN LEV& 81 BENEDICT RD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD'APT 602 4740 S OCEAN BLVDAPT612 STATEN ISLAND NY 10304 1203 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5369 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5371 24434709080000508 500 24434709080000603 500 24434709080000614 500 ROSENBLOOM EDITH R FINK PHYLLIS SHARMA RAJ K& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 508 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 603 4740 S OCEAN,BLVD APT 614 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5353 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5370 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5371 24434709080000509 500 24434709080000604 500 24434709080000615 500 KOREN ILAN& ROSENTHAL PHYLLIS TRUST& BRANOFF INVESTMENTS LTD 412 E WYNNEWOOD RD 15 HEREFORD LN 1500 O'CONNOR DR WYNNEWOOD PA 19096 1614 NEW CITY NY 10956 6606 TORONTO ON M4B 2T8 CANADA 24434709080000510 500 24434709080000605 500 24434709080000616 500 SUSSKIND KENNETH& RESNICK PAUL ROFFE JONAS RICHARDO ROSENBERG& 11011 FOREST OAK LN 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT.605 RAUL LABBE 12613 OF 403 GREAT FALLS VA 22066 3331 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5370 SANTIAGO CHILE 24434709080000511 500 24434709080000606 500 24434709080000701 500 BLAU CHARLES& MORRIS BEATRICE GOLDSTEIN ARTHUR M-Sw - 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 511 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 606 4740 SS 0� 1/D APT 701 BOCA RATON, 3-3487 5353 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5370 HIGH D BEACH FL 33487 5372 -,/24f I-,/- 24434709080000702 434709080000702 500 24434709080000712 500 24434709080000807 500 PANGAN RENATO PUTESKA JANET B ANNUNZIATA JAMES G& 11800 SUNSET HILLS RD UNIT 618 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 712 4740 S OCEAN B�3348775375 RESTON VA 20190 4783 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5373 HIGHLAN BEAC 24434709080000703 500 24434709080000714 500 24434709080000808 500 WYMAN SHELDON& FIRKSER KAPLAN FAMILY TRUST& HIRSCH EVELYN 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 703 3 ABRAMS PL 4740 S OCEAN BLVD-APT 808 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5372 NORTH YORK ON BOCA RATON FL 33487 5375 M2L 1W7 CANADA 24434709080000704 500 24434709080000715 500 24434709080000810 500 ROSE ANDREA TRUST DEMOSS BRIAN L& DONMACAR LTD 7284 W PALMETTO PARK RD STE 101 4740 S OCEAN BLVD'APT 715 200 LANSDOWNE AVE APT 602 BOCA RATON FL 33433 3406 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5374 WESTMOUNT QC H3Z 3EI CANADA 24434709080000705 500 24434709080000716 500 24434709080000811 500 GENDAL PHYLLIS RUBINSTEIN ARTHUR SCHWEIZER ALLEN H TRUST 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT'705 289 SCHOLES ST 253 W 72ND ST APT 415 HIGHLAND BEACH-'FL 33487 5372 BROOKLYN NY 11206 1730 NEW YORK NY 10023 2721 24434709080000706 500 24434709080000801 500 24434709080000812 500 KLEINER JUDY& YAGNISIS THEODORE MARCUS NEIL R& 4740 S OCEAN DLVD APT 706 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 801 209 LONETOWN RD HIGHLAND-BEACH FL 33487 5372 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5374 REDDING CT 06896 1504 24434709080000707 500 24434709080000802 500 24434709080000814 500 SIROTA GEORGE& SANDERSON ROBERT L& SHERIDAN JULIE A TRUST& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 707 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 802 65 BENTLEY CT BOCA RATON FL 33487 5373 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5374 DEERFIELD IL 60015 4873 24434709080000708 500 24434709080000803 500 2.4434709080000815 500 GOLDEN JACQUELYN TR FAIZILBERG LARISA .l00 WALTER DONALD JxF. "� 400 W 49TH TER# 2036 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 803 4740 S OCEAN BEND APT 815 KANSAS CITY MO 64112 2532 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5374 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5376 24434709080000709 500 24434709080000804 500 24434709080000816 500 407 4740 S OCEAN BLVD FLORIDA LAND TRUST CUOMO FRANK& PEISER EDITH S 4955 RIVERSIDE DR#1202 W 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 804 4740 S OCEAN,..BLVD UNIT 816 WINDSOR ON HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5374 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5376 N8Y 5A3 CANADA 24434709080000710 500 24434709080000805 500 24434709080000901 500 PANAYOTOPOULOS DEMETRIOS& ROSE JOSEPH B TRUST MURANIA JOAN E 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 710 7284 W PALMETTO PARK RD STE 101 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 