Loading...
2008.03.25_TC_Minutes_SpecialTOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH MINUTES OF TOWN COMMISSION MEETING SPECIAL MEETING TuesdayT March 25, 2008 3:30 P.M. Mayor Jim Newill called the Special Meeting to order in Commission Chambers at 3:30 P.M. CALL TO ORDER: Roll Call: Members present: Mayor Jim Newill, CPA; Vice Mayor Miriam S. Zwick; Commissioner Doris M. Trinley; Commissioner John J. Sorrelli: Town Attorney Thomas E. Sliney; Town Manager Dale S. Sugerman; Town Clerk Beverly M. Brown and members of the public. . 1) PUBLIC COMMENTS Joseph Colby -Villa Costa While selecting a new Commissioner, recommend that you take in consideration the amount of volunteer time already donated to the Town. 2) SELECTION OF COMMISSIONER -One-Year Vacancy Mayor Newill stated that he had requested the Deputy Clerk to review past records to see which potential candidates had previously served on a Board within the Town. The Town Clerk will read the names of the individuals and he will state whether they had previously served on a Town Board. A) Review of Letters of Intent: John J. Pagliaro -Served two terms on Code Enforcement Board Karen Finkelstein -Resident Lucy Whalen Miller -Serving second term on Beaches & Shores Shepard D. Osherow -Resident Anthony P. Ruotolo -Serving second term on Board of Adjustment Joseph Yucht -Presently serving on Planning and Boca Raton Airport Authority Advisory Board, previously served on Charter Review • Judith Asselta -Resident Town Commission Special Meeting Minutes March 25 2008 Page 2 of 3 • B) Nominations by Commissioners: None C) Voting by Ballot Ballot #1 Results: John J. Pagliaro - 2 Votes Lucy Whalen Miller - 2 Votes Ballot #2 Results: John J. Pagliaro - 2 Votes Lucy Whalen Miller - 2 Votes Ballot #3 Results: John J. Pagliaro - 2 Votes Lucy Whalen Miller - 2 Votes Ballot #4 Results: John J. Pagliaro - 2 Votes Lucy Whalen Miller - 2 Votes • At this point, Lucy Whalen Miller and John J. Pagliaro both gave a brief synopsis of their history and volunteerism within the Town of Highland Beach. Ballot #5 Results: John J. Pagliaro - 3 Votes Lucy Whalen Miller - 1 Vote John J. Pagliaro was appointed Commissioner to complete the one-year vacancy. 3) OATH OF OFFICE ADMINISTERED TO CONIlVIISI50NER PAGLIARO Town Clerk Beverly M. Brown administered the Oath of Office to Commissioner John J. Pagliaro. Commissioner Pagliaro signed the Oath of Office which is attached as part of this file. Commissioner Pagliaro assumed his seat on the dais. 4) PUBLIC CONIlVIENTS • No additional comments were received r~ U Town Commission Special Meeting Minutes March 25, 2008 Pa eg 3 of 3 • 9) ADJOURNMENT There being no further business to come before the Commission, Mayor Newill adjourned the Special Meeting at 3:40 P.M. upon a MOTION by Commissioner Pagliaro and seconded by Commissioner Sorrelli to adjourn. APPROVE: Jim Ne/uvill, CPA, Mayor ice ~`_ ~ n U Attest: ~~ ~ Beverly M rown~MMC Town Clerk ~iis Doris M. Trinley, Commissioner OATH OF OFFICE TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH, FLORIDA n U 1, ~~h ~ /ail ~¢.~ DO SOLEMNLY SWEAR THAT I WILL SUPPORT, PROTECT AND DEFEND THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES AND OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA AGAINST ALL ENEMIES, DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN, AND THAT I WILL BEAR TRUE FAITH, LOYALTY AND ALLEGIANCE TO THE SAME, AND THAT I AM ENTITLED TO HOLD OFFICE UNDER THE CONSTITUTION OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, AND THAT 1 WILL FAITHFULLY PERFORM ALL THE DUTIES OF THE OFFICE OF COMMISSIONER IN THE TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH, ON WHICH I AM TO ENTER, SO HELP ME GOD. ~~~ OATH OF OFFICE ADMINISTERED THIS 25th DAY OF MARCH, 2008 AT TOWN HALL, TOWN OF HIGHLAND BEACH. FLORIDA. Beverly .Brown Town Clerk/Notary ~rio~ M'~Mw~rr2,lNt ~a,a, ~ G°""'n'u"' ~ o0 6one.d?Mo~,~~ • ~° V 2901 S. Ocean Blvd., #905 Highland Beach, FL 33487 l~Iarch 18, 2008 Highland Beach Town Commission 3614 South Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FIJ 33487 Attn: Beverly Brown, Town Clerk • I wish to submit my name as a candidate for the one year vacancy scat on the Town Commission. Enclosed please find my resume. _a~y ,. --...~, ,. , __~ ~ ~ ~; John J. Pagliaro :J John J. Pagliaro 2901 S. Ocean Blvd Highland Beach, FL i ~ 11~f.