901 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5373 BOCA RATON FL 33433 3406 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5376 24434709080000711 500 24434709080000806 500 24434709080000902 500 GLADSTONE JO-AN GOLDMAN WILLIAM DAVID--& PALMERI MICHELE& 241 PERKINS ST#J802 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 806 5 NICOLOSI DR BOSTON MA 02130 4082 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5375 STATEN ISLAND NY 10312 5847 /-50, 24434709080000903 500 24434709080000914 500 2,4434709080001008 500 EAGLE RONALD K TRUST& SELIS RUTH L FERGANG MELVILLE L TRUST 74 WELLESLEY CIR 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 914 201 E 42ND ST FL 8 NORTHBROOK IL 60062 1137 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5354 NEW YORK NY 10017 5720 24434709080000904 500 24434709080000915 500 24434709080001009 500 CHITTOOR SREENIVAS& AUER VON DER HAID MARIA G CARRACINO MARILYN 4825 CROOKED LN 2322 FRUITVALE AVE 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1009- DALLAS 009-DALLAS TX 75229 4214 OAKLAND CA 94601 2534 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5356 24434709080000905 500 24434709080000916 500 24434709080001010 500 THE SAMUELS SWEET VELIA TRUST GREENBERG STEVE& WOLF BETTYE S 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 96'5 17 WESTERLY DR 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1010 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5377 NEW CITY NY 10956 6652 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5356 24434709080000906 500 24434709080001001 500 24434709080001011 500 GARFIELD GARY& WASSERMAN DOROTHY SLATER ALAN& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 906 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1001 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 101 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5370 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5355 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5356 24434709080000907 500 24434709080001002 500 24434709080001012 500 ROTHMAN EMANUEL TRUST DVOR ARKADY& LATSKO JAMES 8 ROCKRIDGE LN 1480 GUNPOWDER RD 63 FLAGG CT STAMFORD CT 06903 4331 JENKINTOWN PA 19046 1209 STATEN ISLAND NY 10304 1157 24434709080000908 500 24434709080001003 500 24434709080001014 500 ROSEN STEVEN J& DRAPKIN ARNOLD H& GOBO ALTAIR M& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 908 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1003 122 OVERLOOK AVE HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5377 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5355 WAYNE NJ 07470 4328 24434709080000909 500 24434709080001004 500 24434709080001015 500 SENZON MITCHEL& BECK CHESTER ROSEN FRED M 154 FOXWOOD DR 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1004 4740 S OCEAN DLVD-20t 1015 JERICHO NY 11753 1122 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5355 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5357 24434709080000910 500 24434709080001005 500 24434709080001016 500 GOLDEN LEE& LEAFER MICHAEL H& HENICK GARY& 1118 SMITH MANOR BLVD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1005 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 1016 WEST ORANGE NJ 07052 4230 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5355 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5357 24434709080000911 500 24434709080001006 500 24434709080001101 500 SPATAFORA MATTED& MORSE PATRICIA H LABBE LOUIS THOMAS TRUST& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 911 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1006 ! 568 CHEMIN DYER BOCA RATON FL 33487 5354 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5355 SUTTON QC JOE 2KO CANADA 24434709080000912 500 24434709080001007 500 24434709080001102 500 FRADETTE GUY ZALAZNICK ARLYNE& MYERS TIMOTHY& 2003 DES ROSEAUX 400 E 56TH ST APT 26P 181 BEACH 137TH ST QUEBEC NEW YORK NY 10022 4339 FAR ROCKAWAY NY 11694 1329 G3E 1N1 CANADA /6 24434709080001103 500 24434709080001114 500 24434709080001208 500 BRISKIN BARBARA L FOX BONNIE GENOVESE D J& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1103 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 1114 3117 AVENUE M BOCA RATON FL 33487 5357 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5359 BROOKLYN NY 11210 4746 24434709080001104 500 24434709080001115 500 24434709080001209 500 JACOBSON ALLEN H SPARAPANI GARY& SMITH ARTHUR D 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT-1104 53 TEMPLAR RD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1209 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5358 ENGLISHTOWN NJ 07726 