~ I received degrees from New York University, a Bachelor of Science in 1956 and a Master of Arts in 197 and became a high school American History teacher and Departmental Administrative Assistant at the Wheatley School in East Williston, NY. 1967- 1969 Vice President of the East Williston Teacher's Association 1969-1971 President East- Williston teacher's Association 1987=1990 Treasurer and then President of Pebble Beach Farms Home Owners Association in East Marion, NY, 1988-1993 I pursued a second career in the real estate business. I co-managed an off ce with my wife, Gerry, for five years, in one of the tap firms on the North Fork of Long Island. 1994-1998 President of the Tides a subdivision of Newport Bay in Boca Raton. 1996-1999 Arbitrator on the Dispute Settlement Board in Fort Lauderdale resolving Lemon Law disputes. 1999-2001 Secretary/Treasurer of the Board of Directors of Highland Place in Highland Beach, 2003 to present I have been a turtle volunteer, recording, and rescuing. turtles. I have a close relationship with the Gumbo Limbo center. My wife and I lived in West Boca for five years and have been living in Highland- Beach for nine years. I have recently completed two terms on the Code Enforcement Board in Highland $each, one year as Vice Chairman and three years as chairman. n L.J • n LJ March 19, 2008 Karen Finkelstein 4300 South Ocean Boulevard Apt. 4 Highland Beach, FL 33487 ~~d ~~ To: Mayor Newill, Vice Mayor Zwick, and Town Commissioners of Highland Beach My name is Karen Finkelstein. I would like to apply to the opening you have on the Town Commission. I have lived in the Town of Highland Beach since July, 2005. Prior to living in Highland Beach, I have lived in South Florida since June, 1989. I have been continuously employed in the Boca Raton area since January, 1990, and within that time period I have been a financial aid adviser at Lynn University; the University Residency Coordinator at Florida Atlantic University, and currently I work in the College of Science at FAU, helping students who are trying to get into medical, dental and/or veterinary programs after graduation from FAU. I have been a mentor at both Lynn University and Florida Atlantic University, where I was Mentor of the Year in 1996/97. I hold a BA degree from Lynn University in Behavioral Science (awarded June, 1995), Magna Cum Laude. I worked full-time and attended college at the same time, earning my BA degree in 4 years, which was quite an achievement considering I was working full-time, going to school during my lunch hours, in the evenings and even on Saturdays, and was still able to be a wife, mother, and a main care-taker of an elderly, sick mother. I tell you this because I feel that (this) shows that I can be part of the commission even while working at my full time position at FAU. Although I have no political experience per se, I have held offices in various organizations over the years, starting as a PTA President at the Seaman Neck Elementary School in Seaford, NY, PTA Treasurer at Gen. Douglas MacArthur High School (Levittown, NY), and in Florida I served on the HOA Boards at the Ashley Park AD-Hoc Committee (Boca Raton), the Ashley Park Homeowners Association (Executive Board), and the HOA Board of Directors at Town Place in Boca Raton. Highland Beach is our home. I live here with my husband Marty, and our dog, Luka. Luka is a West Highland Terrier - I call him a "West Highland Beach Terrier'. I would like to see Highland Beach on the right track now that we have a new mayor. I would • like to see our Commission represent the town, and be responsive to the people of Highland Beach. A new start. For a long time, we had animosity on the Board, and a snarly Vice Mayor who thought he was above the intelligence of the residents .who helped put him on the Board. Hopefully that era is over, and we can begin anew. I'd like to be part of that, or at the very least, know that the person who is chosen as a commissioner comes to the table with a new perspective and a fresh attitude, with the idea that they are there to serve the town, not the other way around. Highland Beach needs and deserves that! Thank you for your time and patience. Respectfully, t# y Karen Finkelstein (561) 274-3575 (home) (561) 297-3307 (work) r~ LJ • . Lucy E. Whalen Miller • 3301 South Ocean Boulevard, Apt. 506 Highland Beach, FL 33487 561-278-7456 561-251-2498 (Cell) n U March 20, 2008 Beverly Brown Town Clerk Town of Highland Beach Highland Beach, FL 33487 Dear Beverly, K3.'