1727 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5361 24434709080001105 500 24434709080001116 500 24434709080001210 500 NEWFIELD KEITH& ROTHSTEIN JEFFERY A& HARKAVY HARRY& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1105 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT`1116 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1210 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5358 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5359 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5361 24434709080001106 500 24434709080001201 500 24434709080001211 500 WEBBER GERALD& MOLLICK SHEPPARD& SAELENS JOY D TRUST 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1106 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1201 4016 VENDOME DR HIGHLAND-BEACH FL 33487 5358 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5359 AUBURN HILLS MI 48326 1866 24434709080001107 500 24434709080001202 500 24434709080001212 500 SEITEL FRASER P& KOMACK ADAM STERNBERG STANLEY& 355 HARDENBURGH AVE 21 LUMBER RD APT 2F 25 ROCKLEDGE AVE APT 1013 DEMAREST NJ 07627 1314 ROSLYN NY 11576 2247 WHITE PLAINS NY 10601 1217 24434709080001108 500 24434709080001203 500 24434709080001214 500 SOLOWAY PETER& WERTHEIMER MARC TRUST REISS MARTIN& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1108 10011 GARY RD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1214 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5358 POTOMAC MD 20854 4110 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5361 24434709080001109 500 24434709080001204 500 24434709080001215 500 PHILLIPS MARY ANN BOKSER JOETTA BRAEMAR 1215 LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 1109 47 VICTORIA PL E 202 DEVON AVE HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5358 FORT LEE NJ 07024 1805 TOWN OF MT ROYAL QC H3R 1B7 CANADA 24434709080001110 500 24434709080001205 500 24434709080001216 500 FRISHMAN SCOTT H& EDEIKEN NICOLE J SOBEL WALTER& �4 >._ 165 SALEM RD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1205 4740 S OCEAN J3LVD A 7-fff6 ROSLYN HEIGHTS NY 11577 1518 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5360 HI HLAND BEACH FL 33487 5362 24434709080001111 500 24434709080001206 500 24434709080001401 500 CHIMERINE LAWRENCE& TRAMUTOLA THOMAS& DAVID EVALYN B 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 1111 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1206 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1401 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5359 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5360 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5362 24434709080001112 500 24434709080001207 500 24434709080001402 500 GURRIERI JAMES J& LERNER JOAN& HUTT PAUL TRUST& 3 WOODFIELD LN 6261 GRAYCLIFF DR APT C 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1402 GLEN HEAD NY 11545 2242 BOCA RATON FL 33496 3251 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5362 24434709080001403 500 24434709080001414 500 24434709080001508 500 JALENS ADELEIGNATIN JOEL D& FOOTE GARY& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT'1403 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1414 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1508',..& HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5362 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5381 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5382 24434709080001404 500 24434709080001415 500 24434709080001509 500 ZAMORA JOHN N& ARVID STENHUSEN& FOOTE GARY& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1404 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1415 22 ANN DR HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5362 BOCA-RATON FL 33487 5381 SYOSSET NY 11791 5904 24434709080001405 500 24434709080001416 500 24434709080001510 500 KALLMAN HAROLD& MILLS JAMES GERSTEL ROBERT& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1405 118 E 60TH ST 990 CORPORATE DR APT 233 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5362 NEW YORK NY 10022 1185 WESTBURY NY 11590 6719 24434709080001406 500 24434709080001501 500 24434709080001511 500 MARSHALL HELEN DRILLINGS ARLETTE ROTH MARTIN A& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1406 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1501 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1511 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5383 HIGfi,LAND BEACH FL 33487 5381 BOCA RATON.FL 33487 5378 24434709080001407 500 24434709080001502 500 24434709080001512 500 RUSSELL ROBERT W& BONTEMPO C ANGELA CAPUTO CHARLES A& 30 HALLOCK RD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1502 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1512 EAST QUOGUE NY 11942 4204 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5381 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5378 24434709080001408 500 24434709080001503 500 24434709080001514 500 GREENE HARVEY R& ROGE ROBERT H& ZOREF HAROLD& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1408 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1503 131 MOUNT AIRY RD S BOCA RATON FL 33487 5383 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5381 CROTON ON HUDSON NY 10520 2136 24434709080001409 500 24434709080001504 500 24434709080001515 500 PINES MICHAEL MILLER STEVEN B& STEIN CAREY& 140 8TH AVE APT 5B 2607 GLENN DR 1000 PORTWINE BROOKLYN NY 11215 1745 BELLMORE NY 11710 5027 DEERFIELD IL 60015 2433 24434709080001410 500 24434709080001505 500 24434709080001516 500 STOCK JERRY S&BONNIE REVOCABLE TRUST SCOTT EVELYN F TRUST KVIDERA DAGMAR E 1000 N LAKE SHORE PLZ APT 39B 18285 E TEN MILE RD 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1516 CHICAGO IL 60611 1512 ROSEVILLE MI 48066 5802 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5378 24434709080001411 500 24434709080001506 500 24434709080001601 500 GUTLON SUSAN SEIFER BLANCHE NASSAU BARBARA A 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1411 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1506 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1601 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5383 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5382 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5379 24434709080001412 500 24434709080001507 500 24434709080001602 500 LAROUCHE CHRISTIAN& WHITBRED HOWARD T GRATZ STEVEN D& 555 ARGYLE 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 1507 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1602 " WESTMOUNT QC BOCA RATON FL 33487 5382 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5379 H3Y 3B8 CANADA / ��; 24434709080001603 500 24434709080001614 500 24434709080001708 500 FLEISHMAN HARVEY R.&-`y . GREENBERG JOEL& SIMON BRUCE M& 4740 S OCEAN BLV6 UNIT 1603 727 MERION SQUARE RD 11133 MILL RUN fB!OCA�TON FL 33487 5379 GLADWYNE PA 19035 1505 HOPKINS MN 55305 3052 fw 24434709080001604 500 24434709080001615 500 24434709080001709 500 KRATZER CHARLES& ARONSON HOWARD M& MARKUS MICHELLE& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD,#1604 389 3RD ST 1056 5TH AVE APT 7A w,r' BOCA RATON FL'33487 5379 BROOKLYN NY 11215 2801 NEW YORK NY 10028 0112 24434709080001605 500 24434709080001616 500 24434709080001710 500 IANELLI JOSEPH J& MANTELLE MICHAEL& FORELL OLE& 80 PARK AVE 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 1616 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT LPH7 CAMBRIDGE MA 02138 4570 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5384 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5379 24434709080001606 500 24434709080001701 500 24434709080001711 500 PENN JAMES B& CAPLAN MARK& ADWAR HARRY& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# LPH6 F31-1321 SHERBROOKE W 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1711 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5379 MONTREAL HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5385 QUEBEC H3G 1J4 CANADA 24434709080001607 500 24434709080001702 500 24434709080001712 500 FELDMAN LINDA WEXLER STEPHEN TRUST SALZMAN SAMUEL TR& 1 WOOD AVENUE 230 LOCUST FENCE RD 124 DEL POND DR APT 1503 ST HELENA ISLAND SC 29920 3031 CANTON MA 02021 2748 WESTMOUNT,QUEBEC H3Z 3C5 CANADA 24434709080001608 500 24434709080001703 500 24434709080001714 500 LAZARCIUC MIRELA N WILLNER STEVEN J BRUNO SAM R TRUST& 1229 ST CLAIR AVE WEST 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1703 50 HIGH ST TORONTO ON HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5322 WEST HARRISON NY 10604 2830 M6E 1B5 CANADA 24434709080001609 500 24434709080001704 500 24434709080001715 500 DOLCE JOSEPH S HIGHLANDING INC SAKETK00 CARRIE 4740 S OCEAN BLVD# 1609 4740 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT 1704 40 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1715 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5380 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5322 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5386 24434709080001610 500 24434709080001705 500 24434709080001716 500 KLEIN NORMA PEARSON KAREN A& SPARAPANI GARY& 4740 S OCEAN BLVD APT 1610 4740 S OCEAN BLVD PH 5 53 TEMPLAR RD HIGHLAND BCH FL 33487 5380 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5385 ENGLISHTOWN NJ 07726 