~~ ~' a~ ~~ /~ ,. I wish to express my interest in being appointed to the open position of commissioner for the Town of Highland Beach which was vacated by Miriam Zwick's appointment to the position of Vice Mayor. Please convey my willingness, availability, and intent to Mayor Jim Newiil and the Commission. If there is anything further required, please so advise. Sincerely, Lucy E. Whalen Miller • ~~ a8 ~~6~I. SS -1-~ ~ ~ 6 ~~ ~~~~ ~ 2 ~~. ~~°~ ~~, ~ ~~ ~~.~; ID'S ~ a ~.~ ~j .T,~~-', . c-~~- ~~ ~~~-~~ ~i~~~~ ~~F~ ~~~~~~ ~` '~~~ s ~~~~~~ ~~~ ~~s ~ ~~J ~~ i ~ ` o, ~ ~ ~ T z .~ ~ ~ , ~ ~~~-~~ ~ ~` ~ ~~ e -ems ~~ ~ ~S a ~-~. ~ ~, K ~-- // `~ ~~ ~~~ ~ f 'tJ /~ ~ ~~ ~~.2 ~ ~ G ~ ~~ ~ U~ ~ ~ ~, ~! ~C Q vV~ -~ ~~~~~ - 3/~~~i~ ~~ ~~ LETTER OF INTEREST FOR VACANCY ON HIGHLAND BEACH BOARD OF • COMMISSIONERS: NAME: JUDITH A. ASSELTA ADDRESS: 3450 S. Ocean Blvd. #LPH3, Highland Beach, FL 33487 YEARS IN HIGHLAND BEACH: 33. Permanent Resident - 8 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE: Graduate St. John's University School of Education, BS 1963, MS 1970 Teacher Grades 1-8 Served on Garden City Board of Trustees for 9 years as a Trustee and Deputy Mayor. During those years I had the additional duties of: Commissioner of Finance - 1 yr -Overseeing Budget Commissioner of Building & Zoning - 2 yrs -Overseeing Code revisions and major development projects Commissioner of Police - 1 yr Commissioner of Recreation - 2 yrs -Participated with Town Manager in selection of a new head for the Department and oversaw the reconstruction of the Town's Indoor Tennis Courts Commissioner of Public Works - 2 yrs -Oversaw the implementation of • the Downtown Revitalization Plan. Previously had chaired the Mayor's Committee that developed the plan. Fire Commissioner - 1 yr Currently a Florida Realtor with ReMax Advantage Plus VOLUNTEER POSITIONS Leader of a Statewide Coalition of Homeowners New York, successfully negotiated a compromise with homeowners and State Legislature on a solution to impacts of Full Value Assessment. NY Times printed my explanation of the proposed law as an editorial, identifying my role in the development of the law. Stanley Fink, Democrat, Leader of the Assembly honored my involvement by inviting me onto the floor of the Assembly for passage of the law. NY State Chairperson Coalition of Peace Through Strength NY State Chairperson Conservative Caucus Chairperson Garden City Fund for Environmental Preservation, Garden City, NY. My Co-Chairperson was TV Columnist, Bill Moyers -Raised over $100,000 and successfully stopped the over development of Garden City. • Served as President, Vice-President, Secretary ,Central Property Owners Association, Garden City, NY representing over 800 households and the downtown business district. Page 2 President Garden City League of Mercy Hospital Received the Pius X Medal from the Diocese of Rockville Centre for years teaching religious education. Chaimerson, The Committee for the Preservation of the Integrity of Highland Beach formed a coalition of property owners in Highland Beach to stop the development of the Hoffmann property south of Toscana. . Casuarina Condominium Association Highland Beach: President, current, Treasurer, 8 months, Boazd Member -past 12 months, Building Chair -oversaw bid selection for shutter replacement and window and sliding glass door replacement damaged by Wilma. Member St. Lucy Church, Highland Beach, 33 years OBJECTNES IF SELECTED: I feel that the primary duty of the Board is to maintain the quality of our beautiful Town within the bounds of fiscal responsibility and to ensure that development stays within the bounds of our current zoning. My entire life's work has been bringing together people of diverse opinions for a common • good. If selected I will apply those life skills to my position as Commissioner. .G Judith A. Asselta . CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht Q • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 BALLOT # • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER • (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller ~, Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 BALLOT # n U CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (En order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Q Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judi#h J. Asselta Q 0 ~~~ CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER • (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 0 0 BALLOT # ~~ ~ 4 • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta Q BALLOT # ~. 