1727 24434709080001611 500 24434709080001706 500 24434709080031090 500 KAHAN DAVID TR LENTZ ROBERT& NAIDE FELICE& 560 KIRTS BLVD# 100 4740 S OCEAN BLVD # 1706 4744 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT C109 TROY MI 48084 4141 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5385 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5321 24434709080001612 500 24434709080001707 500 24434709080031100 500 IL KAGAN MAURICE I& MORSE LOVE LINSON IRIS D 1 ROMAR CRESCENT UNIT 1 400 CHAMBERS ST APT 24K 41 CLAIRMONT ST TORONTO ONTARIO NEW YORK NY 10282 0001 LONGMEADOW MA 01106 1001 M6B 1R7 CANADA 24434709080031110 500 24434709000020090 HODKIN ADAM 1006 GRAND COURT LLC 4744 S OCEAN BLVD APT 4 1001 RUE LENOIR STE A501 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5343 MONTREAL QC H4C 2Z6 CANADA 24434709080031120 500 LENNON MARTHA J TRUST 14105 SWEETBRIAR LN NOVELTY OH 44072 9786 24434709080031140 500 STRIANESE ANTHONY& 25 TALL OAK CRES SYOSSET NY 11791 1123 24434709080031150 500 BRICKEL JILL H REVOC TRUST 4744 S OCEAN BLVD UNIT C-115 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5321 24434709080032090 500 GILDEN SHELLYE A& 4744 S OCEAN BLVD#12 HIGHLAND BEACH FL 33487 5391 24434709080032100 500 COHAN ROBERT M 4744 S OCEAN BLVD APT 11 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5391 24434709080032110 500 PERDOMO ALBERTO J& 4744 S OCEAN BLVD APT C211 BOCA RATON FL 33487 5391 24434709080032120 500 POLANSKY SUSAN R& 440 INVERNESS LN LONGMEADOW MA 01106 2826 24434709080032140 500 M&L PARTNERS& 1120 PERRY HWY PITTSBURGH PA 15237 2113 24434709080032150 500 WEINSTEIN DAVID& 4744 S OCEAN BLVD PT C215 HIGHLAND,BE-ACF FL 33487 5343 MFG REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LLC VRABLE, JULIE 1010 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 MH & OL LLC TRONCONE, MONIQUE 55 NE 5TH AVENUE, 501 BOCA RATON, FL 33432 WOLFSON BRAEMER ISLE, LLC WOLFSON, HYMAN W 4740 SOUTH OCEAN BLVD #309 HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 PARKER HIGHLAND E. CONDO MERRIGAN, JONATHAN JAMES 4605 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 CARRON HOUSE CONDO ASSC. 4600 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 CARRON HOUSE CONDO ASSC. RYAN S. COPPLE, P.A. 11780 US HIGHWAY # 1 SUITE 105 NORTH PALM BEACH, FL 33408 622 BOCA DEVELOPMENT LLC 8 JONATHAN D LOUIS PA 7777 GLADES RD STE 315-B BOCA RATON, FL 33434 EVANTON BAYE TOWNHOMES 4746 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 EVANTON BAYE TOWNHOMES BARRA, RICHARD K 4400 PGA BOULEVARD, SUITE 603 PALM BEACH GARDENS, FL 33410 10/15/2020 Detail by Entity Name DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS Ii I .,d.o �.•��"""""rs rr/.t r,tf/If'f�1/Jtftt�(>�j�[.t!'lf�dt 'r�'��JJ'!td Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Search by Entity Name / Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company MFG REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LLC Filing Information Document Number L13000031475 FEI/EIN Number 46-2187519 Date Filed 03/01/2013 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event LC STMNT OF RA/RO CHG Event Date Filed 09/06/2016 Event Effective Date 07/11/2016 Principal Address 1010 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Changed: 09/06/2016 Mailing Address 1010 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Changed: 09/06/2016 Registered Agent Name&Address VRABLE, JULIE 1010 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Name Changed: 09/06/2016 Address Changed: 09/06/2016 Authorized Persons) Detail Name &Address Title MGRM Vrable, Julie 11988 SR 45 Lisbon, OH 44432 search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=Initial&searchNameOrder=MFGREALESTA... 1/2 10/15/2020 Detail by Entity Name DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS rg.� 00010` '"''"" "'"' fd!l r,jj r'gi1/.Ifflu C!f rrij!! f! 'r eb.jlfe Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Search by Entity Name / Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company BOAT SLIP 13 OF GRAND CAY ESTATES LLC Filing Information Document Number L14000132535 FEI/EIN Number N/A Date Filed 08/25/2014 Effective Date 08/23/2014 State FL Status ACTIVE Principal Address 1020 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Mailing Address 1020 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Registered Agent Name&Address BOROIAN, PATRICK J 1020 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Authorized Persons) Detail Name&Address Title AP BOROIAN, PATRICK J 1020 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Title AP BOROIAN, BONNIE W 1020 GRAND COURT HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/Corporation Search/SearchResu ltDetail?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=Initial&search NameOrder=BOATSLIP13GR... 1/2 10/15/2020 Detail by Entity Name rg Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Search by Entity Name / Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company MH &OL LLC Filing Information Document Number L11000129230 FEI/EIN Number 45-3807121 Date Filed 11/14/2011 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event LC AMENDMENT AND NAME CHANGE Event Date Filed 11/28/2011 Event Effective Date NONE Principal Address 55 NE 5TH AVENUE 501 BOCA RATON, FL 33432 Changed: 01/24/2018 Mailing Address 55 NE 5TH AVENUE 501 BOCA RATON, FL 33432 Registered Agent Name&Address TRONCONE, MONIQUE 55 NE 5TH AVENUE 501 BOCA RATON, FL 33432 Authorized Persons} Detail Name&Address Title MGR TRONCONE, MONIQUE 55 NE 5TH AVENUE 501 BOCA RATON, FL 33432 Annual Reports search.sun biz.org/Inquiry/Corporation Search/Search ResultDetail?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=Initial&searchNameOrder=MHOL L1100012... 1/2 10/15/2020 Detail by Entity Name DTVI IOiV OF I.ORPORATIONS fill Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Search by Entity Name / Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company WOLFSON BRAEMER ISLE, LLC Filing Information Document Number L10000048858 FEI/EIN Number 90-0648064 Date Filed 05/06/2010 State FL Status ACTIVE Principal Address 4740 S. OCEAN BLVD., UNIT 309 HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Mailing Address 131 PARKWAY DR N COMMACK, NY 11725 Changed: 01/13/2011 Registered Agent Name&Address WOLFSON, HYMAN W 4740 SOUTH OCEAN BLVD#309 HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Name Changed: 01/28/2013 Address Changed: 01/28/2013 Authorized Person(q) Detail Name&Address Title MGR WOLFSON, HYMAN W 4740 S. OCEAN BLVD., UNIT 309 HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Title MGR WOLFSON, DEBORAH S search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetaiI?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=Initial&searchNameOrder=WOLFSONBRA... 1/2 10/15/2020 Detail by Entity Name DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS rg I J Irlt(Of'!ft!.)!!11!+r;f�1fll'!d_+! Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Search by Entity Name / Detail by Entity Name Florida Not For Profit Corporation PARKER HIGHLAND EAST CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. Filing Information Document Number 756643 FEI/EIN Number 59-2084837 Date Filed 03/06/1981 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event REINSTATEMENT Event Date Filed 12/31/1987 Principal Address 4605 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BCH, FL 33487-5323 Changed: 04/21/2008 Mailing Address 4605 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BCH, FL 33487-5323 Changed: 04/21/2008 Registered Agent Name&Address MERRIGAN, JONATHAN JAMES 4605 S. OCEAN BLVD. HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487-5323 Name Changed: 04/02/2019 Address Changed: 04/21/2008 Officer/Director Detail Name &Address Title Director, President SOOJIAN, WAYNE 4605 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BCH, FL 33487-5323 search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=lnitial&searchNameOrder=PARKERHIGHL... 1/3 10/15/2020 Detail by Entity Name �t'll;�If)�l`i orf `F.ON P�t �-'fir{"(�� jinn// 1h (ul t,!!.%wifi,/.lflls'ri{i litf;lr+ -A' b j?!e Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Search by Enti y Name / Detail by Entity Name Florida Not For Profit Corporation CARRON HOUSE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. Filing Information Document Number 754133 FEI/EIN Number 59-2209122 Date Filed 09/11/1980 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event REINSTATEMENT Event Date Filed 02/14/2011 Principal Address 4600 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BCH, FL 33487-5390 Changed: 05/18/1984 Mailing Address 4600 S OCEAN BLVD HIGHLAND BCH, FL 33487-5390 Changed: 05/18/1984 Registered Agent Name&Address RYAN S. COPPLE, P.A. 11780 US Highway# 1 Suite 105 North Palm Beach, FL 33408 Name Changed: 10/24/2011 Address Changed: 03/01/2017 Officer/Director Detail Name&Address Title President Jagernauth, Madan 4600 S OCEAN BLVD #502 search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetaiI?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=Initial&searchNameOrder=CARRONHOUS... 