0 • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 BALLOT # 0 • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 0 ~~ BALLOT # • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht Judith J. Asselta D 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 BALLOT # ~lr"(~Y~•l~i'V~, ~I /'A/~{'1 li/ ~Y ~l!'!/I/" =o~~~~-G"`A"~'--- Town of Hi bland Beach ''* i ~: ' a •ni ~~i~ •• ~• APPLICATION FOR 90ARD/COMMISSION APPOINTMENT -1~~~pfLOplOp =~ ~~ ~ ~~~ NAME : ~~~~~~ ~ Lf0??>?>~D PHONE NO . ~ ! ~ Z,~« (Home) ADDRESS : ~ Mr. Anthony Ruotolo 3400 S. Ocean Blvd. Apt. ] 4L Highland Beach, FL 33487-2549 1. How long have you lived here? Z. 3. ~. 5. • Are you a full time resident? Are you a registered voter? Educational 198a t ~. S. ~~~~ ~~ PleasQ li t 1la~. ~aK .~ y~s background: T~ ~~ e ~~ ~~ ~~~ sz ,Xf' s' ~ - ~csT- ,v ~ ,,,,' ~ / X68' r• Y R~~ ,~ ~.c.~ssEs.~ r ,.ytD ~ c. ~N-GD+H~ ra4 +~~C~/S .~Y.~rC~,+~lT'f~~i~~~!/1~L t ~ w~ ' PTeass-"3."is£"" hob ies'"8r otFie=" area o into=est: ~~ ~/li'~,~ ~iY~S ,~,[l~Y,,~~Tt3~,.~o~tLtfzil,~:~Jd~ ,c,~rE 7~f~i Fs sQ~YD +9 ev~sN~t~ ~E'~D~,,Q fi . What is the -~3wa~d-tCommission. of your choice? ~f~~Y ~~?s,~l~,S,S~O,~ Describe briefl wh ~~ y y you wish to serve: -~~ /PG~~fr ~ t ,rte /~ ~ L ~_~r-~st2's~SD o t~<6:aiPltGl.sLf~ ~ir~sst~ ~IrS SGI~tsE~ Y 7. Do you understand that absence from 3 consecutive , Meetings after appointment will be considered as .resignation subject to automatic acceptance? ~,E'.S 8. Would you have any appointed? ~_ limitations on attendance If so, please describe; _ ~-•-'" 9. How many meetings of your preferr d rd have ~~''u attended in the past three (3 ars?~ ~/~ ~ ~~~l~e:7%l'~>~7~/!~~,~'" ~r 10. Do you understand the duties and responsibilities of the Board or Comm ~ c you are requesting a ointment? Signature f Applicant Date - (Work) APT. N0. !'~j~~..- ~~`' es ~s ~s ems` Gl,~,~,~' ,/%~ rlo,~s. Gls'~ at meetings if ~„- ~t%a * * * * * * * * RESUMES ARE INVITED TO B£ ATTACHED * * * * * * ' ; • JOSEPH S. YUCHT ~ ~ Z~Q~ 4748 S. OCEAN BLVD., #7B HIGHLAND BEACH, FL 33487 Phone (561) 367 - 0700 Mazch 20, 2008 Mayor and Town Commissioners Town of Highland Beach 3614 South Ocean Boulevard Highland Beach, FL 33487 Gentlemen and ladies: This letter is in response to a request made by the Town Commission for the submission of letters of interest in being appointed to the Town Commission. Yes, I am interested in being so appointed. I think that each and everyone knows who I am. I have been a resident of this • Town for more than ten (10) years and during that time I have attended almost all of the Commission's workshop and regular meetings. At many of those meetings I have had the privilege of addressing the Commission. I am proud to state that many of my suggestions have been adopted into practice and are part and pazcel of the Town's procedure. During my residency I have served on the following Town "Boards": Welcome Committee, Charter Review Board, Board of Adjustment and Appeals, Planning Board, Boca Raton Airport Authority Noise Abatement Committee, and the Boca Raton Airport Authority Advisory Committee. It has been my pleasure to serve on these Boazds. I have had a weahh of experience in the operation and functioning of government. I served as a state attorney for the Delawaze State Senate for 7 years; was acting director of the Legislative Council of the State of Delaware for 1 1/2 years; served as a member and President of the New Castle County Board of Elections for 4 years; was a member of the Tax Appeal Board of the State of Delaware for 19 years and chairman thereof for 16 years; and last but not least I was a Master {Judge} in the Family Court of the State of Delaware for 3 years. I am a fiscal conservative when it comes to spending. I believe that government should spend what it can afford to spend and not what it wants to spend. • Mayor and Town Commissioners March 20, 2008 Page 2 For your additional information, I have attached hereto a copy of my biography. I am proud of my career to date and know that I can be of assistance to this Town by serving on the Town Commission. Thank you. Respectfully, ~~ a Joseph S. cht Enclosure v • n U • JOSEPH S. YUCHT, ESQUIRE (RETIRED) BIOGRAPHY Permanent full time resident since January 1998 - 4748 S. Ocean Blvd., Apt. 7B, Boca Highlands, Highland Beach, FL 33487 Prior residence -Wilmington, Delaware Occuaation -retired Attorney -State of Delaware Date of birth -October 7,1929 Marital status -married 53 years to Rene Yucht, retired State of Delaware Law Librarian Children - 3 married with 2 grandchildren ReGaious affiliation -Jewish Military service - U.S. Air Force 1951-1953 College education -Univ. of Delaware, B.S. degree; Temple University School of Law, J.D. (LLB) degree Business eguerience -Practiced law in the State of Delaware from Apri1,1963 to October 30,1997 - Owned and operated a retail store in Delaware Public Eaaerience -Master in Family Court of the State of Delaware -1964-1967 Attorney for the Delaware State Senate -1967 to 1974 Acting Director Delaware Legislative Reference Bureau Member of the Board of Elections for New Castle County - • 1969 to 1973 President of Board of Elections for New Castle County - 1969 to 1973 Member of Tag Appeal Board of the State of Delaware - 1974 to 1993 Chairman of Tag Appeal Board of the State of Delaware - 1977 to 1993 Delaware Court trained Mediator and Arbitrator Moot Court Judge and Lecturer at Delaware Law School Lecturer on the legislative process in Delaware Member of committee that redrafted Delaware election laws Lecturer for Delaware Continuing Legal Education Attorney for Retail Liquor Dealers Association in Delaware Attorney for Delaware Republican Party in election cases Attorney for two (2) Delaware Volunteer Fire Companies Attorney for Delaware Kidney Fund ,Inc. Attorney for Brandywine Country Club in Delaware Activities - Member and President of Pilot Home and School Association; Active in Little League baseball and basketball; Volunteer member Minquas Fire Company Delaware - 59 yrs • United Fund solicitor; • Member of Congregation of Temple Beth Emeth, Wilmington, Delaware; Member and Director of Brandywine Country Club, Delaware Member of Jewish Community Center, Wilmington, DE; Member of Board of Directors of Delaware Kidney Fund Inc. Member of Board of Directors of Delaware Valley Chapter of National Hemophilia Foundation. Highland Beach Activities -Active Volunteer at Boca Raton Community Hospital; Former Bond owner of Ocean Breeze Country Club Former member of Highland Beach Board of Adjustment; Former member of Highland Beach Charter Review Committee; Member of Boca Raton Airport Authority Noise Compatibility Committee for Highland Beach; Former member of Highland Beach Welcome Committee Member of Delray Beach Fire Company C.E.R.T.; Regular attendee and participant in Town Commission Meetings.. Present Member of the Town of Highland Beach's Planning Board. Pleasures - Spending quality time with my grandchildren, travel, sports, computers, music, photography and politics. Condo Activities - Member of Board of Directors for Dalton Place Condo Former Vice-President of Condo Board Former Chairman of Rules and Credentials Committee; Former member of the Board of the Boca Highlands Center. • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 0 BALLOT # • • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 au~o.. 3 • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 BALLOT # 0 .r- 0 • • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 0 0 ~'~- G~ BALLOT # • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 ~~ ~~ BALLOT # . CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 0 BALLOT # i2~G /L '~ ~~~~~~ • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 BALLOT # • • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER BALLOT# (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht Q • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht • Judith J. Asselta 0 0 BALLOT # • • CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow Anthony P. Ruotolo Joseph S. Yucht . Judith J. Asselta BALLOT # ~ ~~~~~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CANDIDATES FOR COMMISSIONER (In order that they were received) [7 John J. Pagliaro Karen Finkelstein Lucy Whalen Miller Shepard D. Osherow BALLOT # Anthony P. Ruotolo ~ F Joseph S. Yucht Judith J. Asselta 0 0 0 0 I•