1/3 10/15/2020 Detail by Entity Name iJ I i S M I•J iy a-- /,.org Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Search by Enity Name / Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company 622 BOCA DEVELOPMENT, LLC Filing Information Document Number L15000190160 FEI/EIN Number 81-4587984 Date Filed 11/10/2015 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event REINSTATEMENT Event Date Filed 12/05/2016 Principal Address 4600 SOUTH OCEAN BLVD UNIT 101 HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33486 Changed: 02/03/2020 Mailing Address 8 BARSTOW RD APT 2A GREAT NECK, NY 11021 Registered Agent Name&Address JONATHAN D LOUIS PA 7777 GLADES RD STE 315-B BOCA RATON, FL 33434 Name Changed: 12/05/2016 Authorized Persons} Detail Name&Address Title MGRM LEVINE, BARRY 8 barstow rd apt 2a great neck, NY 11021 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResu]tDetaiI?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=Initial&searchNameOrder=622BOCADEVE... 1/2 SUN-SENTINEL Sold To: Town of Highland Beach Florida-CU00661788 3614 S Ocean Blvd Highland Beach FL 33487,FL 33487-3393 Bill To: Town of Highland Beach Florida-CU00661788 3614 S Ocean Blvd Highland Beach FL 33487,FL 33487-3393 Published Daily Fort Lauderdale,Broward County,Florida Boca Raton,Palm Beach County,Florida Miami,Miami-Dade County,Florida State Of Illinois County Of Cook Before the undersigned authority personally appeared Charlie Welenc,who on oath says that he or she is a duly authorized representative of the SUN-SENTINEL, a DAILY newspaper published in BROWARD/PALM BEACH/MIAMI-DADE County,Florida;that the attached copy of advertisement,being a Legal Notice in: The matter of 11745-Other Legal Notices, Town of Highland Beach Florida Thursday,Nov 12,2020 9:30am Was published in said newspaper in the issues of;Nov 02,2020 Affiant further says that the said SUN-SENTINEL is a newspaper published in said BROWARD/PALM BEACH/MIAMI-DADE County,Florida,and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said BROWARD/PALM BEACH/MIAMI-DADE County, Florida,each day and has been entered as second class matter at the post office in BROWARD County, Florida,for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that he or she has neither paid nor promised,any person,firm or corporation,any discount,rebate,commission or refund,for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. Signature of Affiant Sworn to and subscribed before me this: November 05,2020. RECEIVE® Signature of Notary Public N O V 10 2020 Town of Highland Beach, FL Town Clerk's Office llll:y commission.Expires Hav"ler 23,2020 Name of Notary,Typed,Printed,or Stamped Personally Known(X)or Produced Identification( ) Affidavit Delivery Method:U.S.Mail Affidavit Email Address: 6795858 SUN-SENTINEL TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH PUBLIC HEARING YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that the Plan- ning Board of the Town of HighlandBeach will conduct a public hearing on Thursday, November 12,2020 at 9:30 XM,in the Commission chambers at Town Hall, 3614 South ocean Boulevard,Highland Beach,Florida to consider the fallowing application APPLICATION NO 20.0014—REQUESTING AN AMENDMENT TO.A PREVIOUSLY AP- PROVED TEN POST PLATFORM BOAT LIFT (APPLICATION NO.39412)IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE HEIGHT OF THE BOAT LIFT FOR THE PROPERTY LOC,ATEDAT 1O06 GRAND COURT. APPLICANT;RICHARD TOUCHETTE DUG to the centers for Disease control and Prevention(CDC)social distancing requirements,to attend the meeting,all interested'persons roust preregister by contacting the T +rn clerk's Office at pu!b- IiccommentschighlandbeachmS 24 hours prig to the meeting date. The application is available for inspection in the Town clerk's office atTicyrn Hall, Monday through Friday during normal business hours of 8:30 a.rn.to 4;30 Piro Any parson that decides to appeal any decision made by the Town Commission with respect to any matter considered at thi's meeting,,such person will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made,which includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based, The Town of Highland Beach does not provide such a r e rd., In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities AM persons who need special accommodation to attend or participate in this meeting should contact the Town clerk's office at(561)278-4548 at least 48 fours prior to the meeting, If you are hearing or speech Impaired,please con- tact the Florida Relay service at 1-800- 955-8770 or 1-800-955-8771. For additional information,please contact the Town Planner at(561)637-2012, TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH, BUILDING DEPARTMENT 11/2/2020 6795858 Order#-6795858